Scan barcode
quoththegirl's review against another edition
2.0
After three books of John Carter chasing after and attempting to rescue the oft-kidnapped Dejah Thoris, Burroughs decided to mix it up this time: Carthoris (the son of John Carter and Dejah Thoris who sounds like he was named after a Livejournal community shipping the two characters) chases after and attempts to rescue the oft-kidnapped Thuvia instead. Burroughs is like, I've got one plot line, and by George I'm going to keep reusing it until someone physically stops me. We still have no explanation of why John Carter doesn't age, so I'm guessing we never get one. Burroughs had used the frame narrative at the start of book three but didn't conclude with it, and he totally abandons it altogether for this installment.
staatz's review against another edition
3.0
World War one era pulp sci-fi at it's best. Sexist and racist by today's standards but not so bad for a book written in 1916. I think it differs enough in some of it's themes to distinguish it from other books in the series as well (those silly European- I mean red men going to war for a silly reason)
valhecka's review against another edition
3.0
Compared to the previous ones, this was fun and quick. It's the first NOT written in first person, which serves the narrative well because it eliminates Carter's internal monologuing about how great he thinks he is. The swap games in perspective were sloppy, but the plot is endearingly soap-operatic and the descriptions remain beautiful.
murkymaster's review against another edition
5.0
Thuvia and the son of John Carter shared the spot light in this short but interesting book, where quite a novel premise is introduced. This story is much the textbook example of "damsel in distress", but provides some oppurtunities for Thuvia to shine.
vintonole's review against another edition
2.0
Story above John Carter's son Carthoris and Thuvia. Entertaining, but not as globe spanning as the first three novels.
jvan's review against another edition
3.0
Better than book 3, this slightly tangled narrative brings in even wackier Barsoomians with mighty mental powers who are still petty asses just like everyone else on Mars. Thuvia should have been more badass; recognizing the times, I get why she wasn't, but there are constant references throughout the books to Barsoomian women taking up weapons when needed and being in some ways better with them, but here in this book, when it would have been great, Thuvia doesn't do that. She's more the object of the story than the subject (not surprisingly, again given the time) but her handy ability to make banths do her bidding at least means she plays a part now and again.
Carthoris is like boring John Carter. Let us never have him feature as protagonist again, okay?
Carthoris is like boring John Carter. Let us never have him feature as protagonist again, okay?
ruben_lapuerta's review against another edition
3.0
Another book in the Barsoom series. This is the worst I've read so far but I still consider it a book worth reading.
It is a short and easy to read adventure book. You're not going to find the originality of the first books nor the same depth but only action. In this book things seem to happen without clear reasons breaking the rules of what was stated in the previous books. Characters behave in a way you don't expect and the author doen't provide a plausible explanation for their actions. Things just happen to keep the story moving.
It is a short and easy to read adventure book. You're not going to find the originality of the first books nor the same depth but only action. In this book things seem to happen without clear reasons breaking the rules of what was stated in the previous books. Characters behave in a way you don't expect and the author doen't provide a plausible explanation for their actions. Things just happen to keep the story moving.
michaeldrakich's review against another edition
4.0
This is the fourth book in the Mars series by Edgar Rice Burroughs, but the first in where John Carter is not the hero. Instead, it focuses on his son, Carthoris.
My first reaction was a mild disappointment with the change. After the first three novels, my emoting with John Carter was deep and I wasn't at first ready for the transition but after a few chapters, I had settled in.
The plot to kidnap Thuvia seemed overly complicated at first as I did not comprehend the intentions of the captors on their initial plan. The whole taking her to a long-abandoned city in the south of Mars made no sense. It became obvious that the author was not worried about reason, only wanting to establish a new setting and characters not previously discovered in the previous novels. The whole 'mentally projected archers' thing also didn't work for me.
Nevertheless, like the first three novels, there is plenty of heroics, lots of battles, and a number of challenges, both mental and physical, for the hero, all things I had come to expect so all enjoyable.
The final result, 4 stars. The previously mentioned issues being too much to overlook to go 5.
My first reaction was a mild disappointment with the change. After the first three novels, my emoting with John Carter was deep and I wasn't at first ready for the transition but after a few chapters, I had settled in.
The plot to kidnap Thuvia seemed overly complicated at first as I did not comprehend the intentions of the captors on their initial plan. The whole taking her to a long-abandoned city in the south of Mars made no sense. It became obvious that the author was not worried about reason, only wanting to establish a new setting and characters not previously discovered in the previous novels. The whole 'mentally projected archers' thing also didn't work for me.
Nevertheless, like the first three novels, there is plenty of heroics, lots of battles, and a number of challenges, both mental and physical, for the hero, all things I had come to expect so all enjoyable.
The final result, 4 stars. The previously mentioned issues being too much to overlook to go 5.
sonshinelibrarian's review against another edition
4.0
I think Thuvia is my favorite character so far in this series.