Scan barcode
ilvermorny73's review against another edition
5.0
Truly great. I loved it once I found out the girls weren't British.
ljankowski19's review against another edition
1.0
It was a good classic old story ,but for me, i do not wish to hear about young woman's little problems for most of the story. Not saying all of it was like that, but most.
jagisoffline's review against another edition
2.0
Story: 2/5. This was quite a bit of a burden to get through. It's not that it's a bad story, but it is perhaps something for a very particular kind of reader and I am not that reader. It was laborious for me because it is full of so much lightness and has almost no tension or stakes to balance all of its levity and wholesomeness. It is an altogether wholesome tale of four sisters and their love for each other and their parents, and everything that then transpires over the course of a few years of their lives. It is, in a sense, a slice of their lives, but their lives are mostly riddled with small errors and lapses in judgement which are almost always immediately mended and forgiven. These characters come off as unnaturally understanding and patient with each other in a way that makes them feel as though they existed in an alternate utopia where people don't get angry or hold grudges or treat people badly. I just finished this after suffering through it at a snail's pace and I don't believe I can think of a single truly antagonistic experience in the story. Perhaps it was written for a dark time when people needed hope and to be reminded that goodness still persists, I don't know. But it left me feeling quite unsatisfied and begging for something to care about. In the end, it really was only some of its character work that kept me through it until the last dreadful page.
Characterisation: 3/5. This is the saving grace of this otherwise bone-dry experience. Though most of its characters are just the most perfect and consideration caricatures on the planet, Jo March and Amy March were its most fully-realised and realistic characters throughout. The chapters concerning Jo and Amy were the only ones I felt myself truly invested in and keeping up with (bar Amy's last handful of moments). Jo felt real and driven and conflicted and had beliefs which fluctuated realistically whenever certain events occurred. Her relationships with the other characters seemed to drive the narrative and she was followed in this very closely by Amy. Laurie had his moments, too, and Bhaer was a good and healthy addition to the story.
Language: 2/5. Herein lies my other problem with the experience of this read. I have read other books from the 1800s before and this was the sloggiest of all of them, by far. This writing style is the absolute example of why 'show don't tell' is a rule. We are told every fluctuating emotion of every character in every interaction and are never left to deduce any of it ourselves. Worse more, these fluctuations are usually conclusive and inclusive of their future actions. We are told resolutely that this is now what the character has decided and how they will be, moving forward. There is no mystery in the experience of this novel and it kills all excitement which could exist in its reading. It was utterly frustrating and also felt very much in its tone as though we were being spoken to like children or - in many of its moments - like young girls being taught how to live the most godly and conservative family-led lives. It felt very much like a product of its time in a very tiring and demeaning way and it was not a good experience. When sharing in its world, it was fairly vivid and had enough character to get by, which makes me believe that Louisa May Alcott had a beautiful world within her, but no such story to populate it with.
7/15: I have no desire to ever think about this again.
Characterisation: 3/5. This is the saving grace of this otherwise bone-dry experience. Though most of its characters are just the most perfect and consideration caricatures on the planet, Jo March and Amy March were its most fully-realised and realistic characters throughout. The chapters concerning Jo and Amy were the only ones I felt myself truly invested in and keeping up with (bar Amy's last handful of moments). Jo felt real and driven and conflicted and had beliefs which fluctuated realistically whenever certain events occurred. Her relationships with the other characters seemed to drive the narrative and she was followed in this very closely by Amy. Laurie had his moments, too, and Bhaer was a good and healthy addition to the story.
Language: 2/5. Herein lies my other problem with the experience of this read. I have read other books from the 1800s before and this was the sloggiest of all of them, by far. This writing style is the absolute example of why 'show don't tell' is a rule. We are told every fluctuating emotion of every character in every interaction and are never left to deduce any of it ourselves. Worse more, these fluctuations are usually conclusive and inclusive of their future actions. We are told resolutely that this is now what the character has decided and how they will be, moving forward. There is no mystery in the experience of this novel and it kills all excitement which could exist in its reading. It was utterly frustrating and also felt very much in its tone as though we were being spoken to like children or - in many of its moments - like young girls being taught how to live the most godly and conservative family-led lives. It felt very much like a product of its time in a very tiring and demeaning way and it was not a good experience. When sharing in its world, it was fairly vivid and had enough character to get by, which makes me believe that Louisa May Alcott had a beautiful world within her, but no such story to populate it with.
7/15: I have no desire to ever think about this again.
aidaninasia's review against another edition
2.0
I think this is one of those books where you either really like it or you really don’t. I really don’t. I was reading it with a student of mine, they had chosen it. It is a touching story but as I am not Christian, I could not appreciate it entirely.
electricicebird's review against another edition
5.0
An excellent book which I listened to on librivox
anyacrittenton's review against another edition
4.0
First read:
My mother's been trying to get me to read this my entire life and I'm so glad I finally did! It was so lovely and charming. I grew particularly fond of Jo and Amy. I had been misled about Jo and Laurie's relationship (and found him rather childish and infuriating until Amy knocked some sense into him) but I'm very pleased for how everything turned out. I was absolutely smitten and endeared by the Professor.
Second read:
I am still Jo, Jo is still me. The older I get, the more I love Amy. She grows so much and by the time she's in Europe, she's such an amazing woman. And I love how she puts Laurie in his place. She and Laurie belong together, as do Jo and Bhaer.
My mother's been trying to get me to read this my entire life and I'm so glad I finally did! It was so lovely and charming. I grew particularly fond of Jo and Amy. I had been misled about Jo and Laurie's relationship (and found him rather childish and infuriating until Amy knocked some sense into him) but I'm very pleased for how everything turned out. I was absolutely smitten and endeared by the Professor.
Second read:
I am still Jo, Jo is still me. The older I get, the more I love Amy. She grows so much and by the time she's in Europe, she's such an amazing woman. And I love how she puts Laurie in his place. She and Laurie belong together, as do Jo and Bhaer.
shaelinsan's review against another edition
3.0
Finally I finished Little Women and Good Wives yeayy
What a long journey!
This book is slow paced and feels like I'm growing up with them
What a long journey!
This book is slow paced and feels like I'm growing up with them
abarbaramf's review against another edition
3.0
I read this maybe 5 times when I was 10, and haven't read it again ever since. The parts about Pilgrim's Progress and Pickwick Club always annoyed me.