Reviews

Beautifully Broken (#1) by Shery A. Soule

bookboyfriendandhusbandmake3's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

As per usual, Lee has left me speechless and so angry at myself for not reading this until now. Beautifully Broken is quite different from her other books, and I’m truly blown away that this was only the second book she published.

Her talent knows no bounds; even from the start, her words prove that she excels at creating characters that feel as though you’ve known them your whole life, even though you’ve only just met them. A storyline that immediately pulls you in and gets more mesmerizing with every word.


I went into this not really knowing anything about it. I hadn’t even read the blurb. Within a few pages, you could feel the waves of heartbreak begin to crash against your chest. Kat’s life hadn’t been easy, to say the least.

Now that that’s out of the way, Kat had spent most of her life in and out of foster care. Her mother was an addict and led a life less than desirable, surely one that would traumatize a child who was continuously ripped from her home. She had learned early on that the only person she was able to rely on was herself. She wasn’t really able to be a kid, and that’s something I connected with; although my experience was different than hers, the emotions I’ve had were right there on the pages before my eyes.

She kept her heart locked down like Fort Knox. In her experience, when you let someone in, it is soon followed by heartbreak. Even still, while she kept relationships out of the equation, she wasn’t completely hardened to the world. She was just tired—not like she needed a nap, more like bone-deep exhaustion. She was sassy and incredibly determined to move away from the town and all the judgmental stares from people who only thought they knew who she was.

Gavin was sweet, but don’t let that fool you; he had the growly alpha side too. When he looked at Kat, he didn’t just see her beauty; he had a way of looking deeper and seeing the things she never allowed anyone to see. The pain that she masked—it seemed as though he was the only one who could see what was underneath it all.

It may have started with physical chemistry, but that was merely the ignition that lit the all-consuming, soul-searing connection between Gavin and Kat. The moment they met, it was palpable, and it only grew more intense with every interaction. Even when they knew they shouldn’t and tried to keep some distance between them, it felt as though there was a magnetic force that kept them from doing what they "should."

I’m not sure there are words to express the emotions these characters feel, and more specifically, the vigorous way they flow through you. The waves come and go; at times it feels as though it’s the calm before the storm, and then it’s a hurricane of emotion until you feel like you can’t breathe. My heart shattered right alongside Gavin and Kat, but in between the angsty turmoil, there was more healing than I could have imagined. Not just with the fictional characters. I was able to find an escape that I needed desperately. I needed to escape reality, and it’s been hard to find it lately.

When an author can not only draw your mind into the world they created, but also have their characters' emotions take over as if they were your own, I believe it is a true testament to their talent. Lee has that and more. You open the pages, and you aren’t just an observer of the story taking place on the pages. You feel a part of it, and that adds to your ability to allow yourself to escape into the fictional world before you.

I can’t think of a better note to bring my 2022 reading to a close. Maybe there was a reason I continued to push this book down my TBR list. It hadn’t been the right time. I needed the escape that this book offered me on every level, and because of that, I only slightly regret putting it off for so long. I don’t recommend being like me, though. Don’t put it off. Dive in headfirst and don’t look back.

If, for whatever reason, you’ve felt as though you’re broken, then this book is for you. Allow for this story to sweep you away to another place, and while you’re there, take to heart the healing that happens in the pages of this fictional world. Your story may be different, but it doesn’t make the lessons learned throughout Gavin and Kat’s story any less impactful.

Beautifully Broken is a must-read. An unputdownable combination of soul-searing chemistry, a swoony alpha hero, and a sassy and incredibly strong heroine, brimming with angst, wit, healing, and hella hot steam.


One more thing.

I once saw a comment from someone on an author’s post expressing how much she hates when characters have "horrible, disgusting, no-good parents," and she feels as though it’s a lazy way for an author to create conflict.

I think that she may have been one of the lucky ones who made it through childhood without trauma. We aren’t all that lucky, so when we read a book with people who are going through similar things, we feel connected to the character in a much different way than usual. Not only that, but if the feelings that you’ve had are expressed by the character, even if it’s only the inner monologue, as the character finds a sense of healing, there are times that it helps to heal a little bit of what’s broken inside you.

I think an author being able to help readers connect with a character in such a profound way is the exact opposite of lazy. The comment was a slap in the face to anyone who has connected with a character because they shared similar experiences as the character with "horrible, disgusting, no-good parents." Sometimes it’s those very things that can help someone not feel so alone.





Website | Amazon | Facebook | Instagram

jill_mac's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Gavin and Kat were everything!

It’s been a minute since I read a Student/teacher romance and this one was one of the best!

I’m usually picky with s/t reads, but Beautifully Broken did not disappoint. The angst. The steam. The emotion. It was all addicting. I found myself missing the story anytime I had to put it down.

This is my first by Laura Lee, but it definitely won’t be my last!

rosesandwords's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This book was just the best feel good love story. Ugh I can’t get over it. It started with a taboo relationship, mixed in with heavy loss, an amazing love connection, some heartbreak and a redemption that just makes your heart soar!
The love in this story truly just made me feel good, it was pure and gave me every bit of butterflies.
Our main FMC is a complex woman with a difficult past and plenty of obstacles in her life, but her strength and growth are really inspiring.
And to top it off the spice is just delicious!

Trigger warnings: SA, substance abuse, loss of a parent and loss of a child.
Safe reading loves, your mental health matters

all_bookedup19's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

3.5 stars

Thank you to the Smuthood and Laura Lee for letting me be a part of this tour.

I'll start off by saying I am confused. The blurb makes it seem that this book starts, things happen, and then suddenly it's 4 years later. But we don't get to 4 years later until we are 90% done.

Kat has been through a lot, in and out of foster care homes most of her life. Her mom is a heroin addict, she doesn't know who her father is. She went through something traumatic as a freshman in high school and now she uses alcohol and (mostly) sex to numb herself. On her 18th birthday, she meets Gavin in a bar. He is recently divorced. they go home, she sneaks out of his house. Fast forward to the first day of school, she realizes that he is her teacher.

Now, this is where I have an issue. Multiple times Kat mentions they live in a small town, and everyone knows everyone's business, yet Kat is constantly at his house, they are constantly in his classroom with the door shut, and no one notices? I believe once it was mentioned they went grocery shopping together (but I could be wrong). I just don't understand how they didn't get caught by anyone else. Also, Dylan was a little pushy throughout most of the book, practically begging, and almost forcing Kat to have sex. I did not like that at all!

Don't get me wrong this was a good book, I laughed at certain parts, and I got teary at certain parts, I felt so bad for Kat at certain parts. Watching the character growth of Kat was amazing. By the end of the book, I was her biggest cheerleader. This is still one that I will recommend.

elizasbookshelf's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.5 stars

I enjoy watching Kat's growth with this story. She had a rough childhood in and out of the foster care system and still dealing with some of it in her final year of school. She doesn't play the victim and give up. She takes what happens to her and makes it to where that is not the only thing that defines who she is. She's determined to get a scholarship to college.

I wish we got more of the story 4 years after Kat and Gavin meet. The synopsis makes it seem like it would be 50/50 high school then 4 years later and it wasn't. I like the back story and seeing how they got to where they are now. But I also want more after the coffee shop.
More...