Reviews

Public Wife, Private Mistress (Italian Husbands) by Sarah Morgan

tsukikomew's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This review was posted at Tsuki’s Book Blog on August 29, 2013.

On the edge of my Lucy Monroe binge I went looking at the library for other favorite HP authors. In this case I stumbled on the library's collection of Sarah Morgan (much smaller) and I snatched this one up. This was a pleasant book divergent from desert sheikhs and instead featured an Italian billionaire and a failing marriage (my fave).

When Rico's sister took a fall from a horse, she calls out his estranged wife's name in her unconscious state. Rico calls his almost ex-wife back to Italy nearly kicking and screaming. When Chiara awakens and doesn't remember the past 18 months, Rico blackmails Stasia into being his wife again to help Chiara remain healthy and happy. As they play their roles they begin to fall in love all over again. Naturally there was a reason behind their almost divorce and that night still stands between them.

I love nearly failed marriages turned back into love stories. In this case I was pleased to watch the repair of their marriage when they started TALKING. Imagine that! A billionaire tycoon actually took an hour and TALKED to his wife. He could not understand why she cheated on him with a nearly teenage boy or why she ran out on their marriage if she was innocent. She, on the other hand, couldn't believe he thought she cheated AND he didn't bother to come after her.

While I loved the romance and the falling in love part, the Chiara part drove me crazy. Chiara hit her head AND had a personality change. Stasia made it pretty clear Chiara was a mess with her from the beginning but when Chiara thought it was 18 months earlier she was suddenly accepting and nearly perfect with Stasia. That just struck me as strange. Also when she got her memory back she still didn't tell Rico about the night Stasia and his marriage fell apart and her role in the whole thing. I understand teenagers can be stupid but seriously?! That seemed ridiculous.

The other problem with this one was Rico's family's dependence on him. His entire family barely did anything unless Rico gave permission and approved. Stasia called him out on the fact she had never been like that but that was what he expected. At the same time she conceded she should have understood why he felt that way. I'm sorry but he became head of household when he was fifteen and while I get cultural differences, it was insane. His mother, sister, grandmother ceded all control to him at fifteen and still ceded all control years later. They had zero personality and zero spine. How...disturbing.

While I had my issues with this book, it was enjoyable. It isn't a book I would recommend for new HP readers. It's a book I would recommend to people who love nearly failed marriage romances OR Sarah Morgan fans. It was a fun read although some aspects were a bit disturbing. Hopefully the next Sarah Morgan book I read will be a bit more like "Once a Ferrara Wife" so I can finally put one higher than that one in comparison.

3 Stars
Published by Harlequin
April 2006
187 Pages
Provided by--the Library

mrose21's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This was pretty tame.

I liked it. I just wasn't in love with either. Both characters were ok but no real chemistry.

farahm123's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.5

destinugrainy's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

Baru kali ini saya tidak menyukai novel karya Sarah Morgan. Ide ceritanya sebenarnya bagus, tentang kesetiaan dan komunikasi dalam pernikahan. Tapi karakter hero-nya nyebelin banget, bar-bar, dan super egois. Rico bisa dengan mudah menggunakan seks untuk menaklukkan istrinya, tanpa benar-benar memahami keinginan istrinya. Masa lalu serba kekurangan mungkin membuat Rico berpikir istrinya puas dengan harta dan hubungan badan. Rico tidak merasa perlu mendengarkan kesepian yang dialami Stasia. Stasia sendiri juga merasa lebih baik tidak usah berbicara pada Rico, dan menunggu Rico berubah.

apn01's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

blackferrum's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Sebel sama Rico. Sebel banget karena sesuai sama judul, Stasia berasa simpenan aja kalo di rumah. Asli gedeg abis denger jawaban dia ke Stasia cuma begitu. Jahat, seksis, sinting! Walaupun cuma salah paham, tapi tetep aja kata-katanya nggak pantes diucapin. Kadang buat ukuran bussinessman sukses, Rico ini agak bodoh juga buat mahami wanita (yang bahkan istrinya, lho).

