1.31k reviews for:

Before We Came

Sloane St. James

3.72 AVERAGE


3.5⭐️

DNF at legit chapter 3. It’s just written so poorly already I know I won’t enjoy. Makes no sense

Notes:
OK, but to be realistic, there is no photo where you could clearly see BOTH a birthmark on your thigh and the color of your eyes at the same time


OK, can the author write that this chapter is in the past? I literally thought there was another little girl name to birdy, but then Lonan randomly says I’m 8?

I’m sure this will be foreshadowed: “You can’t live here, where would you go to the bathroom?” I grunt as I jump up and throw the rope over the beam.
“I’ll have my husband build a bathroom, right”—she crosses the floor and spins around, pointing at an imaginary spot she deems acceptable—“here.”

Also young birdy foreshadow: “I don’t know who he is . . . but when I meet him someday, he’s going to be the most perfect man in the whole wide world,” she says with her arms out wide. “He’s going to say nice things to me and build lots of cool stuff for the fort, like a bathroom, a skylight so we can watch the stars, and a garden outside so we can grow vegetables. But only the good vegetables, not the gross ones.”

“I can build things. I built a birdhouse with your dad, remember? It’s just like that, only bigger.”
“Yeah, you’re right.” She grins. “Okay. You can be my husband.”
“Just like that? Cool.”

Childhood love: “Yeah, Bridg. I like-like you.” She looks at me with those gray eyes of hers, and I’m a goner.
“Me too. I mean, I like-like you too.”

They were each others first kiss

I’m confused so was that all a dream or him dreaming a memory?
dark emotional mysterious sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No

braulia_bma's review

3.75
challenging emotional funny hopeful inspiring reflective sad tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
mcduffiek's profile picture

mcduffiek's review

4.0
emotional funny hopeful lighthearted fast-paced

Somewhere between a 2.5-3. I liked it, not loved it most of the way. It was interesting and had a different feel but wasn’t enough. The premise had me really excited and I liked the trope list. I hated the last 22%, frustrated with the ending. Starting, it felt unique and had a mystery/suspense aspect… but like nothing really came of it. And the back and forth between pretending like nothing happened to causing problems. It just felt unbelievable and then I hit the point and it just crumbled for me.

Loved it. It was actually quite entertaining. The chemistry and the meet cute. This actually was an unexpected find, the author dis captivate me from the first chapters…but I felt like there could have been more development in the main plot. Besides that and the fact that they had their HEA… solid 4/5

hexgirls13's review

3.0

This was okay. I got bored at about 60% and skimmed the rest.

The overall plot had potential but the follow through was not there. The main characters were basic without anything really to help you empathize with them. Considering the MFCs background this is pretty difficult to do. The spice was there, a lot of praise, but that's the only thing the book did right.

DNF 30% the writing is so boring, like it reads like a to do list; today I woke up. And did this. And felt like this. Ugh, even one of the most crazy plot points was made so trivial and dumb. Also who tf is named LONAN?????