Scan barcode
7ft_rat's review
adventurous
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.5
ghutter05's review against another edition
3.0
Waffling between 2 and 3 stars. It just seemed to trail off somehow. I was really interested in finishing it, but by the time I did, I just wasn't invested anymore.
calville's review against another edition
2.0
I so passionately wanted to like this book, but it just didn't happen for me, and I gave up at about 80% through. The characterization of the protagonist was just all over the place - for example, after SPOILERY BAD THING happens on the road to the capitol, one page--and one day--later, she's laughing and getting flirty with Love Interest and not thinking about SPOILERY BAD THING at all. She was also supposedly so devious, but her master plan boils down to: "You, get the guy drunk; you, stay out of the way; you, bring him over to the corner where I'll be chilling with a knife." Not exactly three-dimensional chess. And the gender-bendy stuff--which was this book's main selling point to me--was way below the sophistication or insight level that you'd see in good fanfiction or in, say, Ancillary Justice or The Bone Doll's Twin (which was written almost 20 years ago!). I would take a chance on this author's next series, but this one just did not work.
avocaho's review against another edition
4.25
When I say I want to read casually queer books, this IS the archetype. This is what I want. I slammed this entire book in one sitting.
lindadreams's review against another edition
2.0
genderfluid rep (ownvoice)
this book is supposed to be a fantasy with a mafia background, but it's poorly executed: the magic system is never explained and it seems to me that it works kind of randomly, and to say there's mafia in this book is an exaggeration.
the plot and the romance are rushed - a problem that i seem to find in a lot of ya books - and the characters are so boring and flat i couldn't make myself care about any of them.
the good thing is that it's a light and quick read, but that's it.
this book is supposed to be a fantasy with a mafia background, but it's poorly executed: the magic system is never explained and it seems to me that it works kind of randomly, and to say there's mafia in this book is an exaggeration.
the plot and the romance are rushed - a problem that i seem to find in a lot of ya books - and the characters are so boring and flat i couldn't make myself care about any of them.
the good thing is that it's a light and quick read, but that's it.
neglet's review against another edition
5.0
Very inventive world-building, with a protagonist who is sometimes spiky but always sympathetic. Political intrigue and magic make me eager for the next volume!
hellomadalyn's review against another edition
4.0
This review originally appeared on Novel Ink.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
If you’re a regular visitor to my blog, you probably know by now that reviews of fantasy books from me are few and far between these days. As my reading tastes have changed over the past couple years, I’ve slowly gravitated away from fantasy, and it takes a special book to make me want to pick up the genre. The Brilliant Death was that kind of book. I fell in love with Amy Rose Capetta’s writing after reading Echo After Echo last year and was eagerly anticipating this follow-up, and it did not disappoint.
In The Brilliant Death, we follow Teodora, the daughter of one of the most powerful mafia families in Vinalia. However, not even her father knows of her magical abilities– which she has been using for years to quietly take down the Di Sangro family’s enemies. The book begins with Teo’s father, along with all of the other heads of the Five Families who hold power in Vinalia, being poisoned by the land’s new ruler, the Capo. Teo sets off for the capital in search of an antidote for her father and of some answers as to what the heck is happening in Vinalia.
I was utterly enchanted by the world of The Brilliant Death. The setting is perfectly described, and it’s easy to see the Italian influence in the descriptions of the art, the food, the politics, the church, and, of course, in the magic. The magic system is one of the most unique ones I’ve ever read; it involves people called streghe (singular: strega… which actually means “witch” in Italian!) who have specific magical abilities. Not all of them have the same ability, but the magic functions in a similar way no matter what form it takes. Our main character, for example, can change other people into objects. We also learn, along with Teo, that when a strega dies, their abilities transfer to others. This has led to a rise in streghe killing other streghe in order to gain more power. The magic almost felt like a character in and of itself; it was always present and even spoke at times. It was well-crafted and made sense while still feeling whimsical.
Also, I tend to gravitate toward and enjoy political fantasies, and The Brilliant Death blended magic and politics perfectly. There’s lots of scheming, plots, and intrigue that keep you on your toes the entire book. It also served to make the world feel all the more atmospheric, and the politics definitely upped the stakes of the story. There’s a lot of discussion on how trapped and stifled Teo feels as a daughter in a world that favors sons. She has to contend with these attitudes coming from both her family (specifically her father and brothers) as well as from the outside world. The men in Teo’s life constantly underestimate her, and, well, that never works out too well for them in the end. The Brilliant Death challenges the cishetero patriarchy at every turn, and I was here for it.
Which brings me to my other favorite part… the love interest!!! Cielo, another strega who has the ability to change their own form, becomes Teo’s magic tutor, and the two have to manage their budding romance with, you know, saving the world. Cielo is a genderfluid strega who often shifts forms and uses both he/him and she/her pronouns throughout the novel. I’m 100% in love with them, tbh. They’re exactly the kind of witty love interest I think readers will swoon over. I loved reading their interactions with Teo! Their romance made my heart so happy. Also, I thought the way gender was explored in The Brilliant Death was wonderful– I’m a cis woman, so take my opinions with a grain of salt, but I thought the discussion was excellent.