Satu bintang tambahan buat endingnya, walaupun agak nggak rela bisa balikan. Lagi2 karena seks, ugh. Kalau alasannya di luar seks pun kayaknya bisa nih diperpanjang. Also, tulisan Bunda SM as always layak buat dipertahankan. Sksksksksk aku bebal kayaknya ya, tetap baca aja karya2 SM walaupun cowok2nya pasti kaya, berkuasa, keras kepala, seksis, nggak pekaan, wkwkwk di lain sisi tetap demen ending2 macam bikinan Bunda SM ini, hiks.

gamz's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

From page one you know this is going to be an intense book. It opens with a teenaged girl fighting for her life in the hospital.

Rico's sister is in a coma but wakes long enough to ask for one person - Stasia, his soon to be ex-wife. This request throws the Rico and Stasia back together again. There is deep animosity between them because Rico saw Stasia in his bed with another guy. But all is not as it seems.

Rico and Stasia may dislike each other but the sexual chemistry between them is hot! They communicate best physically and they spent a good portion of the book "communicating".

I loved Stasia. She was so wronged but she held in to her dignity in-spite and secrets in spite of Rico's vitriol. Rico is a Neanderthal who believes that his wife should be home waiting for him in bed.

I absolutely enjoyed this book, my only complaint was the end was rather abrupt. I needed an epilogue to tie up a few loose ends. Otherwise, a good, angsty read.

theladyinreds's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is a "fight fuck fight" book.

The protags are in a relationship on the verge of divorce. The hero believes his wife was unfaithful (not true - but he has good reason for thinking it is). The heroine believes her husband is an unrepentant workaholic (true) who only wanted her for sex (not true). She's also pretty darn pissed at him for even thinking she would cheat on him.

The "fight fuck fight" cycle bothered me because it just seemed like they were hammering the same things over and over again (double entendre totally intended) without anything changing until the very end. But when they did change at the end? Well, I totally grinned. I just would have liked a more gradual progression.

aefedele's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This review was posted at Tsuki’s Book Blog on August 29, 2013.

On the edge of my Lucy Monroe binge I went looking at the library for other favorite HP authors. In this case I stumbled on the library's collection of Sarah Morgan (much smaller) and I snatched this one up. This was a pleasant book divergent from desert sheikhs and instead featured an Italian billionaire and a failing marriage (my fave).

When Rico's sister took a fall from a horse, she calls out his estranged wife's name in her unconscious state. Rico calls his almost ex-wife back to Italy nearly kicking and screaming. When Chiara awakens and doesn't remember the past 18 months, Rico blackmails Stasia into being his wife again to help Chiara remain healthy and happy. As they play their roles they begin to fall in love all over again. Naturally there was a reason behind their almost divorce and that night still stands between them.

I love nearly failed marriages turned back into love stories. In this case I was pleased to watch the repair of their marriage when they started TALKING. Imagine that! A billionaire tycoon actually took an hour and TALKED to his wife. He could not understand why she cheated on him with a nearly teenage boy or why she ran out on their marriage if she was innocent. She, on the other hand, couldn't believe he thought she cheated AND he didn't bother to come after her.

While I loved the romance and the falling in love part, the Chiara part drove me crazy. Chiara hit her head AND had a personality change. Stasia made it pretty clear Chiara was a mess with her from the beginning but when Chiara thought it was 18 months earlier she was suddenly accepting and nearly perfect with Stasia. That just struck me as strange. Also when she got her memory back she still didn't tell Rico about the night Stasia and his marriage fell apart and her role in the whole thing. I understand teenagers can be stupid but seriously?! That seemed ridiculous.

The other problem with this one was Rico's family's dependence on him. His entire family barely did anything unless Rico gave permission and approved. Stasia called him out on the fact she had never been like that but that was what he expected. At the same time she conceded she should have understood why he felt that way. I'm sorry but he became head of household when he was fifteen and while I get cultural differences, it was insane. His mother, sister, grandmother ceded all control to him at fifteen and still ceded all control years later. They had zero personality and zero spine. How...disturbing.

While I had my issues with this book, it was enjoyable. It isn't a book I would recommend for new HP readers. It's a book I would recommend to people who love nearly failed marriage romances OR Sarah Morgan fans. It was a fun read although some aspects were a bit disturbing. Hopefully the next Sarah Morgan book I read will be a bit more like "Once a Ferrara Wife" so I can finally put one higher than that one in comparison.

3 Stars
Published by Harlequin
April 2006
187 Pages
Provided by--the Library
More...