Scan barcode
guardyourhonor's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
Series review: I loved this so so much. I flew threw them, but they're also very competently written. I'm always a sucker for stories where kindness wins. It was an absolute delight to find a world where shifters aren't humans with a wolf inside them, they're always a wolf in any form. The whole world is amazing, in fact, and so detailed you would think Bishop had been writing in it for years. The characters got me just as much as the world. Our Meg immediately stole my heart. She's special, yes, but she's flawed and realistic and kind. But every character in the Courtyard was delightful, from Simon down to the ponies and the human pack. I'm so sad I can't spend any more time with them. If there's a flaw, it's the villains - they are pretty one note, mustache twirling bad guys. That said, they were fun to hate and see get their comeuppance.
anca_antoci's review
4.0
If Murder of Crows was so and so, this one falls in line with Written in Red and is much better. By now I got used to the slow pace of story development and the naive actions of the characters, so it didn’t surprise me. The story picks up where we left off in Murder of Crows. In the aftermath of prior events, and because the Humans First and Last movement stirred a lot of trouble, there is a shift in the dynamic between humans and terra indigene.
Let’s not forget that the Others commonly think of humans as ‘smart meat’ that invents things they can use. But if humans become a threat, the terra indigene population might consider living without the human-made products. Especially if the usually hidden and extremely dangerous ancient terra indigene (known as the Elders) decide the extinction of the human race. The tension and the danger that comes with it is best summed up by Captain Burke’ s joke:
“Do you know what happened to the dinosaurs? The Others is what happened to the dinosaurs. A joke Captain Burke had told him his first day on the job in Lakeside. Except it wasn’t a joke. Burke had known that, at least to some degree. And now so did he.”
The new relationship is strained at best with one exception: the human pack that forms around Meg Corbyn. And this pack seems ever growing while the terra indigene reluctantly accepts them in their midst.
We get to see more our favorite policeman, Monty and see him interact with his daughter Lizzy who comes for a surprise visit. The gory reason behind this visit keeps the story from dragging. Needless to say, Lizzy joins the human pack at the Courtyard. Being a child and a little bit spoiled she manages to stir some trouble for Meg.
The cassandra sangue that were freed by the Others have trouble adjusting to a life outside the compound. Suddenly, Meg feels overwhelmed and has trouble adjusting too. Honestly, that seemed far fetched. When she first arriver at the Courtyard, after having lived in the compound for as long as she could remember, Meg adapted just fine despite not having any real-life experience. She learned fast how to do her job at the delivery office, despite never having a job. Yet when she enters the Crow’s trinket shop Meg is overwhelmed into a panic attack because there were too many things there.
All this meltdown serves a purpose, but I wish it was done differently to make more sense. But let’s not dwell on it, Meg and the other blood prophets suffer from sensory overload (I don’t remember if that is exactly how the author calls it) so Meg wonders what to do about it:
“What do you expect us to do?” Meg shouted. “Write The Dimwit’s Guide to Blood Prophets?”
“Yes! That’s exactly what I want you to do.”
Looking at their stunned expressions, he wondered if he’d been a little too honest. “Figure it out and write it up so we can pass on the information to everyone who is trying to help these girls.”
“I’m not a writer,” Merri Lee protested. “I can make notes, sure, but I can’t write up something like that!”
“Ruthie will help you write it.” There. Problem solved. Ruthie was a teacher. She wrote sentences all the time.
As expected, there are plenty of hilarious moments caused by a poor understanding of how the human acquisition system works. In this case, the terra indigene didn’t understand the necessity of the paperwork needed to buy a house.
“Why couldn’t they just give the human female a bag of money and then pee on the building so that everyone would know it was theirs?”
The same goes for basic human terminology:
“This is Ruthie Stuart, Officer Kowalski’s mate. She will show your pups around the Market Square,” Simon said.
Sarah giggled. Robert said, “We’re not pups; we’re kids.”
Simon looked at Robert and Sarah, then at Ruthie.
Kids. He’d heard Merri Lee say something about when she was a kid. But the word didn’t apply to her now because she was an adult, so it had never occurred to him that, maybe, humans had a little shifter ability that they outgrew as they matured. When she had said kid, maybe she had meant kid?
He eyed Robert and Sarah with more interest. “Little humans can shift into young goats?”
Also, Simon’s reaction to Meg’s haircut is adorable and almost human:
“He had a feeling this was one of those times when a male should express positive enthusiasm regardless of what he really thought—especially when he didn’t really know what was going on.”
When Lizzy comes to the Courtyard she has a stuffed bear that makes her feel safe. While none of the humans bats an eye about it, the terra indigene residents are completely baffled.
“Why did humans give their offspring fake versions of predators that would happily eat those offspring?”
That being said, I’m glad I didn’t give up on this series and I’m happy to move on to the next book.
Let’s not forget that the Others commonly think of humans as ‘smart meat’ that invents things they can use. But if humans become a threat, the terra indigene population might consider living without the human-made products. Especially if the usually hidden and extremely dangerous ancient terra indigene (known as the Elders) decide the extinction of the human race. The tension and the danger that comes with it is best summed up by Captain Burke’ s joke:
“Do you know what happened to the dinosaurs? The Others is what happened to the dinosaurs. A joke Captain Burke had told him his first day on the job in Lakeside. Except it wasn’t a joke. Burke had known that, at least to some degree. And now so did he.”
