Scan barcode
greta322's review against another edition
4.0
A children book I enjoyed as an adult. It gave me comfort during a few sleepless nights and made me crave for coffee, rolls, and cakes.
onceinabluemoon88's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.25
katypicken's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
I love the Chalet School, particularly in its early days, and this will always be one of my favourites. Eustacia is a little prig, though you know from the first that the School will reform her sooner or later. Interesting to read an unabridged version for the first time, and to notice things I'd never seen before. (Though this did include a totally unnecessary use of a racial slur which I think should have been excised. It might have been in common usage in 1930 when the book was first published, but I personally don't think a modern reprint should include it.)
Content Warnings
Moderate: Death of parent
Minor: Racial slurs
celiaedf12's review
4.0
Book 6 of the Chalet School series, and we meet Eustacia, probably the worst student ever (so far, at least). To give you a sample, the first sentence of this book - "There is no disguising the fact that Eustacia Benson was the most arrant little prig that ever existed." (Which is an awesome insult, by the way - I have been waiting for the opportunity to call someone an arrant little prig.)
(Also, I love that the synopsis on the book page makes it sound like Eustacia is plotting to firebomb the Chalet in revenge.)
Anyway, Eustacia is a snob who tells on the other girls (sneaking is very frowned upon) and generally prances around being a twit (this is the fault of her "elderly" parents who have raised her in an improperly adult manner). She and Jo really get on each other's nerves (which lets you know that we're supposed to particularly hate Eustacia). Eventually the entire school, including the mistresses, hate Eustacia, until (as usual) a dreadful accident occurs. Honestly, so many dreadful accidents occur at the Chalet School it seems a rather dangerous place (and it is only book 6). Anyway, the dreadful accident "peels off the layers of priggishness" and Stacie emerges - a far nicer girl. People basically say to her, "Wow, Eustacia was a bitch, but you're quite nice Stacie," and Stacie nods happily in agreement. Personality change to a proper Chalet school girl completed, complete with a new name. Another reviewer said this was really creepy, and I agree - I prefer it when the naughty girls just get a bit less naughty.
At one point Jo gets a talking to about her general influence with people - how everyone pretty much automatically loves and admires her and how this gives her a greater responsibility - I actually liked how Jo's heroine nature was acknowledged in this way.
(Also, I love that the synopsis on the book page makes it sound like Eustacia is plotting to firebomb the Chalet in revenge.)
Anyway, Eustacia is a snob who tells on the other girls (sneaking is very frowned upon) and generally prances around being a twit (this is the fault of her "elderly" parents who have raised her in an improperly adult manner). She and Jo really get on each other's nerves (which lets you know that we're supposed to particularly hate Eustacia). Eventually the entire school, including the mistresses, hate Eustacia, until (as usual) a dreadful accident occurs. Honestly, so many dreadful accidents occur at the Chalet School it seems a rather dangerous place (and it is only book 6). Anyway, the dreadful accident "peels off the layers of priggishness" and Stacie emerges - a far nicer girl. People basically say to her, "Wow, Eustacia was a bitch, but you're quite nice Stacie," and Stacie nods happily in agreement. Personality change to a proper Chalet school girl completed, complete with a new name. Another reviewer said this was really creepy, and I agree - I prefer it when the naughty girls just get a bit less naughty.
At one point Jo gets a talking to about her general influence with people - how everyone pretty much automatically loves and admires her and how this gives her a greater responsibility - I actually liked how Jo's heroine nature was acknowledged in this way.
More...