3.01k reviews for:

The Burning Girls

C.J. Tudor

3.91 AVERAGE


A vicar walks into a small country town ... and there is no punchline. Scary and suspenseful, the thrill of this book builds while it weaves in several characters who do leave you guessing. And Rev Jack Brooks - cigarette smoking, swearer and rough around the edges - packs a punch with her daughter, Flo. They both are a little left of centre, entering a hamlet - Chapel Croft - that is further left field and odd. We learn that Jack's life has not been steady and she is moving away from something. Throw in a 500 martyr execution site for eight religious martyrs where memorials of little stick effigies called ‘burning girls’ are left in strategic places, potential ghost sightings, ghostly apparitions, an odd townfolk and even stranger children and young people.

And what about those teenage girls - why did they leave and did they leave of their own accord? Is there someone more sinister or something more sinister in Chapel Croft? Sounds like a lot to get your head around, and it is. There are a lot of wrong turns and misconceptions, and this author's strength is in taking down the wrong path. It is all worth it. I wish they weren't wrapped up so fast and so neatly, which was the only predictability you could expect in a book of suspense. A good choice for a sunny afternoon read.
dark mysterious medium-paced

Hi and welcome to my review of The Burning Girls! I requested the ARC from NetGalley, sure I’d never be approved, but hey, it’s C.J. Tudor, one must try against all odds. And apparently bookish miracles do happen and here we are!

First of all I must tell you that I have learnt not to wear socks when reading a C.J. Tudor, as she blows them clean off every single time. High expectations? Me?! Of course not, don’t know what you’re talking about! In any case, it doesn’t matter, since The Burning Girls was every bit as amazing as I knew it would be!

By the time I’d reached the end of the shocking, gasp-inducing and highly intriguing prologue, I’d already fallen for The Burning Girls hook, line and sinker. No, actually even before that, with the Wikipedia entry explaining that burning girls are twig dolls to set alight to commemorate the Sussex Martyrs, two of whom were young girls, who were burnt at the stake during Queen Mary’s purge of Protestants. Just an itty-bitty text but it set my spine tingling with anticipation, that feeling you get when you know you’re in for a bookish treat.

The Burning Girls kicks off with Reverend Jack Brooks, and Flo, Jack’s daughter, forced to relocate to the small Sussex village of Chapel Croft, which is currently without a priest, since the last one killed himself. Minutes after their arrival, they meet a blood-soaked girl in the garden, and later that evening, Jack finds an exorcism kit, including a rather unorthodox set of knives. Something is clearly a little off in Chapel Croft.

And then Jack is told that the twig dolls they’ve been finding everywhere aren’t meant for commemoration, but rather to ward off the vengeful spirits of the girls who took refuge in the chapel, but were betrayed and caught, tortured and killed. Which would be fairly easy to dismiss if it wasn’t for Flo who is 100% sure she has actually seen the spirit of one of the girls.

The death of two girls hundreds of years ago, the disappearance of two girls thirty years ago, the apparent suicide of a man of the cloth, the arrival of a new vicar, chequered pasts, ghost stories. Once again, C.J. Tudor has struck the right balance between thriller and horror, creating a story that will appeal to fans of both genres. A mystery, a thriller with an occult thread woven into the story, it works like a charm on me, and it’s what C.J. Tudor does like a queen!

The village of Chapel Croft and its residents emit a perfect Twin Peaks vibe. I just love that kind of creepy small town setting with its folklore and its one family that seems to have a finger in every pie and its oddballs, with everything and everyone, even the most benign, coming across as suspicious. Except of course that one person I trusted blindly who turned out to be the least trustworthy of them all, I’m the worst judge of character!

I loved Jack and Flo as main characters. Modern opinions, firmly rooted in everyday life, genuinely in it for helping people, delightfully sarcastic and not opposed to occasional swearing, Jack is a brilliant priest. Although, like many other Chapel Croft residents, not quite without secrets…

I remember saying that The Other People would be a tough act to follow but The Burning Girls pulls it off. It sucked me in, chewed me up and spat me out a dazed mess, and I mean that in the best possible way! Nothing what it seems, The Burning Girls is a twisty and twisted story that kept me captivated and intrigued throughout and one I’d highly recommend!

Força bé en un principi: les protagonistes, els misteris, la història, el lloc… fins que arriba el moment de resoldre temes i res és creïble ni té sentit, i és increïblement molt i molt trampós. M’ha decebut moltíssim.

Muy pero muy entretenido y atrapante, me gustó que los capítulos sean cortos. Hace que la historia avance de una manera excelente hacia un final que es impecable, de los mejores libros de suspenso/thriller que leí en mucho tiempo.

A simple little mystery thriller. Well written but felt a little messy at times. I am not someone who typically gets caught up on realism as someone who reads mostly horror but when the author is going for something a bit more realistic I do expect the dialogue to not feel quite so odd and noir-esque. Specifically dialogue between the mother and the daughter. Many of the characters also behaved in a way that made absolutely no sense to the characters or the setting.

The Burning Girls was unbelievably good. Not as shocking as The Chalk Man, but I've started to figure out the way Tudor thinks so I was more prepared for the twists. Also, nothing is ever going to beat a head in a box for shock factor. CW for child abuse and evil kids, though.

Reverend Jack Brooks and her teenage daughter Flo are forced to flee a scandal in the city and take refuge in a small town. The small town is known for two things: the burning deaths of 8-ish martyrs half a millenium ago, and the stick dolls the town burns in effigy every year. Of course everyone in town has a big terrible secret, and Jack and Flo get caught up in figuring them out. Well, Flo gets caught up in kissing with tongues and getting injured a lot, and Jack gets caught up in the mysteries.

My only complaint is that I no longer know how to trust a narrator, so I always suspect they have secrets. Can somebody write me a book where everyone is who they say they are so I can be shocked by THAT, please?

What a wild ride. I was so invested in the story. Corrupt small town, murders and coverups, exsurrsism, satanic sacrifice. This book was so good. I didn't see the ending coming. Multiple POV which sometimes was hard to follow but I Really really liked it.

After a tragedy in Nottingham, Jack is sent to be victor of a small town but this is not going to be a simple post. First, what happened to the old victor and does it have something to do with the two girls who disappeared decades ago. When Jack's daughter's safety starts to come into question she starts digging deeper into this town and their secrets, but hers might be the biggest of all. While all of this is going on is someone from her past hunting her and are her and Flo safe where they are.

This is one of those books that drag you in and keep you reading til the end. This story is full of so many secrets that it keeps you guessing. I definitely recommend.

Good book, but was hoping for something more supernatural gothic horror. This turned out to be more of a suspense thriller.