Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.92 AVERAGE
3.92 AVERAGE
Would give it a 3.5 if I could. I liked it, but it didn't totally draw me in.
The title 'The House of Broken Angels' is a perfect one for this novel. A domestic fiction, the story is loosely based on the author Luis Alberto Urrea's real family.
The history of four generations, from the mid-twentieth century to current time, is told in flashbacks while a birthday party for the family's Mexican-American patriarch, Big Angel, is planned. Big Angel is seventy and dying of cancer. He reflects about his own brutal father, Don Antonio, and about being a Man and a father, while surveying the gathering of the three current generations of his extended family, prematurely in attendance before his planned birthday party because of the unexpected death of his mother, Mamá América. We readers also follow along in the activities of several other members of the family.
Perla is Big Angel's devoted wife. Her sister, La Gloriosa, was and still is the beauty of the family, much desired still by younger brothers-in-law. Little Angel, Big Angel's youngest half-brother is such a one, although his mother was an American woman, Betty, not Perla, a result of Don Antonio deserting his Mexican family to live in America. Little Angel moved to Seattle, and he does not feel very Mexican or accepted by his large Mexican family despite his fluent bilingualism. However, he accepts the invitation to attend Mamá América's funeral and his older brother's birthday party, re-establishing many family relationships. There are some surprising revelations, such as some of the third generations' involvements in drugs and gangs. One of the unexpected developments is the spilling over into Big Angel's party plans a drug-addicted nephew’s issue with a gang banger.
The result of these marriages and pairings was a lot of now adult children - and some of them are profiled in depth in this story through flashbacks as well as current life events. The result is somewhat confusing to read, and I wish some notice that a family tree had been supplied in the back had been said before I discovered it in turning the last page! Explanations of family relationships and connections are brief or slowly revealed in the text, so I recommend paying attention and a close reading is required. These are my only complaints about the structure of the book.
My last quibble is related to my predilections - I felt claustrophobic due to the family dramas. The book is full of heartwarming humor and ordinary family dramas - especially in accurately detailing in brief vignettes the dying body of Big Angel, but I simply find such close large families exhausting in real life. The fact that I was triggered by the book into feeling suffocated is actually a tribute to the author's talent!
; p
The history of four generations, from the mid-twentieth century to current time, is told in flashbacks while a birthday party for the family's Mexican-American patriarch, Big Angel, is planned. Big Angel is seventy and dying of cancer. He reflects about his own brutal father, Don Antonio, and about being a Man and a father, while surveying the gathering of the three current generations of his extended family, prematurely in attendance before his planned birthday party because of the unexpected death of his mother, Mamá América. We readers also follow along in the activities of several other members of the family.
Perla is Big Angel's devoted wife. Her sister, La Gloriosa, was and still is the beauty of the family, much desired still by younger brothers-in-law. Little Angel, Big Angel's youngest half-brother is such a one, although his mother was an American woman, Betty, not Perla, a result of Don Antonio deserting his Mexican family to live in America. Little Angel moved to Seattle, and he does not feel very Mexican or accepted by his large Mexican family despite his fluent bilingualism. However, he accepts the invitation to attend Mamá América's funeral and his older brother's birthday party, re-establishing many family relationships. There are some surprising revelations, such as some of the third generations' involvements in drugs and gangs. One of the unexpected developments is the spilling over into Big Angel's party plans a drug-addicted nephew’s issue with a gang banger.
The result of these marriages and pairings was a lot of now adult children - and some of them are profiled in depth in this story through flashbacks as well as current life events. The result is somewhat confusing to read, and I wish some notice that a family tree had been supplied in the back had been said before I discovered it in turning the last page! Explanations of family relationships and connections are brief or slowly revealed in the text, so I recommend paying attention and a close reading is required. These are my only complaints about the structure of the book.
My last quibble is related to my predilections - I felt claustrophobic due to the family dramas. The book is full of heartwarming humor and ordinary family dramas - especially in accurately detailing in brief vignettes the dying body of Big Angel, but I simply find such close large families exhausting in real life. The fact that I was triggered by the book into feeling suffocated is actually a tribute to the author's talent!
; p
At the end of the day, all he really knew was that he was a Mexican father. And Mexican fathers made speeches. He wanted to leave her with a blessing, with beautiful words to sum up a life, but there were no words sufficient to this day. But still, he tried. “All we do, mija,” he said, “is love. Love is the answer. Nothing stops it. Not borders. Not death.”
