Scan barcode
spinnerroweok's review against another edition
3.0
Ida Saxton is an interesting person. In her youth, she was a very vibrant, active, adventurous woman who bucked the attitudes of gender roles in her day by working in her father's bank. She married Civil War hero and up-and-coming politician William McKinley. They had two children, both of whom died very young. This left Ida devastated. She would often see other people's children and imagine what her own would be like. This gave her a fondness for children.
Along with this wound to her psyche, Mrs. McKinley also began suffering from seizures. This made her somewhat reclusive from time to time as treatments would go from helping to harming her. Add to this, she was married to the very ambitious William McKinley who was very doting and attentive to his wife's needs while being a very public figure whom the public begs for attention. This leads to a very interesting lifestyle as he goes from the House of Representative, to Governor of Ohio, to President.
I found it very interesting how McKinley carefully balanced the use of his wife's invalidism in his campaign for president. He managed to derive sympathy for his wife without evoking pity or even disdain for her condition which was considered unacceptable at the time. There were great efforts to hid what her true condition was.
Also very interesting was how Mrs. McKinley could influence policy and the president's decisions during the White House Years. At times, she became incredibly dependent upon "the Major" as she called him, frequently calling him away from important meetings. Other times, she would help him think about the situations he was dealing with.
Overall, the book was very informative and enjoyable. Mr. Anthony has done a lot of research to put this together. I was very impressed. It did get a little tedious at then end in describing Mrs. McKinley's widowhood as there seems to be a long list of shows and events Mrs. McKinley attends. However, this is very necessary in describing Mrs. McKinley's recovery from grief after the assassination of her husband.
I recommend.
Along with this wound to her psyche, Mrs. McKinley also began suffering from seizures. This made her somewhat reclusive from time to time as treatments would go from helping to harming her. Add to this, she was married to the very ambitious William McKinley who was very doting and attentive to his wife's needs while being a very public figure whom the public begs for attention. This leads to a very interesting lifestyle as he goes from the House of Representative, to Governor of Ohio, to President.
I found it very interesting how McKinley carefully balanced the use of his wife's invalidism in his campaign for president. He managed to derive sympathy for his wife without evoking pity or even disdain for her condition which was considered unacceptable at the time. There were great efforts to hid what her true condition was.
Also very interesting was how Mrs. McKinley could influence policy and the president's decisions during the White House Years. At times, she became incredibly dependent upon "the Major" as she called him, frequently calling him away from important meetings. Other times, she would help him think about the situations he was dealing with.
Overall, the book was very informative and enjoyable. Mr. Anthony has done a lot of research to put this together. I was very impressed. It did get a little tedious at then end in describing Mrs. McKinley's widowhood as there seems to be a long list of shows and events Mrs. McKinley attends. However, this is very necessary in describing Mrs. McKinley's recovery from grief after the assassination of her husband.
I recommend.
nataliesboooks's review against another edition
4.0
William and Ida McKinley sound like such a cute couple. He was absolutely devoted to her as she was to him. Ida had a lot of tragedy in her life (lost 2 children, husband assassinated, ongoing health issues) and I really felt for what she went through. I thought it was cute that she almost always referred to her husband as “the Major” - a moniker she used after meeting him for the first time when she couldn’t recall anything about him other than his military rank. I thought the book got a little overly detailed in some spots, but it was interesting to learn more about a First Lady I wasn’t really familiar with at all.
**read for book scavenger hunt: read two books - one fiction and one nonfiction - about the same subject/person (nonfiction - Ida McKinley)**
**read for book scavenger hunt: read two books - one fiction and one nonfiction - about the same subject/person (nonfiction - Ida McKinley)**
cancermoononhigh's review against another edition
5.0
This was my first introduction to the McKinley's, their legacy and their lives. It was like reading fiction, it flew so well together. I truly enjoyed Ida and would like to know more about her Major, if he truly was as devoted as her appeared in this book.
