Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.08 AVERAGE
4.08 AVERAGE
Third in The Royal Ranger series (and fourteenth in the overall Ranger's Apprentice series) for middle-grade readers and revolving around Princess Madelyn who is apprenticing as Maddie, a Ranger. The Skandians from the Brotherband Chronicles also appear.
My Take
Duel at Araluen continues on from where The Red Fox Clan, 2, left off.
I did enjoy the conclusion of the events that started in book 2. I do wish, however, that Flanagan had made the action more exciting. It was rather ho-hum. I don't know if it was because the action was so spread out or if the fewer pages prevented Flanagan from digging in. I know I would have liked more of a sense of the suffering Horace, Cassandra, and Maddie were going through. Worries about each other, difficulties in penetrating their siege forces, a lack of food, the fear...
Nor did we get much interaction with the characters with Flanagan barely touching on any of the minor characters in any group. And this includes barely touching on the brotherbands!
Instead it was all just too easy and uninformative.
It's always such a shock for one's parents when they discover just how good you are. Maddie shocks the Skandians as well with her skills. It helps that Flanagan uses third-person global subjective point-of-view, as it allows us to peek in on everyone and hear their thoughts, their plans, and "participate" in their scenes without requiring Maddie's presence.
I also appreciate Maddie's practicality. She takes pride in her skills but is humble enough to know when to step back. A good point to discuss with your kids, lol.
Flanagan is always good for the moral lessons, including why a Ranger should not accept free gifts and why Cassandra is so beloved — just the opposite of Vikor Trask. Oy. There's a touch on bullying here, making this a trifecta of discussion points.
I do enjoy the tactics and strategy that each group — Cassandra in the tower at the castle, Horace and Gilan at the hill fort, Dimon who has taken the castle, and Maddie with the Skandians — plan out and employ, making it personal, albeit too easy.
And everyone learns that Maddie is an apprentice Ranger.
The Story
With her family trapped in two separate camps, Maddie has her work cut out for her. Neither her father nor her mother will escape the Red Fox Clan sieges without her help.
Even Maddie will need help, and lucky for her, the Heron brotherband and their friends are eager to leap into the fray.
But will they be able to help her father break out...? Will they reach Castle Araluen before the traitor kills her mother?
The Characters
Princess Madelyn is also Ranger's apprentice Maddie in her fourth year. Bumper is her psychic, practical-joke-loving Ranger horse. Ingrid is Princess Madelyn's maid, although she really takes to the tasks of quartermaster while they're under siege.
Princess Cassandra, a.k.a., Evanlyn, is her father's heir, the ailing King Duncan "Bandylegs". Sir Horace is Cassandra's husband, the commander of the army with expertise as a strategist and tactician, and the paramount knight of the realm. Stamper is Sir Horace's battlehorse.
Sergeant Merlon is in charge of the palace guards who include Proctor as a cook, the archers — the senior Thomas, the young Dermott, and Simon — Jeremy, and Jerrod. Maikeru, a Nihon-Jan master swordsman and Cassandra's instructor, held Dimon and his men at bay in The Red Fox Clan. He didn't survive. Uldred is the head librarian who helped Maddie. Timothy is one of Cassandra's senior retainers in charge of the dining room.
Castle Araluen is the primary seat of government while Castle Redmont is home for the retired Halt and his Lady Pauline and near Will Treaty's home. Baron Hexel is in charge in the northwest.
The hill fort near Harnel Village is...
...where Horace, Gilan, and his men are trapped. Sergeant Nilson is one of Horace's men.
The Rangers is...
...an elite special forces unit with Ranger Gilan as the commandant, having taken over from Halt. Blaze is Gilan's Ranger horse. Other Rangers include the barely there Will Treaty (Ranger's Apprentice) who is mentoring Maddie. Sable is Will's border shepherd.
The Skandians are...
...allies of Duncan and Cassandra (with their own spin-off series, the Brotherband Chronicles) and led by Oberjarl Erak.
Hal Mikkelson, young but an experienced shipwright, is the skirl of the Heron and his crew includes his best friend and first mate, Stig; Ingvar, who is a huge and strong warrior with bad eyesight; Thorn; Edvin who is their healer and cook; Jesper is a bit too jokey; Lydia normally watches Ingvar's back but she stayed in Skandia this trip; Stefan; and, the twins, Ulf and Wulf.
Wolfbiter, the assigned duty ship, is damaged and captained by Jern. Sten Engleson is his first mate with Lars and Blorst Knucklewhite among the eighteen crewmen.
The Red Fox Clan is...
...a subversive organization that wants to rollback Cassandra's grandfather's decree that the oldest child, regardless of sex, inherits the throne. Sir Dimon, a distant relative of Cassandra's, infiltrated and rose to become their leader even as he acted as the commander of the Palace Guard. Ronald is an engineer.
