Scan barcode
katiewo's review against another edition
dark
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.75
crow43's review against another edition
5.0
Reading this was mind-blown, my first dyostpian book. The different main character's perspectives and plot twists were amazing, my reaction were shocked, anger, confused and heartbreaking,I did come across some questions of my own though a reread would probably solve it. Also possibly tab and make notes next time 😅 Rate: 5/5 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Spoilers:
The first plot twist was unexpected but made sense in a way I understood how it became what the book is about. Scythe Goddard annoyed me so much yet he played a good villain. Declaring that Citra and Rowan should glean one another to decide who gets to be the scythe!
I was shocked and couldn't believe Scythe Faraday would gleaned himself but I knew something was fishy, then later in the book turns out he was hiding, I was so overjoyed! Though Citra gets fucking blamed for murder of her past mentor??? Come on >o< I was thinking it had to be Goddard but turns out it wasn't, but it amazed me on how smart and diligent Citra was. With hacking into the backbrain of Thunderhead, trying to backtrack to Faraday's last moment. It was just so much to take in and catch up.
I was hoping Goddard would be killed somehow and boy was I happy he was. By Rowan himself who he himself is called Scythe Lucifer later on! Citra last test to be a scythe took my breath away, she had to do the unthinkable act to be the next or rather bring the true justice of what scythedom was about. Her gleaning her own brother had to take alot on her, I tried not to cry lol because I can't imagine myself doing it to a love one of my own.
Scythe Faraday is my most favorite of all, the good guy in the book. His way of scythhood was compassionate and rendered with his consciousness. I pictured myself as him if I were a scythe. His existence I believe is who I believe made Citra who she is but not entirely, there's Scythe Curie who I also admired as well. It took me awhile to understand her way of scythhood and how she thought of humanity from her journal entries. Volta was another Scythe I really liked, he was not like any other or rather like Goddard's disciples. He had no choice to do what he had to but his suicide tore me abit because I really felt bad for him, he never wanted to hurt people that was not in the scythedom rules or just for pleasures.
I truly thought Rowan was going to be my favorite character throughout the book but not as much as Citra. I thought he was influencial, being under Goddard as his mentor he had. His motive to protect Citra to the end in which he did, but there were times I thought he would turn into Goddard. He was more of a finding my true identity within scythehood. Then I understood what Rowan's motive in the end with not being an offical scythe but to bring justice by getting rid of the false and overbearing bad scythes that bring shame of scythehood. So you could say it goes hand to hand on these two main characters, both of them had really amazing development throughout the book overall.
I was happy with what Citra did to save Rowan in order to free him just like how Scythe Curie did for her to escape from being punished and possibly gleaned! I didn't want neither of them to be gleaned or cast out of the book. I will say I didn't like the romance, it was better off as friends, the love/liking eachother was too unrealistic for either of them to be in that way. Though I understood why Rowan really liked Citra, his way and her way of protecting another was precious in a way best friends would've done for eachother!
If I have upset or misunderstood anyone with my review, feel free to correct my mistake. I have my way of understanding I'd like to hear/read yours!
Spoilers:
The first plot twist was unexpected but made sense in a way I understood how it became what the book is about. Scythe Goddard annoyed me so much yet he played a good villain. Declaring that Citra and Rowan should glean one another to decide who gets to be the scythe!
I was shocked and couldn't believe Scythe Faraday would gleaned himself but I knew something was fishy, then later in the book turns out he was hiding, I was so overjoyed! Though Citra gets fucking blamed for murder of her past mentor??? Come on >o< I was thinking it had to be Goddard but turns out it wasn't, but it amazed me on how smart and diligent Citra was. With hacking into the backbrain of Thunderhead, trying to backtrack to Faraday's last moment. It was just so much to take in and catch up.
I was hoping Goddard would be killed somehow and boy was I happy he was. By Rowan himself who he himself is called Scythe Lucifer later on! Citra last test to be a scythe took my breath away, she had to do the unthinkable act to be the next or rather bring the true justice of what scythedom was about. Her gleaning her own brother had to take alot on her, I tried not to cry lol because I can't imagine myself doing it to a love one of my own.
Scythe Faraday is my most favorite of all, the good guy in the book. His way of scythhood was compassionate and rendered with his consciousness. I pictured myself as him if I were a scythe. His existence I believe is who I believe made Citra who she is but not entirely, there's Scythe Curie who I also admired as well. It took me awhile to understand her way of scythhood and how she thought of humanity from her journal entries. Volta was another Scythe I really liked, he was not like any other or rather like Goddard's disciples. He had no choice to do what he had to but his suicide tore me abit because I really felt bad for him, he never wanted to hurt people that was not in the scythedom rules or just for pleasures.
I truly thought Rowan was going to be my favorite character throughout the book but not as much as Citra. I thought he was influencial, being under Goddard as his mentor he had. His motive to protect Citra to the end in which he did, but there were times I thought he would turn into Goddard. He was more of a finding my true identity within scythehood. Then I understood what Rowan's motive in the end with not being an offical scythe but to bring justice by getting rid of the false and overbearing bad scythes that bring shame of scythehood. So you could say it goes hand to hand on these two main characters, both of them had really amazing development throughout the book overall.
I was happy with what Citra did to save Rowan in order to free him just like how Scythe Curie did for her to escape from being punished and possibly gleaned! I didn't want neither of them to be gleaned or cast out of the book. I will say I didn't like the romance, it was better off as friends, the love/liking eachother was too unrealistic for either of them to be in that way. Though I understood why Rowan really liked Citra, his way and her way of protecting another was precious in a way best friends would've done for eachother!
If I have upset or misunderstood anyone with my review, feel free to correct my mistake. I have my way of understanding I'd like to hear/read yours!
baphomeow's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
cmrams's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
4.5
olamroczek's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5
laudis98's review against another edition
dark
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
dumb_library's review against another edition
3.0
I’m.....very sad I didn’t enjoy this book. I honestly thought I would adore it and at first, I was super into the story. I think the story really fell flat for me when it came to the romance. Like....it was so unnecessary and done so poorly in my opinion. It threw me off and I couldn’t get back into the story. I DNF’d this book pretty close to the end.