emotional inspiring reflective slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

angelajuniper's review

4.0

I have not read 'Confessions', despite it sitting on my TBR for longer than I can remember. This letter from Floria, St. Augustine's discarded lover, to the infamous bishop of Hippo is an eye-opener into the life of a zealot and those affected by such religious fervour. Strangely captivating.
zamakodknjiga's profile picture

zamakodknjiga's review

4.75
dark reflective tense fast-paced

I still feel shudder in my body after finishing this book. Once again, this book has proven why I enjoy reading amazing creations by Jostein Gaarder. Let's be clear at beginning - this wasn't type of books I love to read definetly. For some reason, the medieval philosophy is most uncomfortable for me. Jostein Gaarder still has incredible skill to make me fall in love in anything he has written and to start looking it from another perspective.

The scariest thing about this book is that it's based on true events. The author's "job" was 'just' to translate it from Latin to Norway.

One part, I think it's VIII or IX letter from Floria made me feel so anxious. I find myself in Floria and find my ex in Augustine. Both of them became theologists. The way Augustine treated Floria when he thought she's the reason because he can't find peace within himself was red flag for my previous relationship.

While I was reading whole book I had the same thought: "How are theologians, who consider themselves as God's envoys, so simple that they only consider their beliefs as true and judge everything which is opposite - and often their beliefs are the most primitive and the most subjective which just prove that they are unable to portray God who represents 'universal' and who was so diligently making the whole world."

It looks like they are so depressive and lonely so they twist the truth which the God has send to them. (This is just my opinion, that doesn't mean it's right!)

I was a little bit bored when Floria told Augustine the same thing for the fifth time, but I guess that she's just trying to let betrayal she feel out. If we analayte how he treated her, he made a lot of sins for a Saint. He spend his whole life betraying himself and he thought that's will bring him closer to the God. Maybe it did, but I don't think that mindset is healthy.

We are talking about 4th century, but mentality hasn't change a lot. It seems like people use faith to wash people's brain and manipulate. That's might not be truth. I believe God is more then what He's envoys try to show us.

UPDATE FROM 2023. (3 YEARS LATER)

Wow, okay... This was really deep. I'm very happy that I was able to re-read this book from whole other perspective - when I healed a lot after a break up with theologist. I did identify with Floria then, but it was right after the break up... Now, I identify with her even more! And I feel enormus pain for what she had gone through!

I think that Floria's confession was really important document to show how blindness and obsession with something can turn into something so unhealthy even if it seems like it makes you feel good... At the other side, it shows the diferent perceptions of God and how the Christianization society then... It was rather creepy what she has to go through so Augustin could feel "clean" in front of God. And, it does show her view of life being to short to spend it numb to all of the earth experiences when you're living on it.

Some parts of her confession was repetitive, but I didn't really mind it because I could understand why she's bringing it up. It was really healing to read this one! Floria is indeed one really smart person.

The only "problem" I saw was that there's a lot of references and I have to check it even if I don't need it and that grabbed my attention and slowed down the reading of the relatively thin book.

And for the end, I must say that I love the backstory of how Jostein find the letters in the first place!!! <333
earlapvaldez's profile picture

earlapvaldez's review

4.0

Of course one has to take note of the fact that Codex Floriae is nothing but a fictional work, as evidently shown in the style that Gaarder uses in composing the letter. One gets the feeling that it is not as medieval and modern as Augustine would have written a work.

Nevertheless, I believe that this is a book on love lost and how one remembers it as grace.
rixx's profile picture

rixx's review

1.0

Jostein Gaarder is hit-and-miss for me at the best of times, and this wasn't the best of times. *Vita Brevis* is the fictional letter (complete with frame plot about finding it in an old book store blah blah) of St Augustine's wife to the man himself after he became famous. It's St Augustine fanfiction. Not my genre.
informative inspiring reflective slow-paced
inthelunaseas's profile picture

inthelunaseas's review

3.0

[a:Jostein Gaarder|1388082|Jostein Gaarder|http://photo.goodreads.com/authors/1271411783p2/1388082.jpg] is one of my favourite authors, so I'm torn on what to think of this book- one that carries his name, but is allegedly not written by him. I don't believe the letters are real. Gaarder gives a little tongue-in-cheek mention at the end about the truthfulness of these leters:

And indeed, it was incredibly naive of me not to ask the Vatican Library for a receipt at least!

This is basically his way of saying, sup guys, this is just a fictional story, like Sophie's World and The Solitaire Mystery. There's also the fact that Floria writes out several parts of St. Augustine's Confessions verbatim, she also meanders throughout the letters, repeating herself a number of times. She keeps falling back to the part where he asks her if she's ever been to Rome. This continual memory flashback bothers me. It doesn't strike me as true. Floria just strikes me also as being too much of a modern woman. Now, who's to say that the woman of the 4th Century and the woman of the 21st Century aren't very much alike in terms of pre-marital sex, the Catholic Church and sin? But ultimately I just found the entire thing to be too unlikely.

Now, none of this isn't to say the Gaarder made the whole thing up. It is likely he found a letter in Buenos Aires that was supposedly from Augstine's concubine, and it turned out to be a fake. That's definitely possibly. But [b:Vita Brevis|29648|Vita Brevis A Letter to St Augustine|Jostein Gaarder|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1168035944s/29648.jpg|30079] being the true thing? Yeah, unlikely. Still, this is a nice, romantic, bittersweet and very quick read.
emotional informative inspiring reflective sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

twinofarabella's review

5.0

I got this book in the most random way possible and I instantaneously fell in love with Gaarder.

apfel's review

1.5
reflective slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: N/A