The Sonderland mercenaries are...
...notorious and allied with the Red Fox Clan. Their leader is a cowardly clueless fighter, Vikor Trask. Ruka Bel is a young officer and good tactician.
The Cover and Title
The cover is the end with Maddie in her Ranger's cloak and leather pants and shirt, concentrating on her target, bow ready and arrow cocked. The long-haired Princess Cassandra, her mother, is in the background, whirling in the two-storied room with its arched windows on both floors, her katana in hand, in a duel for her life. The double series information is at the very top. The overall series is in an embossed and antiqued silver, fading into the roof while the information for this particular series is much tinier beneath it in an embossed copper that doesn't fade quite as badly. The title is an embossed hammered silver just above Maddie's knees with an info blurb in white below the title. The author's name is in a hammered gold below that.
The title is the final Duel at Araluen between Cassandra and Dimon.
My Take
Duel at Araluen continues on from where The Red Fox Clan, 2, left off.
I did enjoy the conclusion of the events that started in book 2. I do wish, however, that Flanagan had made the action more exciting. It was rather ho-hum. I don't know if it was because the action was so spread out or if the fewer pages prevented Flanagan from digging in. I know I would have liked more of a sense of the suffering Horace, Cassandra, and Maddie were going through. Worries about each other, difficulties in penetrating their siege forces, a lack of food, the fear...
Nor did we get much interaction with the characters with Flanagan barely touching on any of the minor characters in any group. And this includes barely touching on the brotherbands!
Instead it was all just too easy and uninformative.
It's always such a shock for one's parents when they discover just how good you are. Maddie shocks the Skandians as well with her skills. It helps that Flanagan uses third-person global subjective point-of-view, as it allows us to peek in on everyone and hear their thoughts, their plans, and "participate" in their scenes without requiring Maddie's presence.
I also appreciate Maddie's practicality. She takes pride in her skills but is humble enough to know when to step back. A good point to discuss with your kids, lol.
Flanagan is always good for the moral lessons, including why a Ranger should not accept free gifts and why Cassandra is so beloved — just the opposite of Vikor Trask. Oy. There's a touch on bullying here, making this a trifecta of discussion points.
I do enjoy the tactics and strategy that each group — Cassandra in the tower at the castle, Horace and Gilan at the hill fort, Dimon who has taken the castle, and Maddie with the Skandians — plan out and employ, making it personal, albeit too easy.
And everyone learns that Maddie is an apprentice Ranger.
The Story
With her family trapped in two separate camps, Maddie has her work cut out for her. Neither her father nor her mother will escape the Red Fox Clan sieges without her help.
Even Maddie will need help, and lucky for her, the Heron brotherband and their friends are eager to leap into the fray.
But will they be able to help her father break out...? Will they reach Castle Araluen before the traitor kills her mother?
The Characters
Princess Madelyn is also Ranger's apprentice Maddie in her fourth year. Bumper is her psychic, practical-joke-loving Ranger horse. Ingrid is Princess Madelyn's maid, although she really takes to the tasks of quartermaster while they're under siege.
Princess Cassandra, a.k.a., Evanlyn, is her father's heir, the ailing King Duncan "Bandylegs". Sir Horace is Cassandra's husband, the commander of the army with expertise as a strategist and tactician, and the paramount knight of the realm. Stamper is Sir Horace's battlehorse.
Sergeant Merlon is in charge of the palace guards who include Proctor as a cook, the archers — the senior Thomas, the young Dermott, and Simon — Jeremy, and Jerrod. Maikeru, a Nihon-Jan master swordsman and Cassandra's instructor, held Dimon and his men at bay in The Red Fox Clan. He didn't survive. Uldred is the head librarian who helped Maddie. Timothy is one of Cassandra's senior retainers in charge of the dining room.
Castle Araluen is the primary seat of government while Castle Redmont is home for the retired Halt and his Lady Pauline and near Will Treaty's home. Baron Hexel is in charge in the northwest.
The hill fort near Harnel Village is...
...where Horace, Gilan, and his men are trapped. Sergeant Nilson is one of Horace's men.
The Rangers is...
...an elite special forces unit with Ranger Gilan as the commandant, having taken over from Halt. Blaze is Gilan's Ranger horse. Other Rangers include the barely there Will Treaty (Ranger's Apprentice) who is mentoring Maddie. Sable is Will's border shepherd.
The Skandians are...
...allies of Duncan and Cassandra (with their own spin-off series, the Brotherband Chronicles) and led by Oberjarl Erak.
Hal Mikkelson, young but an experienced shipwright, is the skirl of the Heron and his crew includes his best friend and first mate, Stig; Ingvar, who is a huge and strong warrior with bad eyesight; Thorn; Edvin who is their healer and cook; Jesper is a bit too jokey; Lydia normally watches Ingvar's back but she stayed in Skandia this trip; Stefan; and, the twins, Ulf and Wulf.
