Scan barcode
exquisite_tragedy's review against another edition
3.0
Even with the sketchy premise, these characters are just so endearing I have to keep reading.
raine_rki's review
hopeful
relaxing
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
rereader33's review against another edition
5.0
Okay, I have to give this volume five stars as it is easily the BEST volume in the series so far. Everyone was enjoyable, I got see some characters in a new light, and this current arc may very well be the best yet. I have to say, the Chairman really surprised me, in a good way. It isn't odd for characters like him to leave a family member penniless to teach them a lesson, but it made perfect sense in the context of the story. Takane is treated horribly by his family for being the heir, though they believe he is undeserving of it (really they just want the title themselves, but whatever). In order to make Takane prove his worth, the Chairman wants him to climb his way back to the top, and what I love is that the Chairman truly believes he can do this. If there is one thing Takane is constantly praised for, it's his hard work. This is validated when readers get to see him staying late, going to meetings, and genuinely pushing himself to be the best because he has to in order to maintain his standing. The Chairman's actions may be harsh, but they are not unrealistic, and I truly love that about this scenario.
Takane's behavior once he loses his wealth is also interesting, as it is more in keeping with his character than most in his situation. Readers know that Takane has an aversion to commoner things (though he's gotten better with Hana's help) and is easily sickened or weakened over hurt pride/things outside of his small comfort zone. Being forced to work in such a "crude" environment with only what is absolutely necessary is devastating to him and explains his pathetic behavior and attitude. I also enjoyed Hana's take on the situation as well. I found it refreshing that she initially tried to see Takane's circumstances and his rebuff from a logical perspective, but was told to view it from how Takane has been treating her. Ordinarily I would side with Hana's logical conclusion, but Okamon's advice rings more true in this situation (side note, thank you Okamon for finally doing something of actual value! Yay!). Takane has been disrespecting Hana's privacy and personal time whenever he feels like it, why shouldn't she? Why should his circumstance leave her out of the picture, especially after all the time they've shared? Seriously, the ending of the volume was absolutely brilliant and I loved loved loved it! I can't wait for volume 7, I want to see where this arc goes!
Takane's behavior once he loses his wealth is also interesting, as it is more in keeping with his character than most in his situation. Readers know that Takane has an aversion to commoner things (though he's gotten better with Hana's help) and is easily sickened or weakened over hurt pride/things outside of his small comfort zone. Being forced to work in such a "crude" environment with only what is absolutely necessary is devastating to him and explains his pathetic behavior and attitude. I also enjoyed Hana's take on the situation as well. I found it refreshing that she initially tried to see Takane's circumstances and his rebuff from a logical perspective, but was told to view it from how Takane has been treating her. Ordinarily I would side with Hana's logical conclusion, but Okamon's advice rings more true in this situation (side note, thank you Okamon for finally doing something of actual value! Yay!). Takane has been disrespecting Hana's privacy and personal time whenever he feels like it, why shouldn't she? Why should his circumstance leave her out of the picture, especially after all the time they've shared? Seriously, the ending of the volume was absolutely brilliant and I loved loved loved it! I can't wait for volume 7, I want to see where this arc goes!
holly_keimig's review against another edition
3.0
This volume took some strange twists and turns. Takane ends up seeing what a world without riches feels like and Hana steps in to show him she doesn't only like him because he's rich. Good character development with some surprises in the plot.
millyferg's review against another edition
4.0
Continues to entertain, this time with.... FEELINGS?!
Also, the whole last 10 pages cracked me up but now I want the next volume!
Also, the whole last 10 pages cracked me up but now I want the next volume!
regent_ace's review against another edition
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
stephsfeelinbookish's review
emotional
funny
lighthearted
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
heyjudy's review against another edition
4.0
~4 Stars
(Contains light spoilers.)
The volume starts normal, with Christmas and then some friend drama. Of course, Takane goes over the top for Christmas, because he wants it to be special for Hana. And then we see how Nicola's flirty personality affects one of Hana's friends not-quite-as-intended.
But then, in the latter half of the volume, Takane has to see his family for a get-together, which leads to a surprise turn of events for Takane. He gets thrown a curve-ball, in which he's going to have to experience life like a normal, poor person. My main issue with this idea, is that all of Takane's money and everything goes away, even what he has worked for himself. He wasn't given everything, he did actually do an important job for the company. But, I see the reason behind it—and, I do love seeing it humble Takane. It's a big difference to what he's used to, and despite how Hana has always reacted to his money and actions, he doesn't think she'll be okay with this version of himself.
The facial expressions in this series are kind of epic. They're ridiculous, and often for humor, but done so well and so purposely, that I love them. The reactions between Hana and Takane, too, are great. They work to surprise each other, to pretend they don't feel as strongly as they do, but sometimes the surprises are just natural, like when they're honest with each other, as they are at the end of this volume.
I'm really enjoying this series. It's grown on my to where I look forward to each volume, and I'm really interested to see what happens next with Takane.
(Contains light spoilers.)
The volume starts normal, with Christmas and then some friend drama. Of course, Takane goes over the top for Christmas, because he wants it to be special for Hana. And then we see how Nicola's flirty personality affects one of Hana's friends not-quite-as-intended.
