funny hopeful informative lighthearted reflective sad slow-paced
informative slow-paced

cmollyw's review

5.0
informative fast-paced
informative lighthearted reflective fast-paced

Very interesting history of retail and fashion and influencer culture in the American zeitgeist. I’d recommend this as a follow up to Selling Sexy (The history Victoria’s Secret) and Glossy (a profile on the founder of Glossier). 

I love a corporate rise/fall. It's my true crime. This one was particularly interesting to me even though I never really wore much J Crew. I always saw it as an expensive brand for some reason, which made the discussions of affordability or lack thereof interesting.

I particularly enjoyed the discussions of the development of preppy fashion and the effects of the modern fast fashion, rapid trend cycling on the fashion landscape. 
informative slow-paced

Apparently I enjoy corporate case studies (for companies I find interesting)? Would probably rate 3.5 for the overuse of the moniker “merchant prince.”

This was a great, informative book that I enjoyed tremendously. It's so fun getting a peek behind the curtain of the fashion industry - while yes, J. Crew isn't fashion it did work very hard to be, and it is completely embedded in the cultural zeitgeist. I myself have shopped a J. Crew for many years, and had no idea that all of this was brewing behind the scenes.
medium-paced

Listened to the audiobook. I thought this was okay. I really liked the beginning and the thoughtful cultural analysis of economic class and how ready-to-wear prep clothing helped promote a specific ideal. I would have liked more of that and less about IPOs and the company's seemingly endless financial struggles, which got old after a while. Emily Cinader and Jenna Lyons are by far the more interesting characters in J. Crew's story, I didn't care so much about all their seemingly inept male CEOs.

The reflections on the evolutions of retail were somewhat interesting, but definitely written for an audience that lived it firsthand. Catalogs were pretty much done by the time I had my own spending money (I'm more the Madewell generation I think). Thought it was interesting as J. Crew is really making a comeback but not as juicy as I had hoped