Reviews

Mo' Meta Blues: The World According to Questlove by Ben Greenman, Questlove

nickscoby's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Fooled me: this is more like a textbook about the history of hip-hop and neo-soul than a personal memoir. You pulled one over on me, Quest! At certain points, I felt like I was reading my own thoughts. Scary. I definitely relate to the hustle of trying to buy Prince albums as a youth. I laughed out loud at Quest's encounters with Prince, Puff and Alicia Keys. He's such a nerd! Overall, great read.

trevoryan's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This is a great book. Questlove is one of my idols. A drumming music nerd. If you are a fan of The Roots or just love music, this is the book for you.

shannonw19's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

genius. didn't disappoint

bjmcinnarney's review against another edition

Go to review page

funny informative inspiring lighthearted reflective medium-paced

3.75

duparker's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This is a fun and funky book. Questlove writes a memoir, but also a critique of music and a dialog about how we should listen and appreciate music. He uses these themes to discuss the formative aspects of the Roots and his missteps. The writing is cheery and has a bit of bounce to it, and the topics are well thought out. I like that there are no real bitchslaps or attacks, there is some conflict with labels and people, but nothing that is disrespectful.

placoderm_fish's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

An intimate and unorthodox memoir exploring Questlove's career in music with meditations on hip hop and American culture.

cseibs's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Humble he is not. I am inclined to rate this 2 stars, but I'll throw in an extra star on the assumption that a lot of the music stuff was just way over my head. I will agree with the book's editor that Thompson suffers from the Doppler-effect. As the book progressed, there was more and more straightforward recounting, with some hubristic boasting thrown in, and less of the really interesting introspection and reflection found in the chapters dealing with Thompson's early years. Maybe that's a natural by product of having evolved and found himself as an artist, but the struggle, the searching, the ambiguity of his earlier years just make for better reading.

ericfheiman's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

A fairly by the numbers autobiography enlivened by the play with structure and POV. Not that Questlove is uninteresting or intelligent. Far from it. But the celebrity name checking gets a little tiresome after a while and the insights a little facile.

lyrareadsbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Fun, dizzying, thoughtful and thought-provoking.

misterjay's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Like a lot of people, I was intrigued when I heard that The Roots would be taking the slot as the house band when Jimmy Fallon took over The Late Show. I knew who they were, of course; you can't skirt the edges of hip-hop and R&B without having run into them at some point. And I liked them even though I'd never made the transition to out and out fan. They were one of those bands that I liked whenever they showed up on something else I was actively paying attention to: a new record by Common or Mos Def, the Dave Chappelle Show, and on and on across the pop culture landscape.

But I didn't know much about them. I had heard the singles, I had seen a few videos, but that was about it until some of their performances on The Late Show began to go viral. The first one I remember really grabbing me and making me sit up and focus was a clip of The Roots backing Eminem during a burn down the house performance of "Won't Back Down." It stuck in my head for two reasons: one, it cemented the idea in my mind that The Roots really were the powerhouse they were rumored to be, and two, holy cats, is that a tuba?

From there, I got sucked more and more into the world of The Roots and of Questlove in particular. First it was a collection of 'likes' on YouTube, then it was a couple of records, and finally, perhaps inevitably, it was following Quest on Twitter and liking the man that seemed to emerge, 140 characters at a time.

So I knew the memoir was coming.

And yet, I wasn't prepared for how charmed I would be as the excerpts and quoted passages began to roll out ahead of the actual publication date. I wasn't sure what I wanted - more stories featuring Eddie Murphy and Prince? Tales of debauchery backstage in London? Maybe something a little salacious featuring Quest's roster of porn star friends (well, ok, maybe just Sasha Grey)? But, this was meant to be a memoir, not a tell-all. This wasn't meant to be Motley Crue's Dirt. On the other hand, as Quest himself notes in the book, a lot of memoirs begin with a birth and then spin out into facts and figures without any real insight into the person behind them.

Plus, there was the title: Mo' Meta Blues. I mean, it's a play on an old Spike Lee movie to begin with, and then, god, isn't meta kind of played out already?

So what kind of book would it be?

It turns out that it's equal parts actual memoir, history of hip-hop, African-American studies, and discourse on the personal connection people can have with music, the book is compulsively readable and accessible. At the same time, the comments, in the form of footnotes, or e-mails from the co-author to the editor, added a look behind the curtain, to see just how the Great and Powerful Quest was writing his book added the titled meta layer without getting in the way of the story.

And like all good narrative non-fiction, there is a story. It's the story of a young kid growing up in love with music and it's the story of how an unlikely pair of friends ended up forming one of the most influential bands in hip-hop, and it's the story of a life lived thoughtfully and with purpose. All of which made me like Quest that much more. Perhaps more importantly, from a commercial point of view, it made me want to run out and buy several hundred records. Not just ones from The Roots, but from the diverse collection known as the Soulquarians, and from the countless jazz, soul, and R&B records Quest talks about.

Hell, the book should have come with a soundtrack.

Maybe the timing was just fortuitous for me. I've been looking for some new music. Not just new music, but for something that would blow my mind and make me appreciate a sound I had been hearing but not hearing. This book provided that and then some; following the connections and reminders and recommendations here could fill up years. And that alone is worth the cover price.

Get this for the music fan in your life and get it for yourself. You'll be richer for it.