But then, in the latter half of the volume, Takane has to see his family for a get-together, which leads to a surprise turn of events for Takane. He gets thrown a curve-ball, in which he's going to have to experience life like a normal, poor person. My main issue with this idea, is that all of Takane's money and everything goes away, even what he has worked for himself. He wasn't given everything, he did actually do an important job for the company. But, I see the reason behind it—and, I do love seeing it humble Takane. It's a big difference to what he's used to, and despite how Hana has always reacted to his money and actions, he doesn't think she'll be okay with this version of himself.
The facial expressions in this series are kind of epic. They're ridiculous, and often for humor, but done so well and so purposely, that I love them. The reactions between Hana and Takane, too, are great. They work to surprise each other, to pretend they don't feel as strongly as they do, but sometimes the surprises are just natural, like when they're honest with each other, as they are at the end of this volume.
I'm really enjoying this series. It's grown on my to where I look forward to each volume, and I'm really interested to see what happens next with Takane.
tartbarbie's review against another edition
5.0
I devoured the series over the course of a couple of months. Took a little longer than I hoped because a few of them decided to take forever from Amazon. Hana ends up roped into taking her older sisters place in a marriage match never expecting that anything would come from it. Instead a we get a very sweet comical whirlwind romance between her and Takane.
I ended up reading the first one and instantly ordering the rest of them it's such a cute series kind of a enemies to lover romance between them. I loved Hana she's an adorable character and I think because of her I'm going to do bubblegum pink hair next. Each manga has the pair growing as characters. Takane had a lot of growing to do but he get's there eventually.
The artwork is as equally lovely as the story. I was captivated right from the start and fell in love with Hana and Takane's story. This is one of my favorite series that I'm so glad I purchased the set. They will always have a special place on my bookshelf and I know they will get some re-reads as I wasn't ready to say goodbye just yet. I plan to read the authors other manga as I loved this one so much. Highly recommend a perfect sweet romance.
I ended up reading the first one and instantly ordering the rest of them it's such a cute series kind of a enemies to lover romance between them. I loved Hana she's an adorable character and I think because of her I'm going to do bubblegum pink hair next. Each manga has the pair growing as characters. Takane had a lot of growing to do but he get's there eventually.
The artwork is as equally lovely as the story. I was captivated right from the start and fell in love with Hana and Takane's story. This is one of my favorite series that I'm so glad I purchased the set. They will always have a special place on my bookshelf and I know they will get some re-reads as I wasn't ready to say goodbye just yet. I plan to read the authors other manga as I loved this one so much. Highly recommend a perfect sweet romance.
saramarie08's review against another edition
5.0
Read more graphic novel reviews at www.graphiclibrary.org.
The beginning of this wraps up the storylines that happen around Christmas time, then launches into a new story arc - Takane’s grandfather is frustrated that Takane won’t give him details about how his relationship is going with Hana. He decides he’s spoiled the kid too much, so he takes away all his stuff: freezes his accounts, sets him up in a shoebox of an apartment, gives him two cheap suits, and around $91 to live on for the month. He says Takane must climb back up to the top from the bottom to prove himself. Takane is so embarrassed by his new situation that he refuses to see Hana. But, based on the advice of her friend Okamon, Hana takes a page from Takane’s book and decides to pester him for a change.
This new arc is already really interesting, and it’s going to be great watching the tables turn on Takane. The mangaka points out in one side panel that there is a delicate balance between Takane’s appeal as a character and the love interest in a shojo manga. It’s going to be interesting keeping him appealing enough to satisfy the stereotypes and demands of the genre, but it will also be deeply satisfying to see this growth in Takane’s character. I appreciate Hana's dedication, and like that she is not going to let Takane slink away with his tale between his legs. Okamon is a very wise character, and he's definitely also proven his morality - he gives Hana some sound advice even though it is clear he wants to be with her. He more so just wants her to be happy.
Sara's Rating: 9/10
Suitability Level: Grades 8-12
The beginning of this wraps up the storylines that happen around Christmas time, then launches into a new story arc - Takane’s grandfather is frustrated that Takane won’t give him details about how his relationship is going with Hana. He decides he’s spoiled the kid too much, so he takes away all his stuff: freezes his accounts, sets him up in a shoebox of an apartment, gives him two cheap suits, and around $91 to live on for the month. He says Takane must climb back up to the top from the bottom to prove himself. Takane is so embarrassed by his new situation that he refuses to see Hana. But, based on the advice of her friend Okamon, Hana takes a page from Takane’s book and decides to pester him for a change.
This new arc is already really interesting, and it’s going to be great watching the tables turn on Takane. The mangaka points out in one side panel that there is a delicate balance between Takane’s appeal as a character and the love interest in a shojo manga. It’s going to be interesting keeping him appealing enough to satisfy the stereotypes and demands of the genre, but it will also be deeply satisfying to see this growth in Takane’s character. I appreciate Hana's dedication, and like that she is not going to let Takane slink away with his tale between his legs. Okamon is a very wise character, and he's definitely also proven his morality - he gives Hana some sound advice even though it is clear he wants to be with her. He more so just wants her to be happy.
Sara's Rating: 9/10
Suitability Level: Grades 8-12