3.89 AVERAGE

fatbookishfemme's review

3.0

This read like a novelizatipn if the series, with a few extra details, but I think I’m more interested in just the journals
stitchsaddiction's profile picture

stitchsaddiction's review

4.0
informative medium-paced

I had heard about Anne Lister during my preteen and teenage years as I navigated my own sexual identity and devoured books on historic lesbians and homosexual men. She came across as this fascinating yet confusing person and as with many things, my interest waned.

Now, with the incredible drama by the BBC/HBO reawakened interest in the lady who would become known as Gentleman Jack after her passing and the diary she wrote throughout her life? I wanted to know more about the infamous owner of Shibden Hall in Halifax. Gentleman Jack by Anna Choma features extracts from Lister's diary and provide insight into not only her life as she searched for a life partner, but the world in which she lived and loved from the cost of items to the politics of the England she would grown up in during the late eighteenth through to her death in 1840 whilst travelling with her wife, Ann Walker.

The book was one I couldn't put down, and found myself once more fascinated by the woman who broke so many rules dictated by her gender but also finding myself losing some of the love my younger self had for her. She comes across from her diary entries as somewhat of a nightmare to be around, whether it be as a landowner dictating what her tenants are allowed to do in politics, or the way she sees herself being far above those around her. I did find myself sympathetic to her desire to find a true life partner, and to remain loyal to her religion; but  also dislike how she seems to be unaware of her cold manner towards those who love her both platonic and romantic.

I may have felt slightly awful, at times when you read of her faltering in society and shown that she's not ‘all that’ after all. She deserved a few known backs from those around hertI think because she's often insufferable in her mannerisms.

The book is excellently written, with a blend of diary entries, recollections and Choma's own insight to Anne's life. It's also intriguing to see how Lister created not only her own code to write about her personal - more romantic moments with various women, but to berate those she encountered. She was certainly confident that no one would break her code and discover her secrets… She also had to create her own vocabulary for her Lesbian exploits as she didn't know what to use, and it makes me chuckle at times and blush at others.

Anne Lister was so much more than Gentleman Jack, she was a niece, a sister and friend. A landowner and hard working woman who refused to be held down by her gender and whilst this book may have removed the rose tint to my views as a teenager, she is to be admired for all she accomplished but I do dislike how she didn't appreciate the love she was given by the woman, Ann Walker who risked it all for her.
moriah1701's profile picture

moriah1701's review

3.75
emotional informative inspiring reflective tense medium-paced
challenging emotional informative reflective medium-paced

mara_chris's review

4.0

HBO series is absolutely AMAZING, this book is a great companion.

amyslibrarian's review

3.0

Had it not been for the BBC One/HBO series of the same title, I would probably have never learned about this woman and her incredible story. Anne Lister was astonishingly comfortable (albeit understandably careful for her personality-well, mostly-considering when she lived) with her lesbian sexuality, which is predominantly focused on during the 1830s in this book and television series. A fairly solid introduction to Lister's latter years. 2.5

kjackmi's review

3.0

Interesting at first, but repetitive and boring after awile. I suspect the HBO series will be far more entertaining, just going to stick to that.

I struggled with the audio book cause it bounced back and forth and it was hard to read while doing things
reflective medium-paced

jl1551's review

3.0

3.5 stars