Synopsis
Big Angel is dying, but before he goes, he wants his family—all of the twisting branches of it—gathered for his last birthday. Nothing will derail Big Angel’s party—not borders, not internal family feuds, not even his own mother’s death. Told over the span of the days leading up to the party and the party itself, The House of Broken Angels is the story of an unforgettable Mexican-American patriarch and the life he built for his family, spanning decades and borders alike.
Prose
There is a distinctive voice to The House of Broken Angels—though I am an adult myself, Big Angel’s story is presented so intimately and warmly, I felt as if I were a child, drawn onto his knee, to hear a story from my grandfather. The prose is beautiful and enveloping in a way that invites the reader to join the family—this messy, imperfect, sprawling, grieving, celebrating family. Every word felt deliberately chosen and just right. The tone of the vignettes swing wildly from sad, to shocking, to funny, to irreverent—and yet every swing was just right.
As I read, I lost myself in this book—I wasn’t sitting in bed holding a kindle—I was in Big Angel’s backyard, smelling the food, listening to the children shriek, and waiting for Big Angel to come out of his house. For entire stretches at a time, I was in Big Angel’s world in Southern California, only to snap back after thirty or forty minutes to my quiet bedroom. Those moments when you can lose yourself so completely in a book that you are no longer aware that you are reading are so rare, and yet they became common for me on the nights I read this book.
Characters
This family is far from perfect—there’s sadness and violence waiting in the wings for many of these characters, there’s machismo and terrible choices—and yet I loved them. I loved Big Angel’s son Lalo as he grieved, as he fumbled around his definition of what it meant to be a man. I loved Little Angel (so named because Big Angel’s philandering father reused the name on his youngest son) as he sought his place within this family as the half-brother, chosen by their father over them and then ultimately abandoned as well. Minnie, dutiful daughter, yet still missing something—torn between exasperation at being treated far younger than her thirty-something years and yet wanting to stay the baby of the family if it means her father is alive to treat her that way. And Big Angel—imperfect patriarch, yet capable of such dedication to his wife and his children that he seemed larger than life, though trapped in his wasted body. These are complicated people, defined by their blood to Angel and also their humanness, their ordinariness. I half expect there to be a real De La Cruz family in San Diego throwing Big Angel his birthday this weekend.
Immigration and current events
The De La Cruz family and Big Angel himself are Mexican-Americans. They are of one place, living and contributing to the community and economy of another. Some of the members of the family, including Big Angel himself, are undocumented. And here again is where I come back to Urrea’s presentation of Big Angel as larger than life and yet so very ordinary. The House of Broken Angels is the story of the family next door, or maybe across town. You buy groceries next to Big Angel’s wife Perla and you sat next to his son Lalo in high school bio.
I noted in my last review that The Fruit of the Drunken Tree is a single story that explains why so many people might leave their homes in South American to come across our border. The House of Broken Angels is another. Immigration is never simple once actual human beings are involved. It is one thing to speak of policy and “illegals.” It is another to look a human being in the face—a veteran, a long-time employee, and favorite neighbor—and tell them they do not belong. You are not us. The stories of Big Angel’s families are not all stories of lives well-lived. Not yet. And yet they are lives of value. They are lives that belong. Books like The House of Broken Angels seem vitally important in this current climate—in a climate where it is not safe for a neighbor to confide over the fence that he is undocumented and scared. When maybe you don’t know whether you know anyone who is undocumented and it’s not really the thing you ask right now. Read books like The House of Broken Angels and Fruit of the Drunken Tree to remind yourself that what is at stake is the dignity and lives of people.
Notes
Published: March 6, 2018 by Little, Brown, & Co.
Author: Luis Alberto Urrea
Date read: July 11, 2018
Rating: 5 stars* (I swear I don’t usually give this many books 5 stars, I’ve just had a really good streak of reading).
Synopsis
Big Angel is dying, but before he goes, he wants his family—all of the twisting branches of it—gathered for his last birthday. Nothing will derail Big Angel’s party—not borders, not internal family feuds, not even his own mother’s death. Told over the span of the days leading up to the party and the party itself, The House of Broken Angels is the story of an unforgettable Mexican-American patriarch and the life he built for his family, spanning decades and borders alike.
