Scan barcode
telahe's review against another edition
2.0
تعداد شخصیت ها خیلی زیاد بود و سخت میشد باهاش ارتباط برقرار کرد، به محض اینکه شرایط و شخصیت ها اشنا شد و تو روال داستان قرار گرفتم، داستان به زمان حال پرش کرد و شخصیت های جدید وارد شدن و روز از نو روزی از نو.
بخش هایی از کتاب هم احتمالا مشکل سانسور و... داشت که مترجم در لفافه بهش پرداخته بود، مفهوم دریافت میشد ولی خب بازم تو ذوقم میزد.
دو شخصیت اصلی زن داستان (حداقل برای من) اصلا دوست داشتنی نبودن و بقیه شخصیت ها حضورشون در داستان خیلی کمرنگ تر از اون بود که بشه باهاشون ارتباط گرفت.
شاید اگر کتاب خلاصه تر و شخصیت ها کمتر میشد، خیلی بهتر بود اما در کل نسبت به بقیه کتاب هایی که از مویز خوندم ضعیف تر بود.
فکر میکنم شرایط تعیین میکنه چقدر یک کتاب رو دوست داشته باشیم، برعکس یک بعلاوه یک این کتاب رو با سختگیری بیشتری خوندم و شاید هم به همین دلیل اینقدر کم ستاره دادم. فکر میکنم اگر این کتاب رو تو شرایط یک بعلاوه یک میخوندم چهار ستاره بهش میدادم.
بخش هایی از کتاب هم احتمالا مشکل سانسور و... داشت که مترجم در لفافه بهش پرداخته بود، مفهوم دریافت میشد ولی خب بازم تو ذوقم میزد.
دو شخصیت اصلی زن داستان (حداقل برای من) اصلا دوست داشتنی نبودن و بقیه شخصیت ها حضورشون در داستان خیلی کمرنگ تر از اون بود که بشه باهاشون ارتباط گرفت.
شاید اگر کتاب خلاصه تر و شخصیت ها کمتر میشد، خیلی بهتر بود اما در کل نسبت به بقیه کتاب هایی که از مویز خوندم ضعیف تر بود.
فکر میکنم شرایط تعیین میکنه چقدر یک کتاب رو دوست داشته باشیم، برعکس یک بعلاوه یک این کتاب رو با سختگیری بیشتری خوندم و شاید هم به همین دلیل اینقدر کم ستاره دادم. فکر میکنم اگر این کتاب رو تو شرایط یک بعلاوه یک میخوندم چهار ستاره بهش میدادم.
sdownsy's review against another edition
3.0
3.5 stars. I liked the interconnecting stories ultimately coming together for a rich story (though not overly neatly). Among my favorite Jojo Moyes books.
colleenlovestoread's review against another edition
4.0
Find my full review at http://aliteraryvacation.blogspot.com.
I've read a couple novels by Jojo Moyes (The Girl You Left Behind and Me Before You) and really enjoy her ability to whisk me away to either the past or the present with humor and heart, all while making me care for her characters and the ups and downs they experience. With Windfallen, I felt like I got the best of both worlds: a look into the past as Lottie Swift tackles the obstacles before her shortly after WWII as well as a present storyline showing Daisy Parsons tackling her own set of issues. What I wasn't expecting was the similarities between these two women and how their lives would become intertwined.
Unlike most novels I've read that deal with dual timelines, the first half of Windfallen deals exclusively with Lottie's coming-of-age story as she decides to stay in Merham after being sent to the country and out of London during the WWII bombings on the city. I quickly came to like Lottie as she navigated the uppity family she lived with that never quite accepted her as their own. I ached with her as she fell in love with someone not meant for her (as well as felt for the boy who clearly loves her and which she doesn't feel the same for). She's a kind, forthright and sympathetic young character and I'm very glad I already liked her by the time we see her in what I think of as "Daisy's half" of the story as she becomes quite the crotchety and overly opinionated older woman. This is somewhat understandable given her life experiences, but still.
I wasn't as big a fan of Daisy's story but I did appreciate how she grew as a character during her time remodeling Arcadia House. We get to see her go from a battered and broken single mom into a strong woman able to face anyone - whether that be a brash boss, busybody townfolk, selfish ex-lover, or pushy babysitter - with confidence and determination. I also liked how she ended up influencing and helping Lottie as much as Lottie helped her. They both had so much in common, even given the very different circumstances they experienced, and it was interesting to see how both their stories would twist together and apart and ultimately resolve.
As I always do with audiobooks, I should mention that I enjoyed the narrator (Michelle Ford) and thought she did a good job of differentiating the characters. She did an excellent job of effectively expressing the humor in the story as well, and was able to shift between warring emotions clearly and with a good bit of impact for the listener.
Jojo Moyes has such a unique way of telling a story that I'm pretty much a fan for life. While Windfallen isn't my favorite of her novels I've read (that designation still goes to The Girl You Left Behind) it is still a great story full of heart, humor, and emotion.
I've read a couple novels by Jojo Moyes (The Girl You Left Behind and Me Before You) and really enjoy her ability to whisk me away to either the past or the present with humor and heart, all while making me care for her characters and the ups and downs they experience. With Windfallen, I felt like I got the best of both worlds: a look into the past as Lottie Swift tackles the obstacles before her shortly after WWII as well as a present storyline showing Daisy Parsons tackling her own set of issues. What I wasn't expecting was the similarities between these two women and how their lives would become intertwined.
Unlike most novels I've read that deal with dual timelines, the first half of Windfallen deals exclusively with Lottie's coming-of-age story as she decides to stay in Merham after being sent to the country and out of London during the WWII bombings on the city. I quickly came to like Lottie as she navigated the uppity family she lived with that never quite accepted her as their own. I ached with her as she fell in love with someone not meant for her (as well as felt for the boy who clearly loves her and which she doesn't feel the same for). She's a kind, forthright and sympathetic young character and I'm very glad I already liked her by the time we see her in what I think of as "Daisy's half" of the story as she becomes quite the crotchety and overly opinionated older woman. This is somewhat understandable given her life experiences, but still.
I wasn't as big a fan of Daisy's story but I did appreciate how she grew as a character during her time remodeling Arcadia House. We get to see her go from a battered and broken single mom into a strong woman able to face anyone - whether that be a brash boss, busybody townfolk, selfish ex-lover, or pushy babysitter - with confidence and determination. I also liked how she ended up influencing and helping Lottie as much as Lottie helped her. They both had so much in common, even given the very different circumstances they experienced, and it was interesting to see how both their stories would twist together and apart and ultimately resolve.
As I always do with audiobooks, I should mention that I enjoyed the narrator (Michelle Ford) and thought she did a good job of differentiating the characters. She did an excellent job of effectively expressing the humor in the story as well, and was able to shift between warring emotions clearly and with a good bit of impact for the listener.
Jojo Moyes has such a unique way of telling a story that I'm pretty much a fan for life. While Windfallen isn't my favorite of her novels I've read (that designation still goes to The Girl You Left Behind) it is still a great story full of heart, humor, and emotion.
essentiallymeagan's review against another edition
4.0
It took me quite a while to get into this book. I couldn't figure out where it was all going with the characters of Celia and Lottie. Keep with it though- while predictable it is still an interesting story
alexandra296's review against another edition
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Diverse cast of characters? No
2.5
sophierayton's review against another edition
2.0
Jojo Moyes is such a good writer but this one was just OK for me. I know she has written some popular books and I've enjoyed what I have read from her before so I'm not put off of reading what else she's written.