4.92k reviews for:

Ιλιάδα

Homer

3.8 AVERAGE

adventurous challenging slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
challenging tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

reading this book is like actually being in the war. slow, never ending, and not even *that* worth it in the end

The Iliad: The Most Epic Soap Opera Ever Written

Ah, *The Iliad*—the original "why-can't-we-all-just-get-along" story. Homer really outdid himself here, didn't he? I mean, who wouldn't want to read a 700+ page poem about a ten-year temper tantrum between some of the most petty, overpowered characters ever imagined?

First off, we've got Achilles, the ultimate "I'm too cool for this war" guy who spends half the book sulking in his tent because his feelings got hurt. Then there’s Agamemnon, whose main talent seems to be making terrible decisions and annoying everyone in sight. Let’s not forget Paris, the man who single-handedly proves that you should never let a pretty face choose your spouse—or start a war.

The gods, of course, are the best part. Nothing says divine wisdom like meddling in human affairs just to see who wins a bet. Zeus and Hera’s marriage counseling sessions could probably fill a whole other epic, and who wouldn't want to hear more about Athena’s side hustle as a war strategist?

The plot? Simple: A whole lot of fighting, some crying, a few heartfelt speeches, more fighting, a bit more crying, and then finally, a giant wooden horse because, sure, that’s a logical conclusion. Spoiler alert: the horse wins.

But seriously, if you’re into endless lists of who killed whom in the bloodiest way possible, with a sprinkle of heroic speeches that make you wonder if they ever had a chance to catch their breath, this one’s for you. Just don’t expect to find out what happens after Troy falls—you’ll have to pick up another book for that. Classic Homer, always leaving us hanging.

So grab your sandals, pour a glass of ambrosia, and prepare for the most epic soap opera in history. Just be prepared for some serious déjà vu when you realize half the characters have names you can’t pronounce and the other half die before you even get to know them.
adventurous challenging dark tense medium-paced

I’m giving 5 stars for Emily Wilson’s translation. I found it engaging and very readable. 

She’s just not the Odyssey, nor is she the Aeneid. I feel like this epic is filled with repetition and far too many characters to the extent where I really didn’t care about most of them and most of them fell flat for me, even Odysseus, who barely features to be honest. I do like the themes and the questions it poses, but I do genuinely feel like the Aeneid answers and covers them far better, which makes sense since it was written over 800 years later. But still. I loved the themes of mortality vs immortality and the deaths of the young and the conversations had by Achilles and Hector where they both show an awareness of the fact that the Trojan war will kill them, and the different ways they cope with that. The best part of this book was definitely the differences between the behaviour of Achilles and Hector, how neither of them want to fight because they know they will die, but Hector fights to protect his family and city, and Achilles fights for his honour and to be cemented as the best of the Greeks.

It did have some strong points though, especially the final book and the dialogue between Priam and Achilles (especially “I have endured to do what no other mortal man on earth has done - I have brought to my lips the hands of the man who killed my child.”) and how it stands very discordant from how Achilles treats Hector. I just don’t think that I enjoyed the monotonous nature of the majority of the epic.
adventurous challenging dark tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Ts took me 5 months to read. God stuff was interesting and the mortal stuff only got good once Patroclus got there and a little bit when Achilles was there. The middle was a slog through :(
adventurous challenging medium-paced

lindacaltup's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH

It is a war book. We have enough wars right noe

What a fantastic translation by Emily Wilson. Her foreword, translator notes, and end notes are all valuable and bring fresh insights. And it has several excellent maps, which I always appreciate.