Reviews

The Stone Sky by N.K. Jemisin

Only show reviews with written explanations

grahamclements's review against another edition

5.0

The Stone Sky is the third novel in the Hugo award winning Broken Earth trilogy. While perhaps slightly less engrossing than the other two novels, it is still a grand finale to the series. The trilogy features incredible original world building. Its various elements interlock with a thorough consistency. The characters control the world, live the world, breathe the world.

The series is set in a world dominated by seismic events. Earthquakes and volcanic eruptions regularly send the world into a fifth season, which is an extended winter where the sky is full of dust and the sun is blocked for years on end. This causes widespread famines. Tsunamis from the earthquakes also regularly inundate coastal areas.

There are a special class of people called Orogenes who can sense these seismic events about to happen and, depending on the orogene’s power and the severity of the event, can limit their destructiveness. The orogene can also cause these seismic events, either deliberately or as a result of out-of-control emotions. Consequently, they are feared by the general population, and any child found with these traits is murdered unless they are taken by the Guardians.

The Guardians teach the orogenes to control their power and use it to limit seismic events. The Guardians have powers that can control the orogenes and can hurt the orogenes to discipline them. They subject them to a servitude that verges on slave labour.

The trilogy’s main character is an orogene who goes through various names. She comes to the attention of a Guardian who then trains her. She is then sent out into the world to use her abilities to stop seismic events or use them to do things like clear harbour entrances. But she goes rogue. In the third novel she is searching for her daughter, Nassun, who was taken by her husband. Nassun is also an orogene. Mother and daughter are unaware they have two competing goals, one wants to stop fifth seasons from occurring forever, while the other wants to destroy the world.

The prose for this novel is some of the best I have read in genre fiction. N.K. Jemisin really knows how to construct descriptive narratives. I was often marvelling at a sentence she had written. The characters, for the most part, have a real emotional impact on the reader. The reader develops a strong empathy for their situation and their planned actions, even though they could involve the deaths of millions.

The Stone Sky finally brings in the backstory that shows how the world became so susceptible to seismic events. It does this by introducing the story of a group of exploited orogenes from the distance past. The mother and daughter then have their confrontation that brings the series to a compelling conclusion.

This is one of the best fantasy trilogies I have read. I find fantasy full of wizards and trolls and, dare I say, hobbits, so boring these days. This series thrashes most fantasy because of its sheer originality and the author’s writing prowess. It is not a novel for the faint-hearted as it contains physical child abuse. Good and evil are not as clear cut as it is in most fantasy. All three of the trilogy’s novels won Hugo awards, which is a feat unmatched by any other series.

mitskacir's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

What I wanted from this conclusion: 1) Some explanations - mostly check; 2) some action that moved the plot forward - mostly check; 3) feeling some emotion towards the characters - nope (but I never really did in the other books, so I didn't have high hopes for it here); 4) more chapters from Shaffa's POV - nope (I think a severe detriment to the third book, as he really was the most intriguing character and the one who had changed most in the series). What we did get was chapters from Hoa's POV, which I very much enjoyed - he was certainly the most emotionally relatable character in the series, and his chapters provided much needed back story and explanation of how the world came to be in such a mess. However, there were still a few to many gaps missing for me to be really satisfied by the backstory and the ultimate resolution of conflict (which, compared to how plodding the series is, happened exceedingly quickly in the second to last chapter). I'm not disappointed I read this, as it was very different from novels I've read before (in the writing style and world building) and that in itself is an accomplishment.

kifkathleen's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional hopeful medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

mvan998's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional hopeful medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Plot
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

haykim's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

this series was….phenomenal, heartbreaking, and hopeful all at once. An awe-inspiringly rich world, magic system, cast of characters, series of events. The Stone Sky in particular I could not put down. I put off reading this one for a while, I think bc I knew it would be gut wrenching. But I’m so glad I finally read it.