Wolfbiter, the assigned duty ship, is damaged and captained by Jern. Sten Engleson is his first mate with Lars and Blorst Knucklewhite among the eighteen crewmen.
The Red Fox Clan is...
...a subversive organization that wants to rollback Cassandra's grandfather's decree that the oldest child, regardless of sex, inherits the throne. Sir Dimon, a distant relative of Cassandra's, infiltrated and rose to become their leader even as he acted as the commander of the Palace Guard. Ronald is an engineer.
The Sonderland mercenaries are...
...notorious and allied with the Red Fox Clan. Their leader is a cowardly clueless fighter, Vikor Trask. Ruka Bel is a young officer and good tactician.
The Cover and Title
The cover is the end with Maddie in her Ranger's cloak and leather pants and shirt, concentrating on her target, bow ready and arrow cocked. The long-haired Princess Cassandra, her mother, is in the background, whirling in the two-storied room with its arched windows on both floors, her katana in hand, in a duel for her life. The double series information is at the very top. The overall series is in an embossed and antiqued silver, fading into the roof while the information for this particular series is much tinier beneath it in an embossed copper that doesn't fade quite as badly. The title is an embossed hammered silver just above Maddie's knees with an info blurb in white below the title. The author's name is in a hammered gold below that.
The title is the final Duel at Araluen between Cassandra and Dimon.
adventurous
funny
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
adventurous
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
3.5* stars
ok actually i skimmed like 20% of this book, because for the life of me I can NOT focus on battles.
And this book is one big battle. Just contant pages and pages of fighting and swords and blablablabla.
anyway maddie is an icon and so are Gilan and Horace.
Cassandra honestly got herself lowered in the ranks since I started reading Royal Ranger cause she is made to be an overworried mother when she herself was/is quite an adventurer
ok actually i skimmed like 20% of this book, because for the life of me I can NOT focus on battles.
And this book is one big battle. Just contant pages and pages of fighting and swords and blablablabla.
anyway maddie is an icon and so are Gilan and Horace.
Cassandra honestly got herself lowered in the ranks since I started reading Royal Ranger cause she is made to be an overworried mother when she herself was/is quite an adventurer
My friend and I are reading this series together and we were both happy to have guessed the ending of this book. We actually were looking forward to the final fight! I love Maddie and I was glad to see the Herons again in this book.
I am certainly looking forward to reading the next book in Maddie's story.
I am certainly looking forward to reading the next book in Maddie's story.
Seit vielen Jahren lese ich jedes neue Buch, das in Araluen spielt. Dazu gehört nämlich nicht nur die Hauptreihe „Die Chroniken von Araluen“, sondern auch die Prequel-Reihe „Wie Alles begann“ sowie die Nebenreihe „Brotherband“. Insgesamt sind es nun schon 21 Bücher, die sich weltweit millionenfach verkauft haben. Besonders gefallen mir bei John Flanagan immer die Bücher, die die Handlung des vorherigen Bands direkt fortführen – denn Flanagan hat ein besonderes Händchen für Kliffhänger aller Art. So ging es mir auch bei diesem Band, den ich in wenigen Tagen durchgelesen habe.
Im Zentrum der Handlung stehen stets die „Waldläufer“, die fast so etwas wie ein königlicher Geheimdienst von Araluen sind. Dabei verlassen sie sich jedoch völlig auf ihre lang trainierten Fähigkeiten – was unter anderem den Umgang mit Pfeil und Bogen, sowie die Kunst des Verbergens angeht, in beiden Fällen bringen sie es während ihrer Ausbildung zur Meisterschaft. Eigentlich könnte man die Waldläufer auch als sehr lustige Variante von Assassinen bezeichnen. In den Meisten Bänden nimmt die Ausbildung der Waldläufer einen großen – und sehr spannenden – Teil der Handlung ein, jedoch nicht in diesem Band, der sich nur um die Bedrohung für das Königreich dreht.
Ein anderes Merkmal, das alle Araluen-Bücher ausmacht, sind die teilweise sehr abgefahrenen Pläne, die sich die Waldläufer stets ausdenken. Beinahe so häufig wie die Ausbildung der Waldläufer bilden detaillierte Strategien das Zentrum der Handlung. Teilweise sind die Pläne so perfekt, dass der Sieg schon selbstverständlich ist. Umso überraschender kamen im Laufe der Reihe deswegen auch die Momente, in denen es mal schlecht ausging – entsprechend sind sie auch die Höhepunkte der gesamten Reihe. Und ohne zu viel zu verraten: wie jedes gute Buch von John Flanagan, endete „Im Bann des Dunklen Ordens“ mit einem Duell. Aber mehr möchte ich darüber nicht verraten.
