Reviews

Linchpin: Are You Indispensable? by Seth Godin

drewflynn's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Easy read, loved his idea of "ship it". A book that I would have loved to have read right out of high school, but scattered throughout are tidbits useful and empowering information that are applicable even to me now.

jaclynday's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Although prone to repetition, Godin’s book about becoming an indispensable, creative thinker is motivating and inspiring.
“Outsourcing and automation and the new marketing punish anyone who is merely good, merely obedient, and merely reliable.”

While reading, I underlined passages that stuck out—there are a lot of one-liners—and realized that even if Godin’s advice is watered down to appeal to a wide range of industries, it’s particularly applicable to marketing and communications. (I work in marketing.)
“As customers, we care about ourselves, about how we feel, about whether a product or service or play or interaction changed us for the better.”

At heart, Linchpin is about turning your work (whatever it is) into art. It’s a confusing message at first, since “art” brings up images of paintings or music or whatever. Godin’s premise, though, is that art is just an easy way of saying that work should be more relationship-driven and enriching. Instead of a purely transactional moment, “art” elevates a business-prospect relationship to one that’s more trusting and mutually beneficial.
“Consumers are not loyal to cheap commodities. They crave the unique, the remarkable, and the human.”

I enjoyed Godin’s razor-sharp focus on the perceived connection between prospects and organizations, and how content marketing is an essential building block to changing that culture for the better. His points on shipping—getting the product out the door on time no matter what—were clear and actionable and important to any company, no matter what they’re selling.

drasticjo's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

There were some really inspiring nuggets in this book, and I finished it feeling energized overall. However there were a few moments that soured me a bit. Godin seems not to really have any experiential awareness of being poor, and occasionally tosses off derisive statements suggesting it's a result of poor choices. At one point he suggests that anyone whose excuse is not having enough money to take a risk should simply live below their means, because the difference is all profit (as if poor people just haven't thought of this method). He also briefly refers to introversion as a flaw and suggests looking to more extraverted friends to see how to overcome it, which indicates he has made the common error of mistaking introversion for shyness/standoffishness and extraversion for having people skills. On the whole, though, if you have a good filter for privilege, there are definitely things worth learning in this book.

shel_lov's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Really good book that will get you thinking about how you do your work.

rachelwiththelonglegs's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This book had quite a few eye-opening thoughts regarding the entry-level workplace rut so many of us get trapped in. If you are mind-boggled by the current workplace culture that expects you to do as your told but punishes you at the same time for it, this book will deliver some much-needed insight. I will admit I needed to put it down out of frustration a few times at the beginning because it can be brutally honest in a non-inspirational manner. But it's valuable advice for those who choose the non-entrepreneurial career path as well! It's a quick read, and I admire its flow. I've already read it twice in two years and will likely read it once a year as a refresher to make sure I'm not slipping into the status quo of being a mere cog, but an inspirational linchpin instead. What I really enjoyed about Seth's self-help style is that he emphasizes how any job no matter how small, one can apply these skills to and become irreplaceable and that climbing the corporate latter quickly isn't the only measure of a person's professional success.

lindsayan's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

If you are a person who wants to read this, it might be a good book for you. If you are a person who did not choose this book, and wouldn't ordinarily, probably not for you!!

No matter who you are, it would take a lot less time to absorb these ideas if they were written as they should've been, in a teeny blog post, rather than a rambling and repetitive 230 pages.

lapistella's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This book explores ideas about how to be indispensable in a commodity based marketplace. Godin says, “You must become indispensable to thrive in the new economy. The best ways to do that are to be remarkable, insightful, an artist, someone bearing gifts. To lead. The worst way is to conform and become a cog in a giant system.”

He proposes that it’s no longer enough to just be able to do your job as prescribed, the workforce as defined by the industrial revolution has peeked. The white-collar work-a-day job is being phased out because of globalization and efficiencies in technology. And experimental work solutions, like the Amazon Turk, are a glimpse at a future of a componentized base-skill labor pool.

Godin offers seven abilities to aid in making yourself indispensible in the face of these changes. I won’t cover them all, but I feel strongly that I can implement some of them in my current role:
- Provide a unique interface between members of the organization.
- Manage a situation or organization of great complexity
- Inspire staff
- Offer deep domain knowledge

By the time I finished this book, I was fired up and even more excited about my new role at IBM. I love my job, and feel empowered to exert emotional labor and produce interactions that people care deeply about—to be a linchpin.

Godin also says, “You can’t always do what you love, but you can always love what you do.,” which reminds me a little bit of that Joplin song, love the one your with. I recommend this book for anyone looking for a new perspective on their own labor of love.

4ndre's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

O livro é bom mas a tradução deixa a desejar por ser demasiado literal.

botanicus's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative inspiring medium-paced

4.25

bloodravenlib's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Gets three stars because "I liked it," but I did not "really like it." When I started it, I thought much of the content would be statements of the obvious. And there are quite a few of those in this book. But Godin also provides some things to think about, including a thing or two that librarians can learn. I did find myself taking notes from the book now and then, and I will likely post some of those in my blog later. At the moment, I just wanted to get a quick review in so I can mark the book as "read" and move on.

The theme of being an artist is pretty prominent in the book. This does not mean painters, sculptors, etc. per se. Rather, it refers to those folks "with a genius for finding a new answer, a new connection, or a new way of getting things done" (8). These folks are the linchpins of organizations, and while Godin says that they are (or should be) valued and thus command a better salary, so on. Yet the reality is that this is not always the case. Just look at the current economy, not to mention the way many companies mistreat workers to see the evidence contrary to Godin's idealism. I think that is a bit of a problem with the book; the guy is just too idealistic at times. For instance, he often talks about pushing your luck and breaking the rules. If you can afford to do so like him because you are pretty much self-employed, all good and dandy. Try doing that in a restrictive work environment, and you will be given a pink slip. Job loss these days is not a light matter, and no, getting fired does not always mean "it was fate" and something better will come along. As I said, the guy makes some good points, but much of the book is pie-in-the-sky.

Having made the point about much of the book being a bit too optimistic, as I mentioned, the book does make some good points. I would recommend scanning it, finding the good stuff, and skipping the rest. He does have some inspirational stuff for people to try out that is worth considering at least. I know I got some good ideas. So, skim this one. Besides, he can get a bit repetitive, so again, skimming may be best.