Scan barcode
dogtrax's review against another edition
4.0
A hauntingly sad book, seeping with desolation and desperation, with illustrations that will tug your heart and make you wonder at the state of the world.
tx2its's review against another edition
3.0
Reading 2020
Book(s) 103: Zenobia by Morten Durr AND Jane, the Fox, & Me by Fanny Britt
A couple of more graphic novel reviews coming at you. Again reviewing some of these together to keep things a bit more compact for the end of July.
Zenobia is the story of a Syrian girl, Amina as she struggles with the perils of war. She is put on a boat that will hopefully take her to safety. Zenobia is a great warrior that Amina keeps in her mind as she tries to get through the latest challenges. This book is reviewed for ages 10 and older, and the art is beautifully done. My rating 3⭐️.
Helene is on the receiving end of lots of ridicule from her classmates, her former friends. When she is at summer camp, lost in the pages of Jane Eyre for comfort, she meets a fox. Another girl enters Helene's life and shows her how life can be when you drown out the noise. Reviewed for ages 11 and older. Jane, the Fox, & Me is a nicely drawn graphic novel. My rating 3 ⭐️.
Book(s) 103: Zenobia by Morten Durr AND Jane, the Fox, & Me by Fanny Britt
A couple of more graphic novel reviews coming at you. Again reviewing some of these together to keep things a bit more compact for the end of July.
Zenobia is the story of a Syrian girl, Amina as she struggles with the perils of war. She is put on a boat that will hopefully take her to safety. Zenobia is a great warrior that Amina keeps in her mind as she tries to get through the latest challenges. This book is reviewed for ages 10 and older, and the art is beautifully done. My rating 3⭐️.
Helene is on the receiving end of lots of ridicule from her classmates, her former friends. When she is at summer camp, lost in the pages of Jane Eyre for comfort, she meets a fox. Another girl enters Helene's life and shows her how life can be when you drown out the noise. Reviewed for ages 11 and older. Jane, the Fox, & Me is a nicely drawn graphic novel. My rating 3 ⭐️.
maddie_hollar's review against another edition
4.0
This book was mostly beautiful, colorful, sometimes shocking, illustrations. It was the first graphic novel I’d read since Persepolis, and Zenobia was a different style, because it was more pictures than words. I really enjoyed that! It was a quick and heartbreaking read.
mariethelibrarian's review against another edition
3.0
This is a comic that leaves an impact and its quite brutal. In its simplicity. Its very serious and sad.
hereisenough's review
5.0
Well that absolutely shattered my heart and then stomped on every piece. If you need me I'll be in the cry room.
lawbooks600's review against another edition
3.0
Representation: Syrian main character
Trigger warnings: Death of a child in the ocean, military violence and war themes, refugee experiences
5/10, well well well let me tell you something, a few years back I saw this book on the shelf at one of the two libraries I go to and it looked like an interesting read to me until I actually opened it and it was so short but left an impact and ultimately it was depressing, I like that it raises awareness of refugees but I won't read this again. Where do I begin? It starts with a girl on a boat with a bunch of other asylum seekers and the boat tosses her into the sea and that's where it gets quite unique. There is a flashback to an earlier time, it is revealed the girl is called Amina and there was a scene where she played hide and seek with her mother and she lived her life until the civil war came and bombs destroyed the neighbourhood and Amina was forced to escape. Amina's mother reminded her to remember Zenobia who was an ancient queen but I don't get the point of that. The book cuts to present day where Amina sunk further into the sea but then it cuts to when her uncle sends her out onto the boat seen at the start, maybe it was to close the gap between the current time and the past, I don't know. I have one last statement to make which is that the author is a white European and he must've researched this issue before making this but perhaps it would've been better if a refugee wrote an account of their experiences. I think it's just me. Toward the end of the book Amina saw the sunken ship called Zenobia hence the title which juxtaposes the last time I saw that name however now it's in a darker light to set a hopeless mood, the final few pages were the saddest as I hear Amina's final thoughts after she dies. Wow. That's a low note. Read Illegal by Eoin Colfer or When Stars are Scattered, they're just better.
Trigger warnings: Death of a child in the ocean, military violence and war themes, refugee experiences
5/10, well well well let me tell you something, a few years back I saw this book on the shelf at one of the two libraries I go to and it looked like an interesting read to me until I actually opened it and it was so short but left an impact and ultimately it was depressing, I like that it raises awareness of refugees but I won't read this again. Where do I begin? It starts with a girl on a boat with a bunch of other asylum seekers and the boat tosses her into the sea and that's where it gets quite unique. There is a flashback to an earlier time, it is revealed the girl is called Amina and there was a scene where she played hide and seek with her mother and she lived her life until the civil war came and bombs destroyed the neighbourhood and Amina was forced to escape. Amina's mother reminded her to remember Zenobia who was an ancient queen but I don't get the point of that. The book cuts to present day where Amina sunk further into the sea but then it cuts to when her uncle sends her out onto the boat seen at the start, maybe it was to close the gap between the current time and the past, I don't know. I have one last statement to make which is that the author is a white European and he must've researched this issue before making this but perhaps it would've been better if a refugee wrote an account of their experiences. I think it's just me. Toward the end of the book Amina saw the sunken ship called Zenobia hence the title which juxtaposes the last time I saw that name however now it's in a darker light to set a hopeless mood, the final few pages were the saddest as I hear Amina's final thoughts after she dies. Wow. That's a low note. Read Illegal by Eoin Colfer or When Stars are Scattered, they're just better.
booktaintedskies's review against another edition
dark
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? N/A
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0