Reviews - Unlocked | The StoryGraph

So I just finished rereading Unlocked before I read Stellarlune, and I couldn’t help but remember when I first got the book, back in November of 2020.

I preordered my copy from Barnes and Noble, and I remember opening the front door one day and seeing the brown cardboard box sitting out in the cold surrounded by snow. I had screamed, and ran out the door, not caring that my socks were soaked from the snow. I’d grabbed the box and ran into the kitchen, trying not to shake the box to much. I grabbed a pair of scissors and slowly opened up the box, revealing the beautiful, shiny, hardcover copy of Keeper of the Lost Cities Unlocked.

I forced myself to read the entire guide before I read the novella. I remember staring down at the book in awe when I saw the art inside, and the laughter that came out of me when I read all about the problems Keefe had caused Councillor Alina, when she was still the principal of Foxfire.

I remember, sitting on my bed, in the dark with a flashlight and an hour I can’t even remember because I didn’t bother to check the time at all, rereading that letter Keefe wrote to Sophie, trying to figure out how Sophie would react.

And now, here I am. Two years later, finally holding a copy of Stellerlune. And I couldn’t help myself, but I pulled my copy of Unlocked off the shelf, and reread that letter from Keefe, even though is just read it earlier that day. It gave me the courage to open this door, and let me continue this journey with Sophie Foster.

I’ve enjoyed reading Unlocked over the past two years, and I hope that I will continue to reread it, many times. Thank you for reading my review. I hope that you enjoyed this book as much as I did.

foxispunk's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

the art is absolutely amazing in this book!! major props to the artists! especially Felia Hanakata’s pieces hers were my favorite so pretty

tyra_rev's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional funny hopeful slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

padigrumae's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

The registry files & keeper lore & all that other stuff should have been a separate book AND totally pared down so it felt like a registry file and NOT a synopsis I didn’t want. Coverage of all things elvish also should have been separate. As in a separate picture book. With lots of pictures…

ALSO now all I can think about when I’m reading is how the story literally can’t work now that we have a map because of TIME ZONES. My suspended belief is ruined

swiftieandbooklover4ever's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous hopeful lighthearted sad fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Complicated

5.0

abigaillb's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

This series... it's gone on way to long. I loved the world Shannon Messenger has created, the elves live in just about the coolest place ever. However, the whole "war" with the Neverseen has been dragged out to the max. But this book was definitely a good way to transition from the ages of buildup we've had in the last few books, to hopefully what will become a grand finale.

spoiler alert!

Summary This book is basically a way to stall for time before book 9. However, that being said, I still enjoyed reading it. The artwork in the center was also beautiful. I'll admit, I skipped a lot of the 'bonus material' but from what I did read, it seemed pretty well thought out and interesting (at least to someone who may be more invested in the series ). As for the actual novella, it was pretty good. Essentially, Keefe gets a new ability that's super powerful, and Sophie is attempting to find Kenric's old fancy secret box.

Parts I liked
~Biana: She gets better every book. Unlike her brother. I'm a sucker for a good, non- backstabbing female friendship. Biana & Sophie's friendly banter is always a win in my book.
~Fitz/Sophie Improvement: I'm gonna say it. The love triangle in this book is painful to read. Keefe/Sophie doesn't work; Fitz/Sophie doesn't work... But in this book, we return to the better dynamic they had at the very beginning of the series. I loved both Fitz and Sophie at the beginning of the series... and I loved their friendship. Even Sophie's crush on him was pretty cute. But as the series progressed it got so tiring watching the whole will they/won't they drama. Especially when Keefe entered the mix. And especially when Fitz's entire character fell apart. In the novella however, I actually saw some development. They were more open with each other, and it was so much more fun to read. Hopefully this continues. I can't take another book that returns to whatever Legacy was.
~Keefe/Dex Friendship!: loved their whole dynamic, and both remain great characters.
~Actual Series Moving Forward: this is a big one. I'm so thrilled that the war that's been brewing is official. The little "oh no what a fatal blow this is but we're actually fine" wreck the Black Swan has been in with the Neverseen is hopefully over. I really need some cool, ability using battles. Because that's what drives me mad about this series... the unused potential.

Parts I Disliked
~Potential: Maybe Shannon Messenger is saving it all to the end. Maybe the end books will be full of exhilarating, incredible battles. Or... maybe not. This series has been so caught up in the "love triangle" and "drama" that it has completely forgotten there's supposed to be a WAR of some kind going on. I mean, where are the super exciting battles with tons of fancy elf abilities?! Why is there only 1-2 per book? And why are the insanely powerful characters so underused?! Wheeerrree are Linh & Marella? Like if I were the Black Swan, special ol' Sophie wouldn't be the ~~Mocking jay~~ Moonlark. It would be Linh. I'd find all the Neverseen hideouts, fly her in in some type of attack helicopter (don't tell me the fancy elves have no helicopters or that Dex couldn't invent one) and have her flood the whole place. She's such a powerful character. And yet she's so underused.
The Attempt at Romance: There's potential with the Keefe/Fitz/Sophie thing. However, instead of having me root for one or the other I'm firmly sided with neither. It's simple as this. Sophie doesn't deserve either of them. Keefe & Fitz are so dedicated to her, and she's just... not. The whole breakup with Fitz really bothered me. It was so forced. I can 100% tell the author just needed to break the up to bring back the love triangle. And then there's Keefe... who is just so head over heels for Sophie. And I'm sure she has some idea about it! But she just keeps dragging him along because she can't choose. And where is the romance with the other characters? We've had hints of Tam/Biana and Linh/Wylie (also Dex?) but that's it! I really would rather read about those pairs than the disastrous Sophie-Fitz-Keefe triangle.

bluemoon_nymph's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional informative sad tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

More...