2.23k reviews for:

The Giving Tree

Shel Silverstein

4.29 AVERAGE

dlazar's review

5.0

One of my all time favorites. I read this to my kids a lot (try not to cry). It is about unconditional love and giving and kindness.
desertjarhead505's profile picture

desertjarhead505's review

1.0

What a load of maudlin, "abuse-me-please", codependent garbage... there is healthy giving, and then there is giving oneself away totally to those who neither need nor appreciate the gift, and this is a glorification of the latter. What was the man thinking?
ellianamaselli's profile picture

ellianamaselli's review

5.0

I memorized this book cover-to-cover for a presentation at my school about a year ago. It makes me tear up, and I think at least four people in the audience had the same experience. This book is lovely. I think everyone should read it.

unsettled_narrator's review

5.0

A great book that should be read by teachers and students alike.
sbramlett's profile picture

sbramlett's review

3.0

This book was so sad for a children's book! I felt so bad for that poor tree who just loved the boy so much! But at the same time it was a great little book that I will love to read to my children someday.
mmaric's profile picture

mmaric's review

4.0
sad fast-paced

jcj25's review

4.0

It always makes me cry, but the best re-reading ever was when I came across this:
"the tree who set healthy boundaries" - a parody alternate ending by Topher Payne. Please do yourself a favor and look this up, then replace the problematic pages with these. Still a wonderfully meaningful and engaging story, and you can be fulfilled at the end, instead of grieving and ravaged.

saydebug's review

4.0
reflective sad medium-paced

sashapasha's review

4.0

This is literally a two-minute read and it made me cry, so I guess the takeaway is don’t read it after the loss of a parent.
irishslib's profile picture

irishslib's review

3.0
reflective fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: N/A
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

read it for work but didnt expect it to be philosophical. allows us to reflect on our own relationship with nature & those around us