Reviews

Caught by the Scot by Karen Hawkins

nellesnightstand1's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This was a sweet and sad book. To have lost your sister who was more like a mother to you and learn that her will requires you to marry in order to keep your inheritance would suck. Who wants to marry within 3 months of your sister's death?
Connor knows just who he'll marry! His longtime friend Thea! She'll be no trouble at ALL and won't mind him being at sea as long as she has a home to manage. HA HA! Such a poor, misguided man!

He finds her eloping with another man and chases off after her. And thus ensues a hilariously funny road trip romance!
Connor and Thea were perfect together! Loved the commentary between them!

I'm excited to read the other 2.. possibly 3 books?? The Duke will need to marry for his son right?

ARC provided by Netgalley

nellesnightstand's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This was a sweet and sad book. To have lost your sister who was more like a mother to you and learn that her will requires you to marry in order to keep your inheritance would suck. Who wants to marry within 3 months of your sister's death?
Connor knows just who he'll marry! His longtime friend Thea! She'll be no trouble at ALL and won't mind him being at sea as long as she has a home to manage. HA HA! Such a poor, misguided man!

He finds her eloping with another man and chases off after her. And thus ensues a hilariously funny road trip romance!
Connor and Thea were perfect together! Loved the commentary between them!

I'm excited to read the other 2.. possibly 3 books?? The Duke will need to marry for his son right?

ARC provided by Netgalley

hayleyde's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.5 stars. A little drawn out/slow in parts, and didn’t really make my heart swell, but it’s witty and refreshing. The conflicts/obstacle to the relationship in this book feel very real and I really wasn’t sure how they would make it work. I think it’s awesome and exemplary that Thea won’t stand for a marriage that’s not what she deserves, even if it is to a man she loves. There are several characters who seem like they’re going to be stock characters, or played as one dimensionally villainous or obnoxious, but then are handled with nuance. There are five star romances that make you squee and make you think, then there are romances that deliver on the fluff and squee but don’t hold up on close examination, and there are romances that don’t make you squee, but are very thoughtfully crafted and appreciable in subtler ways. This book is one in that last category. It’s not one that I want to shout from the rooftops, but it’s solid and I’d recommend it if the tropes are your catnip or if, like me, you’re a huge consumer of historical romance audiobooks (Gary Furlong does a great job!).

ranoeptn's review

Go to review page

adventurous funny hopeful lighthearted relaxing medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

gothai's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It is a fun friends to lovers romance. When Connor comes to know that he has to marry within 3 months to get his inheritance, he decides that he will marry Theodora his best friend's mousy spinster sister. But when he arrives at their house he discovers that she has eloped with a squire. What follows is a wonderful trip with lots of fun and interesting secondary characters. If you overlook the fact that Theodara's parents and brothers does not follow her to Gretna Green then you can enjoy the book

readbooks_eatapples's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

This was legitimately awful. I don’t know who edited this book, but I do know it isn’t the same people who edited her latest. I absolutely hated this and am appalled at myself for trying to force myself to read it. This was a 70% skim. I’ll be reluctant to pick up anything else except her latest, as maybe she found her niche with contemporary fiction.

loverofromance's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This review was originally posted on Addicted To Romance

In Caught By The Scot, we have an entertaining and witty romance that is perfect for kicking your legs up, with a cup of tea and immersing yourself into. Karen Hawkins has delivered another wonderful story that kept me smiling all the way through and left me wanting more from these two.

Our story begins when Connor Douglas, has come home to visit his sister, with a new baby on the way. But when Connor and his brothers arrive, they learn that their beloved sister has passed away in giving birth and has left behind a husband and an infant son. Their emotions are rattled, but then they learn about their sister's desires for them all, which their brother in law intends on carrying out to honor the woman he loved. They have three months to find a bride or lose their inheritance which will be given to their bitter enemies, a fellow clan. At first, Connor and his brothers are furious, but Connor knows of one woman he could marry. A woman he grew up with, a sister to one of his closest friends. He just knows that she is a spinster and will be grateful for his offer---or that is what he assumes. But upon arriving at her home, he learns that she has eloped with a farmer. So he chases after her and her "fiancee" to convince her his suit is way better than anything she could have with this landowner. Thea has loved Connor for many years, but she is tired of him never seeing her. She craves adventure and to take charge of her own life. And when Lance, a man who is handsome and kind and in love with her, she agrees to marry him. But she never expected the drama, a turned vehicle, or her secret love to be wanting her hand instead. She knows he sees her as a spinster, not a real woman worth of his attention.

