Scan barcode
gwydion's review against another edition
3.0
I've enjoyed the three previous Bosch books but something about this one didn't set well with me. I didn't particularly like Harry in this installment. Thought the hookup with the lone female in the book was silly and didn't add anything to the story. You don't have to create a female character so your protagonist can have sex. And their conversation was just silly. Since it was an audible book I could roll my eyes while listening to those silly, worthless chapters. But I will go on to the next Bosch book as overall I have enjoyed the series.
ruswornom's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
scottk1222's review against another edition
5.0
I really loved this book but I am a bit saddened by it as well. The reason I loved it is is was awesome, like going back to the beginning of the series. Then I remembered that this is one of the older books. which made me feel as if the newer books are kinda loosing their quality because I really loved the older ones.Not that the newer ones are bad , not at all but I don't know I can't put my finger on what has changed but something has. Does that mean I will stop reading the series? No way. I am too well invested in the lives of Harry and the repeat characters to ever just leave them.
anrobe's review against another edition
5.0
I'm so glad that I've been reading the Harry Bosch series because it is really outstanding. This one was probably my favorite so far, perhaps due to it helping fill in some of the Harry Bosch blanks for me. Really great series that I definitely recommend. Can't wait to start Trunk Music, #5 in the series!
burnman325's review against another edition
3.0
A little slower
I enjoy the Harry Bosch novels but this one dragged in the middle. I think it was supposed to be character development but it could've been shorter. The ending was a nice twist though
I enjoy the Harry Bosch novels but this one dragged in the middle. I think it was supposed to be character development but it could've been shorter. The ending was a nice twist though
cdm's review
4.0
Outstanding entry in the #Bosch series, adding new layers of depth to Harry's complex character while delivering shocking twists and turns completely different than those in the show. Really loving how the writers of the TV series are tweaking the strong source material. On to book 5!
twistedsittler's review
5.0
I'm a big fan of Connelley's flawed hero Harry Bosch. and I believe it's the flaws that make him so fascinating.
mildlyjulie's review
2.0
A little slow in the middle. Also it’s funny how LA freeways and traffic are like an additional character in these books.
canada_matt's review
4.0
It is as though Connelly can read my mind, or I his, in this second book that tosses us back into the past and present, surrounding Harry Bosch. In this tale, Bosch, who is on involuntary leave because of an incident with a superior, examines his mother's death and the mystery surrounding it. We get another great glimpse into his life and his past.
While remaining reckless with those around him (destructive even), Bosch has helped shape this image of a character who does not let his past stay there. From tunnels in 'Nam to the case that cost him his pride, to the murder of his mother. All cases that Connelly paints so well in books come to life on the page. Bosch needs to get to the bottom of it, even though it is over 30 years cold.
As Bosch pieces things together and gets himself into trouble (impersonating the lieutenant he roughted up to get suspended), all in the hopes of finding answers. When key political figures pop up as suspects, Bosch does not back down and hopes to crack the case wide open, all while still pissing everyone off at once.
A great read, especially since we see Bosch at his most vulnerable, and worth reading if you have an interest in seeing Bosch at his best.
Great work, Mr. Connelly.
While remaining reckless with those around him (destructive even), Bosch has helped shape this image of a character who does not let his past stay there. From tunnels in 'Nam to the case that cost him his pride, to the murder of his mother. All cases that Connelly paints so well in books come to life on the page. Bosch needs to get to the bottom of it, even though it is over 30 years cold.
As Bosch pieces things together and gets himself into trouble (impersonating the lieutenant he roughted up to get suspended), all in the hopes of finding answers. When key political figures pop up as suspects, Bosch does not back down and hopes to crack the case wide open, all while still pissing everyone off at once.
A great read, especially since we see Bosch at his most vulnerable, and worth reading if you have an interest in seeing Bosch at his best.
Great work, Mr. Connelly.
space_and_sorcery's review against another edition
dark
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5