3.59 AVERAGE

notesonbookmarks's profile picture

notesonbookmarks's review

3.0

This book was rather predictable, and I saw whole plot arc coming from the first 40 pages, but it was sweet and fun and lovely (just like I imagine coconut cake must be). Lou owns a restaurant (French, because her overbearing fiance said so, but she could cook anything anywhere). Al is a scathing food critic who writes under a pseudonym and hates living in Milwaukee. You already know where this is going, right? doesn't matter. it's still a fun read, and I enjoyed it.
Made a lovely, if unintentional, book flight with Kitchens of the Great Midwest - another fun foodie Midwest jaunt, albeit with more serious themes sprinkled in.

kristenbeck's review

4.0

It took some time to get into the flow of the story but I really enjoyed it by the end. It's a fun quick read about a chef who's business is destroyed by a food critic that she happens to fall in love with (because she doesn't know it's him). And now I'm craving coconut cake!

bigsexy's review

2.0

Meh. Boring but the coconut cake recipe at the end sounds delicious.

nourin_s's review

3.0

Just a round the mill book about food. I truly did not see the chemistry between the leads but, I really liked their character arc and the growth they had individually. Together they did not seem to compliment each other. The romance element was not great but, it was a good read.

hilse's review

3.0

2.5 of 5

A couple of things let me from liking this as much as I would have liked...
- Both Lou and Al felt like parodies of characters.
- Plot felt more like a "visit Milwaukee” pamphlet than an actual series of events and character growth. Don't get me wrong - I love what Reichert had done with her setting and Milwaukee is a great backdrop for the story. But the plot doesn't work as a a love story to Milwaukee, in my view. Too much of the store is focused on the relationship between Lou and Al.

I can understand why the publishers didn't market this as a romance (genre snobbery is real!) but this is a contemporary romance novel. The entire book is about the pursuit of a happily-ever-after.

alliepeduto's review

3.0

As a romance, this was actually pretty terrible. But it gets a 5/5 as an advertisement for Milwaukee. Considering I only picked this up since I was traveling to the city it was about, I’m giving it a bit more credit than I normally would. Honestly, it seemed more like a love letter to Milwaukee than a love story between the main characters, but that served my purpose in reading it! If you’re going to Milwaukee and want a quick read that won’t take up space in your brain, this is perfect. For any other reason I would just give it a pass.
emotional hopeful inspiring medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes

I love a foodie story, especially a foodie romance (Simmer Down, With the Fire On High, etc.). But this fell very flat. Not compelling and the narrator was terrible - very monotone and I can't get over her pronunciation of "confit" (con-fit). I realize not everyone was a French major but geez.
caseymalsam's profile picture

caseymalsam's review

3.0

A quick and predicable read. A delightful summer beach read.
whitmc's profile picture

whitmc's review

3.0

Entertaining but painfully predictable. And I'm fine with a basic story that is painfully predictable, it's often comforting, but then it was to be coupled with great writing, tiny internal twists, and/or funny unexpected moments along the way. This had good food descriptions, not great, but good. And likeable characters, so it was a quick read.