Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.38 AVERAGE
4.38 AVERAGE
adventurous
emotional
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This is book two in the series. The magic system and the whole world of demons and the Knights of the Round Table’s descendants is incredibly creative. Add on the root magic and ancestral powers of the once enslaved and you have a fantastic story of strength and resilience.
adventurous
dark
emotional
funny
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
adventurous
dark
emotional
funny
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
To quote Emma, “If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it more.”
This book is a gut punch. I can’t read after this. I can’t think of anything that isn’t this. It romanced too hard. It adventured too bravely. It humored too funnily. It was perfect.
The tension of the plot is sickening in the best way. I was gnawing for more and completely binged the last 300 pages of the book. Tracy Deonn knows how to kidnap me into a story. It isn’t voluntary, I am literally stolen away from the world like Rapunzel in the night. I have an addiction. And being on the run is always a captivating plot because the story has to move as fast as the characters. It is just a masterclass in action, drama, romance, history, and trauma. Unbelievably deep and complex while being easily digestible and comprehendible.
The TENSION (all caps) between Sel and Bree is what killed me though. It’s plaguing my every waking thought, even my sleeping thoughts. I am so deep in the ship, I’m the Titanic. I love Nick and Bree, I do. I really love the whole triangle. But Sel would burn the world for her, and his love is something that chemically altered me. He is so intoxicating, alluring, yet transparent. His compliments are a unique sensory experience because suddenly I’m in a sauna and not my air-conditioned room. I love Sel. He has bewitched me, mind and soul, or whatever they say. And the ending has genuinely not left my mind since reading it. I am distraught, but cannot allow myself to read the next booksince he is hardly in it. I can’t bear it right now. I need him to be okay so I need Tracy to really get cracking because I am SICK!
This book is a masterpiece. I can’t actually say anything thoughtful about it right now because I am just in complete awe of it. There is no critique in my brain, I am rose-tinted, in love.
Read this book if you like good books and have read the first book. That’s all I’ve got to say.
This book is a gut punch. I can’t read after this. I can’t think of anything that isn’t this. It romanced too hard. It adventured too bravely. It humored too funnily. It was perfect.
The tension of the plot is sickening in the best way. I was gnawing for more and completely binged the last 300 pages of the book. Tracy Deonn knows how to kidnap me into a story. It isn’t voluntary, I am literally stolen away from the world like Rapunzel in the night. I have an addiction. And being on the run is always a captivating plot because the story has to move as fast as the characters. It is just a masterclass in action, drama, romance, history, and trauma. Unbelievably deep and complex while being easily digestible and comprehendible.
The TENSION (all caps) between Sel and Bree is what killed me though. It’s plaguing my every waking thought, even my sleeping thoughts. I am so deep in the ship, I’m the Titanic. I love Nick and Bree, I do. I really love the whole triangle. But Sel would burn the world for her, and his love is something that chemically altered me. He is so intoxicating, alluring, yet transparent. His compliments are a unique sensory experience because suddenly I’m in a sauna and not my air-conditioned room. I love Sel. He has bewitched me, mind and soul, or whatever they say. And the ending has genuinely not left my mind since reading it. I am distraught, but cannot allow myself to read the next book
This book is a masterpiece. I can’t actually say anything thoughtful about it right now because I am just in complete awe of it. There is no critique in my brain, I am rose-tinted, in love.
Read this book if you like good books and have read the first book. That’s all I’ve got to say.
adventurous
emotional
funny
mysterious
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
A little slow to start. Deonn had some great false starts where I thought the book would go one way and then you ended up in a completely different place. Really fun book, wasn’t expecting the end, can’t wait for the next two!
adventurous
tense
4/5 ⭐️
this was so slow at some points, especially the middle, but when it picked up IT PICKED UP
this was so slow at some points, especially the middle, but when it picked up IT PICKED UP
Bad first:
This series is in the unfortunate position of having very high expectations from me because it is, in fact, very good, so this time around I came in knowing it would be stellar and was not swept off my feet when it was. That is my fault tbh.