Ida was a leader among the patriotic girls of Canton Ohio during the Civil War, where she spent hours preparing bandages for the wounded Union Soldiers. She was the eldest of 3 and very close to both parents. Ida was quite well traveled, educated and independent by the time she crossed paths with the Major, William McKinley. After the two married, the Major informed Ida that he wanted to follow Governor Hayes into politics. After their honeymoon Ida even declared that her husband would one day be President.
The beginning of their marriage is quite sad, in less than 3 years Ida lost her grandmother, mother, two daughters, Katie and Little Ida, the loss of control of her body and mind. Ida was dealing with chronic disabilities - spinal injury, immobility of one leg, blinding headaches, seizures and was quite vulnerable to infection, due to her immune system being low because of her pregnancy with little Ida. Their were many first eye experiences that saw Ida during that time - how she would slump over or fall and had to be carried from her carriage or even up stairs with the help of her husband.
Epilepsy was not the disease to her before the turn of the century. Those with Epilepsy were not allowed to married and the majority of suffers died in insane asylums across the nation. Ida was disinterested in her disabilities and left her care up to her husband the Major. We don't learn too much more about her health from the Major - most of her discussions were done in person, or the letters were destroyed. Much of her illness today is shrouded in mystery because of the secretive nature of her husband. We do know for about 30 years the medicine the Major was giving her actually led to bromism, which did not eliminate the seizures and led to a more damaged central nervous system.
As the Major's political circle began to widen her condition was shrouded in mystery - her fevers, colds and use of the cane was blamed on her invalidism. The Major was known for his devotion to Ida, he was known to make a reference to her in every meeting and had a massive photograph of her above his desk. His devotion did not come across as showy, but was useful in dealing with lobbyists, journalists and politicos because they were less likely to exploit as gentle soul such as McKinley.
Ida's individualism was used in almost every major campaign for the Major. If fact one slogan went so bold to print, "McKinley the man whose constancy and devotion to an invalid wife not only endears him to every family in Ohio, but commends him as being 'the model' husband to every household in America." McKinley simply made use of his responsibilities for his wife, deriving benefit from his acts of love for Ida. Ida, for her part, publicized the husband's devotion to her, it helped ease her guilt over being unable to help his political career as much as she felt she should have.
When Ida would have a seizure McKinley or another intimate who knew about her condition, would place a large napkin over her face and continue on as if it was not occurring. It was an unsaid rule that no one brings up her episodes. The President would cut off even polite inquires after she had a seizure.
Before the McKinley's left for Buffalo, Ida was very against going, although offering no reason as to why. McKinley refused any attempts of Secret Service. McKinley was heard saying, "If not for Ida, I would prefer to go as Lincoln went. Mckinley was shot twice in a receiving line in Buffalo, New York. No one thought about retrieving the X Ray Machine in display to locate the bullet in the President's back. The bullet remained in him, the wound was closed and disinfection applied. As soon as Ida was informed of the Major's injuries she declared that she must be with him. Ida was confronted with the fact that someone had harmed the person she counted on most to protect her. That confrontation seemed to transform Ida into an assertive and embolden person - almost the girl she was. She was also not with him when the Major died, she was in bed. She was also not told right away. The people around Ida seemed the hardest to keep her from what was going on.
The relationship with the Roosevelt's and Ida benefited her greatly after the passing of her husband. Ida was always a big fan of Roosevelt and Roosevelt in return respected the McKinleys. President Roosevelt granted Ida what she wanted, even as others around her told her no.
Edith would send Ida flowers and in return Ida would send her a note and sometimes dry flowers from the President's grave.
Eleven days before her 60th birthday Ida died. The cause of death was a "brain tumor." Whatever medical issues Ida had, died with her. Five days later at her memorial service, President Roosevelt summed it their marriage up the best, "her faith inspired him, her confidence assured him, her very weakness strengthen him."
*Fun fact - Ida's favorite color was Blue - it seemed to soothe her. Yellow was her least favorite.
*Fun Fact - Ida's brother was murdered.
