3.59 AVERAGE


While I was very excited about the premise for this book, I absolutely fell flat for me. My biggest gripe was that I hated every character in this book. I didn't even like hating them. Towards the end, it started to take twists and turns just for the sake of taking twists and turns. It's like the writer was trying too hard to surprise us. Overall, a disappointment.

Cool retelling of Jane Eyre even if the plot was slow

3.5⭐️ I enjoyed some parts of this book a lot but other parts were tough to get through. I know that a lot of the rich girl country club nonsense was for the character building but boy did I hate it.

Not my favorite of the Hawkins books. Jane got really annoying quite quickly. The twist was fairly predictable as was the wrap up. Meh.

2.5
mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No

If you like Verity by Colleen Hoover, you'll like this. 4stars bc there was a lot of teasing of the main character's past, but not much was really revealed.

This review could start one of two ways. I could give you the premise and my impressions or I can do what I am doing now. I will tell you that while reading this book, I could not help but think of Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier or The Wife Between Us by Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen - both of which I thought were excellent books.

Now, what was it about The Wife Upstairs that made me ponder over those other titles? Well, Jane is a dog-walker in a gated community. The community is rather elite and the women are quite snobbish. Jane definitely does not fit in, but meeting Eddie Rochester is about to change her life. She just might be able to become one of them.

Eddie has a story that he would not rather have to tell. His wife and her best friend have disappeared and is is assumed both women drowned. What is more is that a shroud of guilt is hanging over Eddie's neck. Nonetheless, Eddie and Jane hit it off and the two become a couple. However, Jane is constantly reminded of Eddie's previous wife Bea. She was an icon of sorts. For one thing, Jane often feels that the women in the community are constantly comparing her to Bea. Then there is Eddie. Something is not quite right, especially when she is fighting for his heart, knowing how much he loved and misses Bea every single day.

So Jane changes her appearance, her dialogue and inserts herself into every aspect of Eddie's life and the community. Will it be enough? Meanwhile, there is something eerie going on. Chilling actually, and that is the point when the previously mentioned titles came to my mind.

However, this book has its own edge, its own level of creepiness, deceit and mystery. As a matter of fact, the blurb alludes to a love triangle. Why is that? Well, you would have to read this chilling book by Rachel Hawkins so that you can get that answer. I would have loved to give this book five stars, but the conclusion threw me. Even so, this was a twisty read, filled with a variety of characters, many rather unlikable at best. The plot and its twists were rather captivating and definitely caught me by surprise.

Many thanks to St. Martin's Press and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.

A good read, albeit predictable at points and i would've enjoyed more "closure" at the end. A very quick read that captured my attention

This book was a lot of fun. I haven't read Jane Eyre, so those elements were lost on me, but it was a fast read.