Prose
There is a distinctive voice to The House of Broken Angels—though I am an adult myself, Big Angel’s story is presented so intimately and warmly, I felt as if I were a child, drawn onto his knee, to hear a story from my grandfather. The prose is beautiful and enveloping in a way that invites the reader to join the family—this messy, imperfect, sprawling, grieving, celebrating family. Every word felt deliberately chosen and just right. The tone of the vignettes swing wildly from sad, to shocking, to funny, to irreverent—and yet every swing was just right.
As I read, I lost myself in this book—I wasn’t sitting in bed holding a kindle—I was in Big Angel’s backyard, smelling the food, listening to the children shriek, and waiting for Big Angel to come out of his house. For entire stretches at a time, I was in Big Angel’s world in Southern California, only to snap back after thirty or forty minutes to my quiet bedroom. Those moments when you can lose yourself so completely in a book that you are no longer aware that you are reading are so rare, and yet they became common for me on the nights I read this book.
Characters
This family is far from perfect—there’s sadness and violence waiting in the wings for many of these characters, there’s machismo and terrible choices—and yet I loved them. I loved Big Angel’s son Lalo as he grieved, as he fumbled around his definition of what it meant to be a man. I loved Little Angel (so named because Big Angel’s philandering father reused the name on his youngest son) as he sought his place within this family as the half-brother, chosen by their father over them and then ultimately abandoned as well. Minnie, dutiful daughter, yet still missing something—torn between exasperation at being treated far younger than her thirty-something years and yet wanting to stay the baby of the family if it means her father is alive to treat her that way. And Big Angel—imperfect patriarch, yet capable of such dedication to his wife and his children that he seemed larger than life, though trapped in his wasted body. These are complicated people, defined by their blood to Angel and also their humanness, their ordinariness. I half expect there to be a real De La Cruz family in San Diego throwing Big Angel his birthday this weekend.
Immigration and current events
The De La Cruz family and Big Angel himself are Mexican-Americans. They are of one place, living and contributing to the community and economy of another. Some of the members of the family, including Big Angel himself, are undocumented. And here again is where I come back to Urrea’s presentation of Big Angel as larger than life and yet so very ordinary. The House of Broken Angels is the story of the family next door, or maybe across town. You buy groceries next to Big Angel’s wife Perla and you sat next to his son Lalo in high school bio.
I noted in my last review that The Fruit of the Drunken Tree is a single story that explains why so many people might leave their homes in South American to come across our border. The House of Broken Angels is another. Immigration is never simple once actual human beings are involved. It is one thing to speak of policy and “illegals.” It is another to look a human being in the face—a veteran, a long-time employee, and favorite neighbor—and tell them they do not belong. You are not us. The stories of Big Angel’s families are not all stories of lives well-lived. Not yet. And yet they are lives of value. They are lives that belong. Books like The House of Broken Angels seem vitally important in this current climate—in a climate where it is not safe for a neighbor to confide over the fence that he is undocumented and scared. When maybe you don’t know whether you know anyone who is undocumented and it’s not really the thing you ask right now. Read books like The House of Broken Angels and Fruit of the Drunken Tree to remind yourself that what is at stake is the dignity and lives of people.
Notes
Published: March 6, 2018 by Little, Brown, & Co.
Author: Luis Alberto Urrea
Date read: July 11, 2018
Rating: 5 stars* (I swear I don’t usually give this many books 5 stars, I’ve just had a really good streak of reading).
emotional
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
One of the best books I've read in a while. Funny and poignant with believable, authentic characters. It's a story of love, forgiveness and family.
I give this 3.5 stars. It has some really lovely and surprising moments, but dragged in a few places.
adventurous
emotional
funny
informative
inspiring
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Strong character development:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
emotional
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Read for the Seattle Reads choice of the year. Excellent opportunity to read something I might not otherwise pick up. Mexican immigrant family, patriarch was primary voice.
For most of this book, I listened to the audio which I highly recommend. The stories shared throughout each page made me feel as though I was sitting at a family reunion and listening to all of the stories each person shared. Some sad. Some hilarious. "They would spend forever side by side. And the rest of his fallen children would one day slumber around them all, a constellation of extinguished stars." The perfect book to cuddle up with; storytelling at its best.