Reviews with content warning for Forced institutionalization - The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes

The chapters at the end got really long, but the last 40 pages was a great ending of the book. Much more gruesome than the original trilogy, also more philosophical. Will forever love this series.

Content Warnings

david_slack110507's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious reflective sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

I was not expecting for this book to end the way that it did and for me to be so engrossed throughout but this was honestly a really fun read that had very few issues for me. I haven't read the original trilogy of books as I mainly read this book in anticipation for the movie adaptation to come out and I have watched the movie adaptations of the original trilogy but this book has made me want to start reading the original 3 books as I really enjoyed the way that the story was told in this and I would not be surprised if the movie adaptations of the original trilogy left things out of those books.

It was such an interesting choice to centre the book around the very antagonist of the original series in President Snow, who is simply just Coriolanus here and nothing much else other than having the last name Snow and the reputation that comes with that name. This was a good way of characterising Snow more so then what was done in the original entries into the franchise, and it was done so in being able to add layers to Snow's character while also being able to show how morally corrupt he was and how he didn't suddenly become evil, rather it was a slow process that becomes cemented in the final few chapters of the book and the epilogue in particular - essentially it does not just write off his actions as byproducts of what happened to him in this book and make him a misunderstood villain but rather that the intention behind his later actions was always there but just amplified by this book's events. Lucy Gray was also such a fascinating character too as she truly is someone in the wrong place at the wrong time that brings out the best in someone as bad as Snow and gets nothing good for her efforts and contributions, I like how different she is to Katniss and how being a performer, she immediately adapts to the publicity of the Games and survives because of it. I really liked the two of them as characters but there were also many others that I really liked and/or found fascinating and wanted to see more of such as Tigris, Sejanus, Dean Highbottom, Dr Gaul and more.

Speaking of the Games, they were really interesting to read about as we get it from the perspective of an onlooker (Coriolanus) while Lucy Gray, the one of the two that is actually in the Hunger Games, is trying to survive and fight for her life and so we don't read about any of the action that takes place other than what is seen on the monitors and yet it doesn't get boring and instead adds to the level of mystery and intrigue of the book which is something that it continues on with it's ending and resolution or there lack of for Lucy Gray's fate. It was also really interesting to have the Games as a sort of midway point in the book and to end the first half or so of the book rather than have it be the climatic battle/act that you would expect it to be instead allowing for Snow and Lucy Gray's relationship to grow following the aftermath of Games and their respective participation in it as mentor and competitor/participant, when they both return to District 12. This really solidified the strength of the book for me as it continued to thrive past its main selling point of the Hunger Games and instead allowed for more of a character study of the two to take place.

I feel like my only issue with this really is the fact that at times the pacing felt a little off as it stayed a little too focused on something that didn't seem to have too much significance but that's only really a minor issue I had with the book and only knocks it down a little from being an actual 5 star book to one that's rounded up from 4.5. I'm really interested in seeing how the movie adaptation manages to cover all this information as there is a lot here and I'm sure that there are references scattered about, besides from the obvious ones, to the original trilogy so I really hope that it delivers as this is such a wonderfully written and engaging story that has you become deeply invested in a previously unseen and unheard of character (That actually makes sense given the context) and the central villain who appeared to be just pure evil but is much more layered than that.

Content Warnings

stephanieluxton's review

Go to review page

adventurous dark tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

I loved the beginning and the end of this book. The unfortunate part was the middle which felt more drawn out than it needed to be.

The characters were great. The main characters were nicely fleshed out. They felt complex and interesting. I loved their introductions and watching their relationships grow and change. I enjoyed seeing how they reacted to the dire situations they found themselves in.

The actual hunger games part was pretty dull. This is a prequel so the games are significantly more primitive and less wild than in the main series, but I didn't feel immersed. I suppose that's largely because we are seeing the games from Snows perspective, and he is a spectator.

Then there's a good chunk of story after the games that I just felt was dry and slow. It didn't pick up again until the very end where some major changes happen.

I can see why some people wouldn't like the ending but I thought it was satisfying enough, although it felt quite rushed compared to so much that comes before it.

As far as prequels go, this was decent. It's not better than the hunger games or catching fire but. I think I enjoyed it more than mockingjay.

Content Warnings

kiwichill's review

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

Prequel to The Hunger Games trilogy

Content Warnings

te_ss_i's review

Go to review page

dark medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

Disliked the narrator for this one

Content Warnings

kathis_wonderland's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

Das Lied von Vogel und Schlange ist ein Prequel zur Die Tribute von Panem Trilogie von Suzanne Collins. Hier geht es um den zukünftigen Präsident Snow, der als Mentor bei den Hungerspielen teilnimmt. Sein Tribut ist Lucy Gray aus Distrikt 12. Im Laufe der Vorbereitungen und der Hungerspiele entwickeln beide Gefühle füreinander. Coriolanus möchte alles tun, um Lucy Gray als Siegerin der Spiele zu sehen.

Nach langem hin und her habe ich das Buch nun endlich gelesen. Ich habe mir anfangs Sorgen gemacht, wie mir das Buch gefällt. Es ist jetzt schon viele viele Jahre her, dass ich die Trilogie verschlungen und geliebt habe. Jedoch war Das Lied von Vogel und Schlange irgendwie ganz anders als die Trilogie, aber doch sehr ähnlich. Man hat sich direkt wieder in Panem zurechtgefunden, jedoch war der Schreibstil an Snows Persönlichkeit angepasst. Ich fand es richtig spannend über die Vergangenheit von Panem zu erfahren. Die Geschichte von Snow gibt einen ganz anderen Blickwinkel auf die Geschehnisse.

Sehr interessant war für mich einfach der Konflikt zwischen "mag ich Snow" oder "mag ich Snow nicht". Wenn man die Trilogie gelesen hat und auch die Filme gesehen hat, weiß man einfach, wie böse Snow eigentlich ist. Hier in diesem Buch ist er jedoch Protagonist und somit auch der Sympathieträger. Ein richtig netter Mensch war er anscheinend noch nie. Er ist sehr auf sich bezogen und möchte überall gewinnen. Dennoch lernt man auch gute Seiten an ihm kennen. Dieser Konflikt hat mein Hirn ziemlich verwirrt. Jedoch hat genau das das Buch so spannend gemacht.

Das Buch war sehr spannend zu lesen. Ich habe schon lange kein so spannendes Buch mehr gelesen. Einfach zu wissen, dass Snow später der Antagonist ist und darauf zu warten, was ihn denn zum Bösewicht gemacht hat. Ich habe hart darauf gewartet zu wissen, warum er Distrikt 12 so hasst. Leider war ich dann von diesem Plot-Twist und dem Ende des Buches etwas enttäuscht. Das Ende ist nicht ganz eindeutig. Das hat mich einfach nicht ganz zufriedengestellt.

Leider war meine Ausgabe des Buches auch recht fehlerhaft. Ich habe einige Beistrichfehler und Grammatikfehler gefunden. Gewisse Sätze haben auch absolut keinen Sinn ergeben. Das hat mich ebenfalls gestört.

Ich fand das Buch wirklich spannend, obwohl es sehr zu inneren Konflikten geführt hat. Ich freue mich jetzt auch schon auf den Film im Kino. Es war schön wieder in die Welt von Panem zurückzukehren.

Content Warnings

More...