Ida was a leader among the patriotic girls of Canton Ohio during the Civil War, where she spent hours preparing bandages for the wounded Union Soldiers. She was the eldest of 3 and very close to both parents. Ida was quite well traveled, educated and independent by the time she crossed paths with the Major, William McKinley. After the two married, the Major informed Ida that he wanted to follow Governor Hayes into politics. After their honeymoon Ida even declared that her husband would one day be President.
The beginning of their marriage is quite sad, in less than 3 years Ida lost her grandmother, mother, two daughters, Katie and Little Ida, the loss of control of her body and mind. Ida was dealing with chronic disabilities - spinal injury, immobility of one leg, blinding headaches, seizures and was quite vulnerable to infection, due to her immune system being low because of her pregnancy with little Ida. Their were many first eye experiences that saw Ida during that time - how she would slump over or fall and had to be carried from her carriage or even up stairs with the help of her husband.
Epilepsy was not the disease to her before the turn of the century. Those with Epilepsy were not allowed to married and the majority of suffers died in insane asylums across the nation. Ida was disinterested in her disabilities and left her care up to her husband the Major. We don't learn too much more about her health from the Major - most of her discussions were done in person, or the letters were destroyed. Much of her illness today is shrouded in mystery because of the secretive nature of her husband. We do know for about 30 years the medicine the Major was giving her actually led to bromism, which did not eliminate the seizures and led to a more damaged central nervous system.
As the Major's political circle began to widen her condition was shrouded in mystery - her fevers, colds and use of the cane was blamed on her invalidism. The Major was known for his devotion to Ida, he was known to make a reference to her in every meeting and had a massive photograph of her above his desk. His devotion did not come across as showy, but was useful in dealing with lobbyists, journalists and politicos because they were less likely to exploit as gentle soul such as McKinley.
Ida's individualism was used in almost every major campaign for the Major. If fact one slogan went so bold to print, "McKinley the man whose constancy and devotion to an invalid wife not only endears him to every family in Ohio, but commends him as being 'the model' husband to every household in America." McKinley simply made use of his responsibilities for his wife, deriving benefit from his acts of love for Ida. Ida, for her part, publicized the husband's devotion to her, it helped ease her guilt over being unable to help his political career as much as she felt she should have.
When Ida would have a seizure McKinley or another intimate who knew about her condition, would place a large napkin over her face and continue on as if it was not occurring. It was an unsaid rule that no one brings up her episodes. The President would cut off even polite inquires after she had a seizure.
Before the McKinley's left for Buffalo, Ida was very against going, although offering no reason as to why. McKinley refused any attempts of Secret Service. McKinley was heard saying, "If not for Ida, I would prefer to go as Lincoln went. Mckinley was shot twice in a receiving line in Buffalo, New York. No one thought about retrieving the X Ray Machine in display to locate the bullet in the President's back. The bullet remained in him, the wound was closed and disinfection applied. As soon as Ida was informed of the Major's injuries she declared that she must be with him. Ida was confronted with the fact that someone had harmed the person she counted on most to protect her. That confrontation seemed to transform Ida into an assertive and embolden person - almost the girl she was. She was also not with him when the Major died, she was in bed. She was also not told right away. The people around Ida seemed the hardest to keep her from what was going on.
The relationship with the Roosevelt's and Ida benefited her greatly after the passing of her husband. Ida was always a big fan of Roosevelt and Roosevelt in return respected the McKinleys. President Roosevelt granted Ida what she wanted, even as others around her told her no.
Edith would send Ida flowers and in return Ida would send her a note and sometimes dry flowers from the President's grave.
Eleven days before her 60th birthday Ida died. The cause of death was a "brain tumor." Whatever medical issues Ida had, died with her. Five days later at her memorial service, President Roosevelt summed it their marriage up the best, "her faith inspired him, her confidence assured him, her very weakness strengthen him."
*Fun fact - Ida's favorite color was Blue - it seemed to soothe her. Yellow was her least favorite.
*Fun Fact - Ida's brother was murdered.
littlesprite21's review against another edition
challenging
emotional
informative
reflective
sad
slow-paced
4.0
More...