Scan barcode
kathydavie's review against another edition
5.0
Eleventh in the Maisie Dobbs historical mystery series and revolving around Lady Compton, a.k.a., Maisie Dobbs. There is no couple in this.
My Take
I am so angry with Maisie (and with Winspear)! Yes, it was well-written, but no, Winspear couldn't possibly let Maisie be happy. I was so hopeful for James, and I looked forward to reading of Maisie's exploits with James.
Instead, I cried and cried and cried all the way through this one almost from the very first page. Almost the only thing keeping Maisie alive is thoughts of Dr. Maurice Blanche.
The massacre at Guernica takes place during A Dangerous Place. The Spanish Civil War was a footnote we peeked at in my high school history class. There was no mention of Guernica or what the war was about. Franco was the only real name I remember. Winspear provides an emotional (to me) explanation of why the Republicans are fighting this war. It's a well-done "info dump" that does NOT read that way. Another good example for writers.
It's Maisie's experience, her past, that leads her to give Miriam some good advice.
The Story
It's a familiar world Maisie cannot face, and she gets off the ship in Gibraltar. Maybe a bit more time will make it easier to cope when she returns to England. Instead, her curiosity and compassion pull her into the Spanish Civil War with life-changing results.
The Characters
Maisie, Lady Compton, neé Dobbs, is one of very few core characters in the series we truly encounter. The rest are mentioned, write letters, beg. James, Viscount Compton, was her beloved husband. Frankie Dobbs is her father; Brenda is her stepmother. Billy Beale was Maisie's assistant during her private investigator days. The thought of his insights encourage Maisie. Priscilla Partridge is her best friend and is married to Douglas, a poet and writer. They have three sons who loved their Uncle James. Lady Rowan Compton and her husband, Lord Julian, were James' parents, and they see Maisie as their daughter.
Robbie MacFarlane is with Special Branch now. He suggests she contact David Shaw if she can't get hold of him.
Gibraltar
Mrs. Bishop runs the guest house where Maisie stays in Gibraltar. Arturo Kenyon is spying on Maisie. Mr. Salazar runs the café and looks out for Maisie. Michael Marsh is an inspector with the Gibraltar Police. Jacob Solomon owns the shop which sells Babayoff's photographs. Mr. Santos is a clerk at the Ridge Hotel.
The too-curious, selfish Sebastian Babayoff is the Jewish man who is murdered and provides Maisie the excuse she needs. Miriam and the handicapped Chana Babayoff are his surviving sisters. Carlos Grillo was a fisherman and a good friend of Sebastian's. Rosanna was Carlos' niece and loved Sebastian.
Professor Antonio Vallejo is angry with Britain's complicity in allowing German warplanes to cross the airspace in Gibraltar and refuel there. He knows Professor Francesca Thomas (A Lesson in Secrets, 8); he also studied with Dr. Maurice Blanche, Maisie's mentor. Raoul is the driver who will sneak them into Spain.
Spain
"Red Ellen" Wilkinson is a fighter for workers' rights in Britain. Felipe runs a restaurant in Madrid. Maria is a maid at the hotel. Freda Nicholls and Hattie Benson are nurses who have volunteered to work with hospitals in Spain, caring for the wounded. Sister Teresa is all the people in the small devastated village in Valencia have for medical aid. Brian Smithers is an English fighter for the Republicans.
Thomas Wright is the German who brokers war to anyone. He warns Maisie to stay away from Otterburn.
Dr. Charles Hayden was a friend of Simon Lynch's and lives in Boston with his wife, Pauline. Captain Richard Johnstone tried to keep Maisie on board the ship. Dame Constance is the abbess at Camden Abbey. Mr. Klein is Maisie's solicitor in England, and he receives special instructions regarding a fully equipped ambulance.
John Otterburn is the jerk from Elegy for Eddie, 9, with the experimental aircraft. His daughter, Elaine, is a flake.
