14.3k reviews for:

Reckless

Elsie Silver

4.34 AVERAGE


It’s probably no surprise that this is another 5 star read for me. This might even be my favorite in the series now. 
I resonate so much with Winter. I also bear the nickname Ice Queen. I love that she is paired with the reckless, playful Theo. Their banter made me actually laugh out loud. 
I really thought I would hate the secret baby trope, but it didn’t put me off. If anything, it made me love Theo even more because he was instantly the best dad. He worships the ground that his girls walk on and I’m here for it. 

what do you mean the book ended? 0 stars for lack of more pages!!!

Very sweet. But Winter being so jealous and Theo being so trusting mostly, it annoyed me
emotional inspiring lighthearted medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

4.5⭐️

Probably my least favorite of the series so far but still loved it!! The huge time jump and the stupid miscommunication just irritated me lol. I would say I didn’t fall in love with Winter & Theo QUITE as much as Summer/Rhett, Cade/Willa, and Sloane/Jasper, but it still tugged at my heartstrings and I still adored Theo + seeing Winter’s growth (especially with Vivi)

What a cute small town romance. I ate this book up even thought it had a miscommunication trope in it. I had a great time learning about these characters and what made them tick. I loved how sweet the MMC and how after he realizes something fell through the cracks tries to make up for it. So sweet. 4 ⭐️ 2
emotional funny hopeful lighthearted medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes

This book basically gives you exactly what you think you're going to get out of a stereotypical romance novel. I enjoyed my time reading it, but it's not something that will live rent free in my head forever. However, I will give Elsie Silver a nod for giving me a trope I had never read before. That part was interesting and did keep me on my toes for a hot minute.

idk why i held off reading this book for so long, maybe i was scared of the " reformed manwhore", maybe it's the " secret baby". but i was pleasantly surprised.

*safety:
- safe
- no cheating between mcs
- both celibate during 18month seperation
- owd : an ex hook up shows up but he sets her straight that he's done with that life and has a girl
- omd : not really drama but her ex is a dick and he kept harassing her.


-what i loved :
- the MCs, it was black cat x golden retriever... characters like winter are very controversial because of her cold, rude, slightly bitchy demeanor but i personally eat that up i love me a damaged fmc that is closed off and mean instead of a doormat that lets everyone walk all over her.
and my god theo, never thought i'd love a reformed manwhore so much, maybe it's because we didn't witness his manwhoring ( if it was in previous books i can't remember and thank god for it

I have absolutely no regrets, I absolutely ate this shit up. Are you kidding!!? Obsessed! Onward to book 5