The new relationship is strained at best with one exception: the human pack that forms around Meg Corbyn. And this pack seems ever growing while the terra indigene reluctantly accepts them in their midst.
We get to see more our favorite policeman, Monty and see him interact with his daughter Lizzy who comes for a surprise visit. The gory reason behind this visit keeps the story from dragging. Needless to say, Lizzy joins the human pack at the Courtyard. Being a child and a little bit spoiled she manages to stir some trouble for Meg.
The cassandra sangue that were freed by the Others have trouble adjusting to a life outside the compound. Suddenly, Meg feels overwhelmed and has trouble adjusting too. Honestly, that seemed far fetched. When she first arriver at the Courtyard, after having lived in the compound for as long as she could remember, Meg adapted just fine despite not having any real-life experience. She learned fast how to do her job at the delivery office, despite never having a job. Yet when she enters the Crow’s trinket shop Meg is overwhelmed into a panic attack because there were too many things there.
All this meltdown serves a purpose, but I wish it was done differently to make more sense. But let’s not dwell on it, Meg and the other blood prophets suffer from sensory overload (I don’t remember if that is exactly how the author calls it) so Meg wonders what to do about it:
“What do you expect us to do?” Meg shouted. “Write The Dimwit’s Guide to Blood Prophets?”
“Yes! That’s exactly what I want you to do.”
Looking at their stunned expressions, he wondered if he’d been a little too honest. “Figure it out and write it up so we can pass on the information to everyone who is trying to help these girls.”
“I’m not a writer,” Merri Lee protested. “I can make notes, sure, but I can’t write up something like that!”
“Ruthie will help you write it.” There. Problem solved. Ruthie was a teacher. She wrote sentences all the time.
As expected, there are plenty of hilarious moments caused by a poor understanding of how the human acquisition system works. In this case, the terra indigene didn’t understand the necessity of the paperwork needed to buy a house.
“Why couldn’t they just give the human female a bag of money and then pee on the building so that everyone would know it was theirs?”
The same goes for basic human terminology:
“This is Ruthie Stuart, Officer Kowalski’s mate. She will show your pups around the Market Square,” Simon said.
Sarah giggled. Robert said, “We’re not pups; we’re kids.”
Simon looked at Robert and Sarah, then at Ruthie.
Kids. He’d heard Merri Lee say something about when she was a kid. But the word didn’t apply to her now because she was an adult, so it had never occurred to him that, maybe, humans had a little shifter ability that they outgrew as they matured. When she had said kid, maybe she had meant kid?
He eyed Robert and Sarah with more interest. “Little humans can shift into young goats?”
Also, Simon’s reaction to Meg’s haircut is adorable and almost human:
“He had a feeling this was one of those times when a male should express positive enthusiasm regardless of what he really thought—especially when he didn’t really know what was going on.”
When Lizzy comes to the Courtyard she has a stuffed bear that makes her feel safe. While none of the humans bats an eye about it, the terra indigene residents are completely baffled.
“Why did humans give their offspring fake versions of predators that would happily eat those offspring?”
That being said, I’m glad I didn’t give up on this series and I’m happy to move on to the next book.
indecisivesailorscout's review
4.0
THAT LAST LINE WAS SOOOOOO CUTE OH MY GOODNESS HOLD HANDS FOREVER
ohjessjess's review
1.0
Disappointing. Not recommended if you were expecting character development. I find it hard to believe Meg is supposed to be a major player in war between humanity and the Others when she does fuck all and is kept sequestered away from all the major conflicts.
Simon and Montgomery are the heroes of this book, but I resent the fact the series are continually marketed as if there's a heroine blazing the way. Also "gaggle of females", really.
Simon and Montgomery are the heroes of this book, but I resent the fact the series are continually marketed as if there's a heroine blazing the way. Also "gaggle of females", really.
mamap's review
2.0
I'm glad I didn't have to purchase this book.
A continuation of the story we've been following - no real breakthroughs.
The series is starting to real like an ongoing TV show. Like a story with a beginning, a middle, and an end. Hence why I won't buy.
Simon Wolfgard and the changes he has made due to his relationship with Meg is the only thing holding back the extermination of the entire human race by the terra indigne who rule the land.
A continuation of the story we've been following - no real breakthroughs.
The series is starting to real like an ongoing TV show. Like a story with a beginning, a middle, and an end. Hence why I won't buy.
Simon Wolfgard and the changes he has made due to his relationship with Meg is the only thing holding back the extermination of the entire human race by the terra indigne who rule the land.
getlostmatilda's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
eva__pires's review against another edition
5.0
parece que mais uma vez Anne Bishop consegui melhorar uma história excelente desde o início. a cada livro somos absorvidos cada vez mais por um mundo diferente e belo. só tenho pena que em Portugal os livros demorem tanto tempo a serem editados quando os originais já existem há algum tempo, a espera pelo próximo volume da série Os Outros vai ser longa (1 ano imagino) e difícil, mal posso esperar para saber o que mais vem aí para Meg Corbyn, Simon Wolfgard e restantes membros da matilha