Reviews

Gunmetal Magic by Ilona Andrews

silverwizzard's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I didn't know I would like both Andrea and Raphael so much :) Would have liked to see more of the happy parts ;)

whatsmacksaid's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Not QUITE as brilliant as the rest of the Kate Daniels books, but pretty damn close. (Like 3.5/5 stars. Would read again, definitely.) The acknowledgements say they had trouble with this story, and it shows in a few small areas. But! I still recommend this to ANYONE who has enjoyed the Kate Daniels world. It was very enjoyable.

witchylevy's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Ah poor Anubis. I only say that because I'm a witch with him as one of my Patron Deities lol.
For whatever reason this took me a while to read. I just kept getting bored. The story was completely interesting and I loved the progression, but at the same time it didn't necessarily hook me except in a few moments. Still, I'm happy I reread this.

ransomoney's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

This book from Andrea’s s perspective me think for the first time about the “warrior” form of the shapeshifters. I can’t stop picturing the anamorphs covers now. 

Speaking of covers. I love how these covers keep on getting worse and worse. I love it so much because the books are great and the covers are truely terrible. It makes me love it more. 


elbyjosie's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional funny mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.75

amym84's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I was impressed with this book. I absolutely love the Kate Daniels series and I've loved every book / story that Ilona Andrews has written for the series including the novellas for anthologies which have featured a different POV than Kate. I was a little unsure how I would like a full-length book with Andrea as the narrator. I like her character, but I like how she is through Kate's narration. Plus, not having Kate and Curran in the foreground wasn't something I thought I would like.

Gunmetal Magic starts off after the events in Magic Slays. There's still a lot of things that Andrea has to deal with in regards to the pack and mainly Raphael after she left at the end of Magic Bleeds. She hasn't spoken to Raphael since their fight and she figures things with them are probably off for good, but she still has feelings for him. Both of them are full of pride and feel like the other doesn't understand each other's actions with the Erra situation.

I'm glad to say that Ilona Andrews doesn't skirt around the issue. We all know it's there, and it will get dealt with. I like that it's acknowledged and it's not Andrea and Raphael avoiding each other the whole book but we only get to hear internally what Andrea is feeling. They put all their issues on the table and each of them has to decide if the relationship is worth it. There's a lot of work that has to be done on both sides becuase honestly in my opinion I can see this situation from both points of view and I think they were both equally hurt by the other.

Kate and Curran are still around don't worry. They are off on their own adventure for a little bit (see the extra included short story Magic Gifts at the end) but they eventually join in to help Andrea and crew find out what killed 4 shapshifters on one of Raphaels dig sites. Which leads into an investigation of gods of all sorts.

I'm always impressed with the historical mythology that Ilona Andrews provide. They obviously spend a lot of time with research and it shows. I like that just by reading the books you can tell they really put 110% into it and really it should be that way with every author / story they write.

I think if you happened to pick this book up at random and read it, you wouldn't be lost, but I think it's much more enhanced knowing all the background information and where everyone was coming from beforehand going into the story.

This writing goup just keeps getting better and I can't wait until their next release (regardless of which series because they also have an awesome series "The Edge" with [b:Steel's Edge|12119496|Steel's Edge (The Edge, #4)|Ilona Andrews|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1341723527s/12119496.jpg|17088789] book #4 coming out in November). Until Then!

pixip's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I absolutely love the character of Andrea and am so glad she got her own stand alone book. She didn't disappoint at all the story was fantastic and fast paced and left me unable to put it down. It was great to see her bond with Asciano more and even better to find out more about her past. My only slight niggle with the book was the confrontation with her final tormentor from her youth it felt a little rushed like it was squeezed into the book.
Otherwise loved it and also really loved Roman he was a surprising addition to this book.

divapitbull's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

GM takes place in the Kate Daniel's world with the same cast of characters. The timeline of the story overlaps the events in the Magic Gifts novella which is included. GM is told from the POV of Andrea Nash, Kate's BFF. Andrea is back from her self imposed, "I gotta find myself" exile and coming to terms with her Beastkin nature. Jim, the Alpha of Clan Cat and Curran's head of security pulls Andrea into a murder investigation since Kate and Curren are occupied with the events happening in Magic Gifts. Andrea's investigation into the murders brings her back into contact with her ex. beau Raphael; who she hasn't seen since their big argument and Andrea hieing off into parts unknown after the battle with Kate's aunt.

I like Andrea. Overall I think she's a pretty tough cookie and a decent female lead; but I wasn't on her side with the whole "relationship conflict fiasco". When you add up all the events from the beginning - I kinda side with Raphael and I felt he was the injured party. Still I liked their bantering and I enjoy the humor the authors inject into the story. I liked Andrea's comaraderie with Ascanio. I really like Roman and hope he continues to make an appearance in future installments.

Magic Gifts is a short story that seems to set the stage for Magic Rises with regard to Kate's re-involvement in the Mercenary Guild. There are some fun moments between Kate and Ghastek - everyone's favorite Master of the Dead.

mountainmija's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional

4.0

 guilty pleasure 

indecisivesailorscout's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

*2nd read*
I actually felt like it dragged a bit this time, and while I loved everything up until Raphael and Andrea got back together, everything after that point was kind of meh. It's still a great addition to the series and explains what happened to Raphael in book 5 (and why things were totally fine between Andi & Raphael from book 6 onwards) ((also, the fact that everyone calls her Andi. Melt my heart, why don't you.))

4.5 stars - I liked this a lot more than I thought I would, and really enjoyed this point of view in the story. There are a couple things I didn't like, but they were few and far between. Keep it up, Ilona :)