The Cover and Title
The cover is the woodcut style I so enjoy and that the series has used in the past. This time it's Maisie in a white hat and short-sleeved blouse over a slim black skirt, her brown shoulder bag clutched to her side, one hand holding onto her hat as she looks up at the German warplanes flying over the Rock of Gibraltar in the background. The colors suit the mood in the gloomy grays and creams.
The title is about Spain during its Civil War, and yes, it is A Dangerous Place.
My Take
I am so angry with Maisie (and with Winspear)! Yes, it was well-written, but no, Winspear couldn't possibly let Maisie be happy. I was so hopeful for James, and I looked forward to reading of Maisie's exploits with James.
Instead, I cried and cried and cried all the way through this one almost from the very first page. Almost the only thing keeping Maisie alive is thoughts of Dr. Maurice Blanche.
The massacre at Guernica takes place during A Dangerous Place. The Spanish Civil War was a footnote we peeked at in my high school history class. There was no mention of Guernica or what the war was about. Franco was the only real name I remember. Winspear provides an emotional (to me) explanation of why the Republicans are fighting this war. It's a well-done "info dump" that does NOT read that way. Another good example for writers.
It's Maisie's experience, her past, that leads her to give Miriam some good advice.
The Story
It's a familiar world Maisie cannot face, and she gets off the ship in Gibraltar. Maybe a bit more time will make it easier to cope when she returns to England. Instead, her curiosity and compassion pull her into the Spanish Civil War with life-changing results.
The Characters
Maisie, Lady Compton, neé Dobbs, is one of very few core characters in the series we truly encounter. The rest are mentioned, write letters, beg. James, Viscount Compton, was her beloved husband. Frankie Dobbs is her father; Brenda is her stepmother. Billy Beale was Maisie's assistant during her private investigator days. The thought of his insights encourage Maisie. Priscilla Partridge is her best friend and is married to Douglas, a poet and writer. They have three sons who loved their Uncle James. Lady Rowan Compton and her husband, Lord Julian, were James' parents, and they see Maisie as their daughter.
Robbie MacFarlane is with Special Branch now. He suggests she contact David Shaw if she can't get hold of him.
Gibraltar
Mrs. Bishop runs the guest house where Maisie stays in Gibraltar. Arturo Kenyon is spying on Maisie. Mr. Salazar runs the café and looks out for Maisie. Michael Marsh is an inspector with the Gibraltar Police. Jacob Solomon owns the shop which sells Babayoff's photographs. Mr. Santos is a clerk at the Ridge Hotel.
The too-curious, selfish Sebastian Babayoff is the Jewish man who is murdered and provides Maisie the excuse she needs. Miriam and the handicapped Chana Babayoff are his surviving sisters. Carlos Grillo was a fisherman and a good friend of Sebastian's. Rosanna was Carlos' niece and loved Sebastian.
Professor Antonio Vallejo is angry with Britain's complicity in allowing German warplanes to cross the airspace in Gibraltar and refuel there. He knows Professor Francesca Thomas (A Lesson in Secrets, 8); he also studied with Dr. Maurice Blanche, Maisie's mentor. Raoul is the driver who will sneak them into Spain.
Spain
"Red Ellen" Wilkinson is a fighter for workers' rights in Britain. Felipe runs a restaurant in Madrid. Maria is a maid at the hotel. Freda Nicholls and Hattie Benson are nurses who have volunteered to work with hospitals in Spain, caring for the wounded. Sister Teresa is all the people in the small devastated village in Valencia have for medical aid. Brian Smithers is an English fighter for the Republicans.
Thomas Wright is the German who brokers war to anyone. He warns Maisie to stay away from Otterburn.
Dr. Charles Hayden was a friend of Simon Lynch's and lives in Boston with his wife, Pauline. Captain Richard Johnstone tried to keep Maisie on board the ship. Dame Constance is the abbess at Camden Abbey. Mr. Klein is Maisie's solicitor in England, and he receives special instructions regarding a fully equipped ambulance.
John Otterburn is the jerk from Elegy for Eddie, 9, with the experimental aircraft. His daughter, Elaine, is a flake.