Now I won't say that this is my favorite book from this author, but this book packs a punch in so many ways. At the beginning, I really really shouldn't read books in public, because I was crying buckets of tears. There was so much emotion that begins the story, seeing how much these brothers loved their sister and seeing the way they are grieving for her. It just broke my heart to see these strong and wild Scots be so humbled and broken. You may think that Connor isn't your honest and good hero...but think again because I was so on his side during this book. He has a passion for living on the seas, be he also has great admiration for Thea. He has never wanted marriage EVER....but she is the only woman he would ever marry. He respects her and admires her in many ways and they have become good friends over the years. But we see how Connor sees Thea in a different way. We see how it humbles him and he starts to pursue her, to court her and be very devious in various ways. Connor doesn't expect his competition "Lance" to be so good looking or charming.

Withoot you, I'm a ship with nae crew. A sail with nae wind. A mon with nae heart. I love you Thea.


I understood Thea's reaction to Connor at first, about why she was so against him. I mean she wants a home and family, and Connor is a man that lives and breathes the sea. It's like the fish and the bird falling in love with each other. Even though she does love him, she wants more than just love. She wants a man to rely on, a man who will be there for her and vice versa. She wants a true partnership and won't take anything less and I LOVED that about her character. She isn't afraid to go after what she wants even if that means losing a man she loves. I did admire her values for life, and what her goals were. We see some growth and changes in both characters. Connor starts to realize that courting Thea isn't going to be easy and he may lose anyway. It was interesting to see these two come together. Because both of them have hot tempers and boy do things sizzle between them. I laughed so hard at their antics, and the "creative" ways Connor goes to separate Lance and Thea from each other.

This story just proves why I have fallen in love with this author over the years. She is a marvel at mixing up true depth of emotion with enough lightheartedness and building up characters you want to cheer on. Caught By The Scot is a feisty and lively romance that will keep you fascinated, teary eyed, smiles full of laughter and a love story that proves the fish and the bird can build a nest together!



 

 photo Addicted To Romance Reviews 2_zpsplp8m0tb.png

shinysue's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny lighthearted medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.25

This is a fun story. Comfortable in that the reader knows how it's going to end and each plot beat, but still interesting to read. A smidgen drawn out probably because of its predictability, but I liked it.  The main couple are appropriately feisty and fun, and I'm glad he didn't get what he wanted too easily. 

enur's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Conner Douglas ve kardeşleri vefat eden ablasının son arzusu üzerine evlenmeye karar veriyor. Connor denizlerde olduğu vakitlerde ona sorun çıkarmayacak, kendi halinde, aklı başında bir gelin olarak da en yakın arkadaşının kardeşi Theodora Cumberbatch-Snowe'u seçiyor.

Bilmediği şey ise bir büyükelçi kızı olan Thea'nın babasının görevi hasebiyle sürüklenip sürekli farklı yerlerde yaşamaktan yorulmuş olduğu. Sabit bir evi, yuvası olsun isteyen Thea evlenmek için genç bir toprak beyi olan Lance ile kaçmıştır.

Connor, kaçak Thea ve Lance'i Gretna Green yollarında yakalıyor. Fakat Thea'nın çantada keklik olmadığını bir kere daha anlıyor. Lance'in ona uygun olmadığını kanıtlamaya karar veriyor ve bunun için de türlü numaralarla yollarını uzatıyor.

Aşk üçgeni okumaya katlanamayanlar için açıklık getireyim, aşk üçgeni yok.

Diyaloglarıyla, karakterleriyle, gidişatıyla eğlenceli bir kitaptı. Keyifle okudum.

raciethereader's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I enjoyed this story for its dialogue and moments of levity. I disliked the light historical details, its dependence on tropes, and the frustrating long time it takes for characters to actually admit to things.