Reviews

Serpent's Return: A Superhero Urban Fantasy by Trish Heinrich

kristielmeyer's review

Go to review page

5.0

This book kicks ass!

Very well-written, descriptive without being wordy, action-packed, and filled to the brim with complex and fascinating characters! I'm 25 and I'd be the first to admit superheroes aren't really my thing, but I couldn't put this book down. Well done! I'm a fan.

whit2ney's review

Go to review page

4.0

Heinrich does not shy away from action and pain, lemme tell ya. I almost thought this book was written by a doctor because each kick, punch, throw, or slam felt real. She sustained not only good action descriptions to help you follow what's happening, but she honors the damage each character sustains. There's no Mary Sue-ing going on, even with the superheroes involved. I appreciated this because it gives into the authenticity she's going for with the superhero/1960's/Glory Days vibe. Maybe she's also a vigilante, but each character carries the weight of their injuries—physical and mental—that is believable and sustained. We don't have of this "walk it off" nonsense here.

Okay, so I'm a sucker for feminism, so I'll bite. There's a lot of female empowerment in this book. I wouldn't say it's "perfect" feminism, but who really pulls it off every time? I'd like to this of this novel as the femme version of Batman where you've got a female protagonist, a few female role models, a female tech specialist, and a slew of male characters that know how to work with women to get the job done. No one's really portrayed as better or stronger than the other, which is nice. We've also got some pivotal characters that aren't white! Huzzah! I could gush more about the feminist elements that I love, but that might give too much away.

There was this sort of redundancy that happens throughout the novel that was somewhat frustrating—the martyr trope. There is at least one scene where Alice/Serpent, Lionel, or Marco tell the other two to get out and they would stall or fight. Everyone takes turns doing this, and the other two always insist on staying and fighting as a whole team. I understand the need for this every once and a while, but it felt like it happened every fight. It got tiring after a while and it didn't show as much individual or team growth as I'd like.

I also cringed a bit at the amount of mixed signals Alice gives both of the men. It's obvious early on that she looks up to, trusts, and likes both of them. She admires both of their bodies and personalities. And you can tell they both really like her back—Lionel is an exceptionally open book. It was cringey how obvious it was that they both liked her, and yet she would almost kiss or insist on being embraced for comfort, giving private and public mixed signals. I'm already not a fan of love triangles because they are often so tropey (noteably in YA fiction), and so this might've worked for other readers, but I wanted Alice to pick one and be clear about it. You'll have to read the novel to see where the love triangle takes them.

If you like The Incredibles, Batman, Black Widow, or feminism, you'll love this novel cocktail version. Heinrich does not shy away from some serious topics like violence, trauma, physical abuse, racism, sexism, and more. She doesn't get preachy, which I like, but you do see that tension between the way things are and the way we'd like things to be.

marjories's review

Go to review page

5.0

More than anything else, this book is real. Reading this it is completely plausible that people with X-Men like powers were running around after WWII. The characters are strong, flawed, and dynamic. It is a character driven book with lots of action, a little romance, and no happy ending, but all the stronger for that. No deus ex machina etc here.

The MC's greatest strength is her desire never to be vulnerable again and the amazing support of family and friends that helps her grow into a powerful woman.

ps The descriptions of the costumes in the book were wicked! I wish they were better represented on the cover.

scott_a_gardner's review

Go to review page

4.0

Pulp inspired supers

The real hero (pun unavoidable) is Serpent. Time period is later than the original pulp novels of the 30's, but you'll recognize shades of Doc Savage and The Avenger. Emerging super powers explained by science. Ripping good yarn, suitable for 10 years and up.
More...