Doch es gibt einen Punkt, in dem ich den cbj Verlag kritisieren muss und es ist schon der gleiche wie in meiner Rezension zu Band 13: denn im australischen Original sind Band 12, 13 und 14 gar nicht Teil der Hauptreihe, sondern einer Sequel-Reihe (also einer nach der Haupthandlung spielenden Reihe). Und das hat auch seine Gründe: denn im Zentrum der Handlung steht nicht der alte Hauptcharakter Will, sondern eine neue Protagonistin namens Lynnie.
Das ist aber noch nicht alles. Denn selbst in der deutschen Übersetzung gibt es Unterschiede in den Buchtiteln: fangen die Titel der ersten elf Bände noch alle gleichmäßig und ausnahmslos mit einem Artikel an, wurde ab Band 13 (dem eigentlichen zweiten Band der Prequel-Reihe) damit gebrochen. Wenn schon Hauptreihe, dann bitte auch nicht mit alten Gewohntheiten brechen!
Aber dieser Kritikpunkt konnte mir natürlich nicht den Spaß am Lesen nehmen. Die neuen (und alten) Running-Gags sind immer noch witzig und manchmal habe ich sogar das Gefühl, es wird mit der Zeit immer witziger. Wieder zurück in Araluen zu sein, hat etwas von nachhause kommen, von Entspannung und Vergnügen. Von daher erneut ein Appel an alle jungen (und auch an alle älteren Leser): die Chroniken von Araluen sind es Wert, gelesen zu werden – tut es.
Im Zentrum der Handlung stehen stets die „Waldläufer“, die fast so etwas wie ein königlicher Geheimdienst von Araluen sind. Dabei verlassen sie sich jedoch völlig auf ihre lang trainierten Fähigkeiten – was unter anderem den Umgang mit Pfeil und Bogen, sowie die Kunst des Verbergens angeht, in beiden Fällen bringen sie es während ihrer Ausbildung zur Meisterschaft. Eigentlich könnte man die Waldläufer auch als sehr lustige Variante von Assassinen bezeichnen. In den Meisten Bänden nimmt die Ausbildung der Waldläufer einen großen – und sehr spannenden – Teil der Handlung ein, jedoch nicht in diesem Band, der sich nur um die Bedrohung für das Königreich dreht.
Ein anderes Merkmal, das alle Araluen-Bücher ausmacht, sind die teilweise sehr abgefahrenen Pläne, die sich die Waldläufer stets ausdenken. Beinahe so häufig wie die Ausbildung der Waldläufer bilden detaillierte Strategien das Zentrum der Handlung. Teilweise sind die Pläne so perfekt, dass der Sieg schon selbstverständlich ist. Umso überraschender kamen im Laufe der Reihe deswegen auch die Momente, in denen es mal schlecht ausging – entsprechend sind sie auch die Höhepunkte der gesamten Reihe. Und ohne zu viel zu verraten: wie jedes gute Buch von John Flanagan, endete „Im Bann des Dunklen Ordens“ mit einem Duell. Aber mehr möchte ich darüber nicht verraten.
Doch es gibt einen Punkt, in dem ich den cbj Verlag kritisieren muss und es ist schon der gleiche wie in meiner Rezension zu Band 13: denn im australischen Original sind Band 12, 13 und 14 gar nicht Teil der Hauptreihe, sondern einer Sequel-Reihe (also einer nach der Haupthandlung spielenden Reihe). Und das hat auch seine Gründe: denn im Zentrum der Handlung steht nicht der alte Hauptcharakter Will, sondern eine neue Protagonistin namens Lynnie.
Das ist aber noch nicht alles. Denn selbst in der deutschen Übersetzung gibt es Unterschiede in den Buchtiteln: fangen die Titel der ersten elf Bände noch alle gleichmäßig und ausnahmslos mit einem Artikel an, wurde ab Band 13 (dem eigentlichen zweiten Band der Prequel-Reihe) damit gebrochen. Wenn schon Hauptreihe, dann bitte auch nicht mit alten Gewohntheiten brechen!
Aber dieser Kritikpunkt konnte mir natürlich nicht den Spaß am Lesen nehmen. Die neuen (und alten) Running-Gags sind immer noch witzig und manchmal habe ich sogar das Gefühl, es wird mit der Zeit immer witziger. Wieder zurück in Araluen zu sein, hat etwas von nachhause kommen, von Entspannung und Vergnügen. Von daher erneut ein Appel an alle jungen (und auch an alle älteren Leser): die Chroniken von Araluen sind es Wert, gelesen zu werden – tut es.
adventurous
emotional
medium-paced
funny
lighthearted
relaxing
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
The book is diverse in the characters gender, but not in other ways.
adventurous
funny
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
3.5 stars
it was a bit boring, but i enjoyed it nonetheless
it was a bit boring, but i enjoyed it nonetheless