Reviews

It Chooses You by Miranda July, Brigitte Sire

dondelingdingdong's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Are Miranda July and Lena Dunham friends?

doritobabe's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

How touching, beautiful, sad, hopeful, nostalgic, commemorative, romantic, big, hidden, sweet, and human.

I opened this book this morning and couldn't put it down until Miranda showed me what she wanted me to see.

I would highly recommend this for any lover of people and things like "Humans of New York" and "PostSecret"... Then go watch The Future and feel your heart burst and your face leak and leave a new person because now you know there is always something real to fiction; it's not always make believe.

patchworkbunny's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

We all know what it's like when you've got something you should be doing but the ever present lure of the internet sucks you in. When Miranda July was writing her screenplay for The Future, her procrastination knew no bounds. She started reading the PennySaver, a classifieds booklet that comes weekly with the junk mail. Michael was selling a leather jacket for $10. She wondered what sort of person would place that ad so she called him up and asked if she could interview him.

It Chooses You contains the interviews of the people she meets through the PennySaver, accompanied by photographs by Brigitte Sire. In the age of the internet I can understand the intrigue of these people that go for a more personal approach to selling their random stuff. Miranda asks them all if they use a computer and the answer is mostly not really. It's a little peek into the lives of others. And is quite touching in places though I did worry a bit about the sanity of some. It's certainly not the LA most of us imagine.

The photographer side of me loved the photographs. They're the kind of documentary photos that aren't going to blow you away but reveal a lot about the people, from portraits to items in their homes. There's a project called 100 Strangers whereby you approach a stranger and ask to take their photo and have a bit of a chat at the same time. Some use this as a way to improve their photography but others use it to document a little part of other people's lives. Miranda's project reminded me a little of this but with a wonderfully unique slant.

Miranda also talks a little about the film-making of The Future from the script to the inclusion of one of the people she met through the PennySaver ads. If you've seen the film, I'm sure the book would give you a bit of insight into it.

shawnasty's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional funny inspiring reflective fast-paced

5.0

sujuv's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Lovely book about which I knew very little when I started. Turned out to be about her adventures tracking down people posting classified ads on the Penny Saver and learning more about their lives ostensibly to help unstick her while writing the script for "The Future." While she realizes it's kind of a sham, it eventually does help her in writing the script. I watched about 1/3 of the film and then gave up because I was not in the mood for (spoiler) a kitty snuff film that evening (which is true most evenings). That said I really liked "Me and You and Everyone We Know" and after reading this book will revisit "The Future" through the magic of Netflix streaming and give it a second chance.

meghan111's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Namaste can be translated in a lot of ways; most recently my yoga teacher gave its meaning as, "The divine mystery in me greets the divine mystery in you." And that's what Miranda July is doing in this book. By answering classified ads from the Pennysaver and interviewing the people who placed them. "All I ever really want to know is how other people are making it through life - where do they put their body, hour by hour, and how do they cope inside of it."

kathrinpassig's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Ich hab es eigentlich nur wegen der sehr guten Prokrastinationsgeschichte in der Einleitung gelesen und bin dann dran hängengeblieben. Am Ende geht es um Kunst, also, wie Kunst eigentlich funktioniert. Die Lektüre war einerseits tröstlich: Man kann die ganze Zeit nur Blödsinn machen und herumpfuschen und scheitern. Andererseits beunruhigend: Man müsste das alles viel ernster nehmen, als ich es tue, dann käme auch was Interessantes dabei heraus. Würde auch fünf Sterne geben, vermute aber, dass ich demnächst alles wieder vergessen werde, deshalb nur vier.

trstn's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional funny reflective

4.0

sunscour's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

The ending was fantastic, had to slog through a lot of "oh poor sad me" to get there....

missloflipo's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Cuando hace años vi El futuro, la película que estrenó Miranda July en 2011 sobre la crisis existencial de una pareja de treintañeros -y esto es resumir el argumento mucho, pero mucho- no supe que un año después la directora publicaría este libro. Lo sabría bastante tiempo después y hasta hace un par de semanas no he tenido la oportunidad de leerlo.

Ni siquiera estaba segura del tipo de libro que es Te elige, pero que fuese obra de July era todo lo que necesitaba para estar interesada. El caso es que después de devorarlo sigo sin poder clasificarlo del todo. Esta maravilla es a la vez un ensayo, un diario y un reportaje social tan excéntrico como la propia autora.

Miranda sufrió una crisis creativa durante la escritura del guión de El futuro pero todo lo que podía hacer al respecto era ver videos en YouTube y leer compulsivamente los anuncios clasificados de la revista Pennysavers. Estaba totalmente intrigada por saber quiénes vendían a través de esas páginas cosas tan prescindibles como secadores de pelo viejos, álbumes de fotos ajenos o chaquetas desgastadas.

Abandonada totalmente a la procrastinación, decidió que tenía que entrevistar a esas personas y saber qué lugar ocupaban en el mundo. Se acompañó de la fotógrafa Brigitte Sire y se plantó en las casas de varios desconocidos sin tener claro el fin de todo eso. El proyecto tomó forma al mismo tiempo que se desarrollaba. Tanto es así que este experimento terminó siendo todo un viaje de autoexploración y un retrato de esas personas alejadas del glamour y del ritmo frenético de Los Ángeles. De hecho incorporó su experiencia al guión de la película y consiguió profundizar en un personaje que tenía atascado dotándolo de un motivo.

No puedo contar mucho más al respecto sin estropear el factor sorpresa del libro, pero sin estas entrevistas la película hubiese sido otra totalmente diferente. Estoy deseando verla de nuevo ahora que tengo una visión mucho más amplia de la directora y del proceso de creación que llevó a cabo. Va a ser divertido comprobar cómo hemos envejecido tanto la película como yo.

Ojalá podáis leer Te elige alguna vez porque la dosis de realidad contra la que se estrella Miranda es la misma con la que me ha golpeado en la cara, y de verdad, el puñetazo merece la pena. Ni la dulzura, ni la genialidad ni el fantástico sentido del humor de la autora me han librado de él.