822 reviews for:

The Broken Vows

Catharina Maura

3.89 AVERAGE


Emotional Whiplash!!

This one was HEAVY!!!

Zane has secretly loved Celeste since the beginning of time, rivals all throughout their youth. But unfortunately like too many boys, Zane hurt her feelings over and over again thinking she’d just understand how he felt.

Why is this a thing?! Like truly, how do they learn this illogical behavior?!

Celeste isn’t much better, continuously hating Zane (and thinking he hated her) into adulthood for constantly besting her and teasing her throughout their childhood when in reality her issues should be with her grandfather equating her worth to Zane’s.

After Celeste returns from her years abroad to run her grandfather’s empire, in direct competition with The Windsors, their whirlwind romance truly begins.


- enemies to lovers
- marriage of convenience
- forced proximity


I love how Zane immediately starts to make an amends when she returns from London and they start a beautiful love journey.

Now Lily, well huh that’s all I can say. Mental illness is so important to acknowledge and discuss, but damn the pain and suffering of loved ones left in the dark was STRONG in this one.

Celeste deserved better and Zane truly, truly deserved better.

Please read the Trigger Warnings!!!

well 500 pages just to piss me off
slow-paced
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
emotional hopeful sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Celeste annoyed me and Zane deserved better.
Now I'm ready for Lexington
challenging emotional hopeful sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

The story wasn’t bad overall. But each chapter was continuing days or weeks after the previous one so it read like a forgetful persons diary entries. Also “the work” on relationship is talked about and described but not shown. The couple’s efforts to return mutual trust or earn forgiveness were mentioned in couple sentences and that’s it.

I liked the past much more than the present. Celeste and Zane were perfect in the beginning but in the present incidents I don't like Celeste much because of her repeated insecurity and I'm not a fan of the female lead groveling so there's that. Honestly this book was like third-chance romance trope rather than second-chance. But amid all of this, I loved Zane and really he deserved someone better than Celeste. Anyways, the chemistry was there in the beginning but in the present it seems forced. I'm actually dissapointed that's why LucaVal is still my fav couple in this series.

Wow!!!!!!!