I have now read two books published in 2022 thathave a *best to ever do it but doesn’t know her power* girly borrows too much power from the folklorian king that lives inside her and he sneakily possesses her body right after she finally has her romantic heart-to-heart with her dark haired, moody love interest (who has a name with a y in it) to the heartbreak of all and she is relegated to spend some time in his hibernation dream world where she drowns for a bit in the local water source, meets said king’s loved ones, wreaks havoc, and is called back violently . This would have been SUCH a strong point in the book for me if I hadn’t read One Dark Window first. I am honestly kind of salty that I had that reading experience because I’d already felt the frustration, anxiety, and curiosity about my main girl being betrayed and possessed by her king .
I am often one to judge characters- especially teens- for emotional outbursts or bad communication. Personal flaw, I know. I am not working on it. But of course since this is YA that happened in the plot and it will always grate on me a little bit.
The sequel had a less contained story and plot than the first book which had clear goals, conflicts, and twists. This one was a bit more amorphous so some twists were less twisty because I had a hard time pinning down where it was “supposed” to go anyway.
Nick is basic but Sel is cliched. I like and dislike both in equal measure.
Now. Briana Matthews. Why on earth did you scorch the ancestral plane to free yourself from outside control just to sell yourself to the literal Devil? You are smart and now know that the Hunter will only ever protect you so you would 1000% be able to train and fuck around with your power knowing he would protect you from death and harm. And you don’t need to literally burn bridges with your ancestors and their strength- Vera especially- to get away from them when you can literally just stop calling. Maybe you just want Sel to heal….? But girly this is the end of the world we’re talking about. That is an unbalanced trade .
_____________________
Now the good:
This series is so unique and exceptional in so many ways. The world itself started out very strong with how the Order and Legendborn would intersect with real world structures which is something that a lot of stories absolutely fail to do. I know that sometimes fantasy is meant to just be fantasy, but it is so incredible to be in a universe that expertly grounds the fantasy in real world events, structures, and hopes. I know a lot of people don’t like “low fantasy” but this series excels BECAUSE it is folklore and history in one. Love it.
I had so much fun learning about the magic outside of the Order. So much of this book is influenced by revelations about the traditionalist propaganda of the Order so it was great to explore the magic that existed outside of it. It makes a lot of sense that while Bree is exceptional, there’s gonna be a lot more magic like hers and new to her considering there were two Rootcrafters in her immediate radius in book one . I was ready for lore expansion (thank you for the tip, Monika), so I was able to enjoy the info dumps when they came along.
I am endlessly impressed by Tracy Deonn’s ability to introduce and characterize so many individuals. There are a lot of names at all times, but even if I can’t remember who is what name, I can know their vibe and feel the distinctions between the characters. I’m usually so fatigued in books and series that add in new people all the time because it can feel like a a) crutch, b) nuisance, and/or c) diversity play. None of these characters feel like that. It’s incredible. My favorites introduced in this book were Valec and Samira .
William is the best. I love him. For some reason Nick feels like a blank “white boy of the month” but Will feels so fleshed out and sincere. I love him.
IM SO GLADBREE IS A DRAGON !!!!I GUESS IT AND ITS ONLY AETHER BUT FUCK YES!!!
As much as I hate reading about teenagers kissing (I just age them up whenever it happens) the tension is written well. I respect it.
I. Loved. Volition . It makes sense with the magic, the story, the history, and god it is cathartic and beautiful.
The“Erebus is the Shadow King” reveal was delightful. His protective but cruel nature towards Bree was always interesting and complex and it just makes so much sense. I love a reveal like that.
I really liked the“actually nothing is old and the Order is modern because the Regents are a controlling pair of shitbags” angle. Love.
Glad we’re finally meetingMorgaines after hearing about them in both books.
I think this book was an even more compelling story about grief than the first book. It was much more complex and extended to multiple forms of grief within universe.
I love a fast-paced book. I put this book off for so long because it is massive with tiny font and it moved pretty quickly even though I was in a major reading slump.
I loved it when Max died .