The Cover and Title
The cover is the woodcut style I so enjoy and that the series has used in the past. This time it's Maisie in a white hat and short-sleeved blouse over a slim black skirt, her brown shoulder bag clutched to her side, one hand holding onto her hat as she looks up at the German warplanes flying over the Rock of Gibraltar in the background. The colors suit the mood in the gloomy grays and creams.
The title is about Spain during its Civil War, and yes, it is A Dangerous Place.
applegnreads's review against another edition
3.0
So, what was bad? The beginning. The mystery plot.
What was good? What's always good about Winspear... it's not about the mystery it's about life and coming back from a time of great grief. I'm not sure that totally makes up for the bad but some of what has made me love the Maisie Dobbs series is still here including the time period (which is not a commonly chosen one for mystery fiction), the clash of cultures and social classes and values, the introspection.
Maybe I should have given it 4 stars.
What was good? What's always good about Winspear... it's not about the mystery it's about life and coming back from a time of great grief. I'm not sure that totally makes up for the bad but some of what has made me love the Maisie Dobbs series is still here including the time period (which is not a commonly chosen one for mystery fiction), the clash of cultures and social classes and values, the introspection.
Maybe I should have given it 4 stars.
gracehickman's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.5
mouseczko's review against another edition
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
danileighta's review against another edition
4.0
After terrible, terrible events in Maisie's life, she found herself in Gilbralter, to avoid being in England and to heal. There she finds a good mystery to solve and a purpose.
I won't say much about the tragedy that drew her there, though it broke my heart, but the story itself was less a great read and more a necessary journey for Maisie. I found myself thinking it was a bit more circuitous than it needed to be, but I felt great empathy and wanted the great detective to have all the time she needed to heal her heart.
I'm still enjoying the series and moving onto Maisie's sojourn to Munich as we speak.
I won't say much about the tragedy that drew her there, though it broke my heart, but the story itself was less a great read and more a necessary journey for Maisie. I found myself thinking it was a bit more circuitous than it needed to be, but I felt great empathy and wanted the great detective to have all the time she needed to heal her heart.
I'm still enjoying the series and moving onto Maisie's sojourn to Munich as we speak.
reikista's review against another edition
5.0
Maisie is a widow and just lost her baby, and on her way to England, after going to India to hide from the world. She stops at Gibraltar because she can’t face life back home. She stumbles upon the recently murdered body of a photographer, and investigates his death as a way to heal, becoming ensnared in international spying and the Spanish Civil war.
Learn about Gibraltar’s history, the Spanish Civil war, the evolution of fascism and British responses to it, as well as about Sephardic Jews.
Learn about Gibraltar’s history, the Spanish Civil war, the evolution of fascism and British responses to it, as well as about Sephardic Jews.
melissa_who_reads's review against another edition
5.0
Again, loved this book. Maisie ends up in Gibraltar in 1937, unable to return home to England for deeply emotional issues. Across the border, civil war in Spain is raging. There is intense pressure on her to go home to England. But she stays, trying to help the family of a murder victim -- a victim she discovered in her hotel's garden.
There's not much to say here that isn't a spoiler, but the weaving of Maisie's personal struggle with her attempt to help others -- and where that attempt leads her -- is a very satisfying story.
There's not much to say here that isn't a spoiler, but the weaving of Maisie's personal struggle with her attempt to help others -- and where that attempt leads her -- is a very satisfying story.
saraelizabetha's review against another edition
emotional
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
therealkathryn's review against another edition
3.0
Piling more misery on Maisie's life was unnecessary and resulted in a story that is at times tedious. Not all bad but feels like the author is reaching to bring in new elements.
jojo_27's review against another edition
2.0
Least favorite so far. The plot was a bit tricky, I wasn't as interested in the setting, and I found multiple errors that should have been caught by a copyeditor.
I also felt a bit cheated re: James; most of the time we're around him, Maisie is uncertain. I'm not sure what makes her say yes, and we don't get any of the comfortable, happy, married time.
I also felt a bit cheated re: James; most of the time we're around him, Maisie is uncertain. I'm not sure what makes her say yes, and we don't get any of the comfortable, happy, married time.