As always, Amy Rose Capetta’s stunning prose is another standout element of this book. Her writing is so lyrical and is perfectly suited to this queer, magical fantasy story.
Overall, if you’re looking for a unique YA fantasy read this fall, I can’t recommend The Brilliant Death highly enough! Whether you’re a seasoned or skeptical reader of fantasy, I think this story will enchant pretty much everyone.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
If you’re a regular visitor to my blog, you probably know by now that reviews of fantasy books from me are few and far between these days. As my reading tastes have changed over the past couple years, I’ve slowly gravitated away from fantasy, and it takes a special book to make me want to pick up the genre. The Brilliant Death was that kind of book. I fell in love with Amy Rose Capetta’s writing after reading Echo After Echo last year and was eagerly anticipating this follow-up, and it did not disappoint.
In The Brilliant Death, we follow Teodora, the daughter of one of the most powerful mafia families in Vinalia. However, not even her father knows of her magical abilities– which she has been using for years to quietly take down the Di Sangro family’s enemies. The book begins with Teo’s father, along with all of the other heads of the Five Families who hold power in Vinalia, being poisoned by the land’s new ruler, the Capo. Teo sets off for the capital in search of an antidote for her father and of some answers as to what the heck is happening in Vinalia.
I was utterly enchanted by the world of The Brilliant Death. The setting is perfectly described, and it’s easy to see the Italian influence in the descriptions of the art, the food, the politics, the church, and, of course, in the magic. The magic system is one of the most unique ones I’ve ever read; it involves people called streghe (singular: strega… which actually means “witch” in Italian!) who have specific magical abilities. Not all of them have the same ability, but the magic functions in a similar way no matter what form it takes. Our main character, for example, can change other people into objects. We also learn, along with Teo, that when a strega dies, their abilities transfer to others. This has led to a rise in streghe killing other streghe in order to gain more power. The magic almost felt like a character in and of itself; it was always present and even spoke at times. It was well-crafted and made sense while still feeling whimsical.
Also, I tend to gravitate toward and enjoy political fantasies, and The Brilliant Death blended magic and politics perfectly. There’s lots of scheming, plots, and intrigue that keep you on your toes the entire book. It also served to make the world feel all the more atmospheric, and the politics definitely upped the stakes of the story. There’s a lot of discussion on how trapped and stifled Teo feels as a daughter in a world that favors sons. She has to contend with these attitudes coming from both her family (specifically her father and brothers) as well as from the outside world. The men in Teo’s life constantly underestimate her, and, well, that never works out too well for them in the end. The Brilliant Death challenges the cishetero patriarchy at every turn, and I was here for it.
Which brings me to my other favorite part… the love interest!!! Cielo, another strega who has the ability to change their own form, becomes Teo’s magic tutor, and the two have to manage their budding romance with, you know, saving the world. Cielo is a genderfluid strega who often shifts forms and uses both he/him and she/her pronouns throughout the novel. I’m 100% in love with them, tbh. They’re exactly the kind of witty love interest I think readers will swoon over. I loved reading their interactions with Teo! Their romance made my heart so happy. Also, I thought the way gender was explored in The Brilliant Death was wonderful– I’m a cis woman, so take my opinions with a grain of salt, but I thought the discussion was excellent.
As always, Amy Rose Capetta’s stunning prose is another standout element of this book. Her writing is so lyrical and is perfectly suited to this queer, magical fantasy story.
Overall, if you’re looking for a unique YA fantasy read this fall, I can’t recommend The Brilliant Death highly enough! Whether you’re a seasoned or skeptical reader of fantasy, I think this story will enchant pretty much everyone.
haydensharpe's review against another edition
5.0
Actual: 4.5
Review to come eventually, but what I’ll say now is wow the gender shifting was fascinating.
Review to come eventually, but what I’ll say now is wow the gender shifting was fascinating.
nelsonseye's review
3.0
My rating for The Brilliant Death is hovering between three and four stars, and I may upgrade later. I found the world of the book really interesting and the descriptions of the landscape, food, and city of Amalia quite beautiful/compelling. Tea was an interesting character, but I also liked her family - excluding Beniamo of course. :) The story overall was good, but I think I would have liked more intrigue/time spent with Teo masquerading as Luca. Still, the resolution worked well and I liked the balance of the prologue and the epilogue.
sassyykassie's review
4.0
The ending felt a little rushed or messy, and a little too open ended in my opinion. However, I LOVED SO MUCH OF THIS BOOK 😍😍 i loved how Any Rose Capetta decided to talk about the difference between men and women and their “places” and it just ugh, so good.