Reviews

While this book is a little repetative, it was a cute premise with very enjoyable moments. I really like Fletcher and Lucy together and loved their friendship,

just wish we saw more of it after the big reveal.

I hated the third act break up and had to suspend reality for their make-up.
I mostly enjoyed reading this, but doubt I'll revisit.

Content Warnings

shanchat's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional funny hopeful informative inspiring lighthearted fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

bucolicbookshelf's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.5

The concept of a MFC with anxiety, depression, and ADHD struck a chord with me and I do love a HEA, but unfortunately this one wasn’t for me.

While I’m sure many readers will adore this, I had a difficult time getting into the rhythm of the plot and found Lucy’s inner voice and interactions to be too junior high-esque for what I was expecting.

I wasn’t the reader for this.

Thank you to Forever and NetGalley for the DRC

dinoqueenreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

please note that the trigger warnings and topes/themes may contain spoilers
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
HEA: yes
POV: dual 1st person POV
spice: several open-door spicy scenes
TWs: divorce, mentions of spousal death, identity crisis, imposter syndrome, internalized racism, on page anxiety and depression, struggles with neurodivergence, slight OW drama, slight suicidal ideation, references to grooming/attempted sexual assault of a minor (off page), cheating
standalone: yes
final thoughts: for a book with some pretty heavy triggers for a romcom, it still felt light and fun. The writing style made this a quick, easy, fun read with lots of inserts of the DMs back and forth between their online personalities. I loved having the dual 1st person POV to see the push and pull of their relationships growing online and offline. A great secret identity workplace romance that is perfect for a summer beach read.

read this book if you love

😬 angst
💞 friends-to-lovers
🏝️ forced proximity (coworkers)
🧑‍🏫 teacher
🤫 hidden secrets
🎭 secret identity
😂 romcom
💓 slowburn
💼 workplace romance
🧑‍🤝‍🧑 great side characters

taketwolu's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.5

Offline, Lucy is shy, anxious, guidance counsellor struggling to hold off disaster -- online, she’s bold, confident, and anonymously runs an account under the persona of @ TheMissGuidedCounselor. Fletcher finds himself teaching at the same school as Lucy while dealing with his ex, family drama, and a growing crush, all while getting advice from his online friend.

Ok, imagine it’s your first day teaching at a new school and you get tea spilt on your CROTCH and you have to strip down to your boxers to blow dry your pants in the boys change room as a 6ft tall Scottish gym teacher tells you about his slightly traumatic backstory.

OR imagine being the one who spilt tea on the new teacher’s crotch and trying to dab it out but then running away to decompress (cry) in embarrassment / anxiety (oh and also you’re the school guidance counsellor)

^^ this is just the first 2 chapters btw!!

Honestly, this book had me hooked from the start and with good reason. I loved how hopelessly lost these two were -- yet their ability to find comfort and chemistry (despite the multiple scenes of second hand embarrassment) was undeniably cute. ALSO, the level of chaotic messiness, hilariousness, and genuine moments of vulnerability / insecurity was on par 👌🏼

⚠️ - tw: mental health, panic attacks, anxiety disorder, infidelity, etc + potential spoilers

highlights:

- the intro note + content warnings 🥺

- the whole tea-crotch situation LMAO

- Lucy - a strong anxious, d3pressed fmc -- loved her bold, confident moments, but also her more raw and vulnerable side + she loves Fredrik Backman (yay!!)

- Fletcher - a genuinely solid guy, he’s awkward, understanding, sometimes a little lost and super cute with Lucy hehe

- careful discussions of anxiety, d3pression, ADHD, mental health, and more

- the Konfident Kids Klub… (an after school club Lucy runs -- she had a full on crying session during their first meeting 🙈 btw, they can’t change the name because of the school budget 😂🥴)

- Lucy’s family - they’re cute, messy, and understanding!! loved the mix of cultures/backgrounds (Mexican, Moroccan, and Jewish rep) and the food descriptions!! they ALSO will all sit in lawn chairs waiting for you to come back from your date to interrogate 😂🫣)

- the double identities -- loved the chat msg banter (and awkwardly cute flirting attempts)

- the messy personal drama!? mainly from Fletcher LOL 👀 (Fletcher’s dad is soo MESSY ☠️😬 -- like ‘divorcing your wife because you got your secretary pregnant’ kind of messy AND his ex gf WHO cheated on him with his own brother is also his coworker… YIKES)

- the realness - both characters were vulnerable, raw, patient, and genuinely cared for each other (even despite all the tears and personal drama) 🥺

- Lucy’s sisters (Amira, Julieta) + best friend (Nia) -- amazing female side characters and love the dynamic they all have with Lucy!

- Brodie, the Scottish gym teacher (this guy is so unbothered -- in a good way, overshares, gives golden retriever vibes, makes awkward situations worse, and is a bit of a self-care king 😂 great side character tbh!)

- the ending - cute, funny, and like a warm hug 🤧🥰

- the author’s note 😭 Jessica shares a lot about her personal journey with her identity and mental health 👏🏼

I will note that there were some tropes I wasn’t a fan of (miscommunication, etc) and some scenes were a bit much. Though this might not be for everyone, I really enjoyed this and it’s easily a new fav 🥰 Overall this was such a fun debut and I can’t wait to read more!

Thanks NetGalley and Read Forever Pub for my arc!

lesleygetslit's review against another edition

Go to review page

The “KKK” joke was…a choice.

kelliejohnson19's review against another edition

Go to review page

funny reflective fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

More...