_____________________
The neutral
I wish Alice had died instead of going comatose . You know it won’t happen because the narrative is building up her Mesmer immunity and partial sensitivity to aether but it just doesn’t hit as hard. Granted I like Alice so ultimately I won’t complain.
This book wouldn’t lose anything by aging up the cast to college age. I figure the author wanted to specifically give young black girls a YA book for them, but unlike w the hunger games where their young age is important to the plot I think this book could gain even more maturity and nuance with an older cast.
There are some slight contradictions in the book, specifically about consent and judgment. None are clear or bad enough to ruin the narrative but it’s kinda…. Annoying.
There is no need. No need. To write in a Scottish accent into the physical dialogue. I can imagine it just fine without “youse” “ma da” and all the other stuff. Slang is one thing but bro that got me going lmao
I hate reading a series that isn’t out yet. I’m tryna do one book per year so I can read the final book when it drops but it is difficult to retain information between reads for such a dense world.
I wish this existed when I was younger. It would’ve made me woke so much sooner.
This series is in the unfortunate position of having very high expectations from me because it is, in fact, very good, so this time around I came in knowing it would be stellar and was not swept off my feet when it was. That is my fault tbh.
I have now read two books published in 2022 that
I am often one to judge characters- especially teens- for emotional outbursts or bad communication. Personal flaw, I know. I am not working on it. But of course since this is YA that happened in the plot and it will always grate on me a little bit.
The sequel had a less contained story and plot than the first book which had clear goals, conflicts, and twists. This one was a bit more amorphous so some twists were less twisty because I had a hard time pinning down where it was “supposed” to go anyway.
Nick is basic but Sel is cliched. I like and dislike both in equal measure.
Now. Briana Matthews.
_____________________
Now the good:
This series is so unique and exceptional in so many ways. The world itself started out very strong with how the Order and Legendborn would intersect with real world structures which is something that a lot of stories absolutely fail to do. I know that sometimes fantasy is meant to just be fantasy, but it is so incredible to be in a universe that expertly grounds the fantasy in real world events, structures, and hopes. I know a lot of people don’t like “low fantasy” but this series excels BECAUSE it is folklore and history in one. Love it.
I had so much fun learning about the magic outside of the Order. So much of this book is influenced by revelations about the
I am endlessly impressed by Tracy Deonn’s ability to introduce and characterize so many individuals. There are a lot of names at all times, but even if I can’t remember who is what name, I can know their vibe and feel the distinctions between the characters. I’m usually so fatigued in books and series that add in new people all the time because it can feel like a a) crutch, b) nuisance, and/or c) diversity play. None of these characters feel like that. It’s incredible. My favorites introduced in this book were
William is the best. I love him. For some reason Nick feels like a blank “white boy of the month” but Will feels so fleshed out and sincere. I love him.
IM SO GLAD
As much as I hate reading about teenagers kissing (I just age them up whenever it happens) the tension is written well. I respect it.
I. Loved.
The
I really liked the
Glad we’re finally meeting
I think this book was an even more compelling story about grief than the first book. It was much more complex and extended to multiple forms of grief within universe.
I love a fast-paced book. I put this book off for so long because it is massive with tiny font and it moved pretty quickly even though I was in a major reading slump.
I loved it when
_____________________
The neutral
I wish
This book wouldn’t lose anything by aging up the cast to college age. I figure the author wanted to specifically give young black girls a YA book for them, but unlike w the hunger games where their young age is important to the plot I think this book could gain even more maturity and nuance with an older cast.
There are some slight contradictions in the book, specifically about consent and judgment. None are clear or bad enough to ruin the narrative but it’s kinda…. Annoying.
There is no need. No need. To write in a Scottish accent into the physical dialogue. I can imagine it just fine without “youse” “ma da” and all the other stuff. Slang is one thing but bro that got me going lmao
I hate reading a series that isn’t out yet. I’m tryna do one book per year so I can read the final book when it drops but it is difficult to retain information between reads for such a dense world.
I wish this existed when I was younger. It would’ve made me woke so much sooner.
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
fast-paced