Scan barcode
lull4o4's review against another edition
4.0
3,5. No es tan bueno como el anterior en cuestión de trama, pero Lupin y Sholmès son de lo mejorcito
diegovolkx's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.75
readbymoony's review against another edition
3.0
Zabawna, szybko się czyta, lekka, w klimatach Sherlocka, ale nie do końca to jest jednak mój gatunek i trochę za mało mi Lupina w Lupinie było.
annass's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
mysterious
relaxing
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.5
andy02l's review against another edition
4.0
Me gusto y me dio risa el libro, me gustó más la historia de la lámpara porque no me lo esperaba, aunque eso sí conocer los conocimientos de Herlock fue raro y pobre Willson siempre lastimado
imyra's review against another edition
4.0
Delícia de ler esse livro. Super gostoso e divertido.
Diferentemente do primeiro volume, onde temos vários contos com o Arsène Lupin, neste temos duas histórias apenas: "A Mulher Loura" e "A lâmpada judáica". E, claro, contamos com a presença de ninguém mais, ninguém menos que Herlock Sholmes - seu arquinimigo - e seu pobre assistente, Wilson.
Como sempre Arsène é aquele personagem super carismático, cavalheiro, pronto para ajudar as pessoas, mas com o pequeno defeito de ser um ladrão.
Recomendo muito o livro!
Diferentemente do primeiro volume, onde temos vários contos com o Arsène Lupin, neste temos duas histórias apenas: "A Mulher Loura" e "A lâmpada judáica". E, claro, contamos com a presença de ninguém mais, ninguém menos que Herlock Sholmes - seu arquinimigo - e seu pobre assistente, Wilson.
Como sempre Arsène é aquele personagem super carismático, cavalheiro, pronto para ajudar as pessoas, mas com o pequeno defeito de ser um ladrão.
Recomendo muito o livro!
kynan's review against another edition
1.0
TL: Ugh. A poor interpretation of Holmes and Watson in an attempt to prove Lupin's worthiness to be Holmes' nemesis.
TL;DR: The cover claims that this book is "A Classic Tale of the World's Greatest Thief and the World's Greatest Detective". I'm not sold on the former claim and I found the portrayal of Holmes and, in particular, Watson to border on offensive. Watson, or "Wilson" as copyright claims required him to be named, is not even a parody, he's a lumbering idiotic dolt and Leblanc does everything he can to remove him from the story whenever he pops his head up. Herlock Sholmes (again, thanks copyright) is a better interpretation and the original material occasionally shines through but there's so much time dedicated to making a fool of him that the more nuanced and clever parodying is hidden. Additionally, I felt that the very first story removed Lupin's (dubious) claims from the first book that he's a harmless Robin Hood.
Complaining aside, there are elements of this book that are quite good! The Blonde Lady thread is very well done...and I think I've run out of nice things to say now actually. I've given this 1-star because, well, I legitimately didn't like it. 1-star is maybe harsh but I certainly wouldn't recommend it to anyone, which I think effectively pushes it out of "OK" territory.
TL;DR: The cover claims that this book is "A Classic Tale of the World's Greatest Thief and the World's Greatest Detective". I'm not sold on the former claim and I found the portrayal of Holmes and, in particular, Watson to border on offensive. Watson, or "Wilson" as copyright claims required him to be named, is not even a parody, he's a lumbering idiotic dolt and Leblanc does everything he can to remove him from the story whenever he pops his head up. Herlock Sholmes (again, thanks copyright) is a better interpretation and the original material occasionally shines through but there's so much time dedicated to making a fool of him that the more nuanced and clever parodying is hidden. Additionally, I felt that the very first story removed Lupin's (dubious) claims from the first book that he's a harmless Robin Hood.
Complaining aside, there are elements of this book that are quite good! The Blonde Lady thread is very well done...and I think I've run out of nice things to say now actually. I've given this 1-star because, well, I legitimately didn't like it. 1-star is maybe harsh but I certainly wouldn't recommend it to anyone, which I think effectively pushes it out of "OK" territory.
nicolascortez's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? N/A
4.0
jonigno's review against another edition
5.0
Loved it. The Sholmes and Wilson antics are hilarious and honestly, Conan Doyle had it coming. Leblanc could have even done worse but I guess he still had a shred of respect for the characters and their author.
Will be reading more of the gentleman-thief this year, probably (and more of his grandson lol)
Will be reading more of the gentleman-thief this year, probably (and more of his grandson lol)