3.4 AVERAGE


I'd avoided reading this based on an excerpt I'd read some time ago. It was just... yuck. I've learned to embrace the yuck.

This is essentially a novel of short stories... there's an over-arching plot that pulls things together. It feels like Chuck had a lot of ideas that worked in a short format, not not a full novel. And these do work (well, mostly). They're sick in that way that you love for Chuck to be sick. Not the Palahniuk gateway-drug, but if you're a fan, you'll like this. A bit weak as it nears the end, but pretty satisfying all-around.

robin_huff's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 65%

some short stories were great, others okay, still others just transphobic vitriol. the plot in between stories was too convoluted to be worthwhile. stopped in the middle of a particularly transphobic chapter and just didn't want to finish. 

I just couldn’t fully commit to this. You start to get an understanding, and then four new stories occur about the characters you’re learning about. Good idea, just not for me.

No matter what, keep reading. Keep track of the stories. Piece together these characters. Don't get scared out of finishing this book. Don't label it "weird," or "creepy," and give up on it. Keep reading. This book might change you.

It's definitely not his best work, but there are lots of funny, memorable, disgusting, enjoyable moments.

killerqueen565's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 50%

Downloaded as Audiobook. I think it is meant to be read. 
dark funny sad tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Do not read this book if you have literally any triggers. Most people know about the pool scene, but there's also horrific transphobia, child abuse, and animal death. Proceed with caution. 

So, obviously this is kind of a gross book. That aside, I did have trouble getting into it for like the first 2/3rds. This wasn't because of the gross stuff...it was more because I thought it was so stupid. People don't work like this, logic doesn't work like this, the world doesn't work like this. I got hung up on wondering whether Chuck P actually believed this is how things are.

This was exasperated by the fact that there are like 16 main characters, and I found their voices and personalities pretty indistinguishable. It felt like Chuck P was using these puppets to make the same stupid points over and over.

But the last 1/3rd of the book, imo, made his kafka-adjacent logic more obviously purposeful. It helped that the themes of haunting, storytelling, and performance were spelled out for dumdums like me. I loved the ending of this book.

That being said, even though I was tempted to rate this 4 stars, I went with 3.75 because I am fresh off this novel and worried that l was being biased by a spectacular ending tacked onto a so-so book.

Also I hated the poetry. Gd, did I hate the poetry.

This isn't a boring book, by any means. I just found it frustrating in the beginning. I did think the
foot job stuff
was hilarious. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

“Guts” and “Exodus” I will never forget
challenging dark funny medium-paced

The wraparound story is very weak, but some of the short stories are among the best I've ever read, redeeming the book overall.
challenging dark emotional funny sad tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Expand filter menu Content Warnings