Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.42 AVERAGE
3.42 AVERAGE
From my blog Auntie Spinelli Reads
Hmm. I had a lot of mixed feelings about this one, so let me start with the bad (as per usual for me).
The beginning dragged. A lot. There was waaaay too much teen angst and relationship drama for my tastes (I KNOW, it's young adult. I know. But this was juvenile even for YA), which brought the story down quite a bit - for me, at least. It read too much like a typical and cliche horror movie: A bunch of teens take a trip together; it even had the typical roles, including the slut, the asshole, the bitch, the black guy, and the shy one.
I couldn't stand two of the main characters, which is another thing that ruined my enjoyment of the book. Minnie was the major one for me. It's rather sad when you read a book and actually hope for a character to die. She was a skank and a total bitch, not to mention an extremely horrendous friend. She was supposed to be bipolar, which I suppose would excuse her from some of it...but I didn't feel as if it was portrayed very well.
She complained adamantly about Meg going off to college and guilt tripped her for 'leaving her behind'....sorry but shouldn't you want your friend to be happy and do what she wants to do? And be successful in life? She claimed to be 'in love' with TJ, yet as soon as she got on the island and laid eyes on the first hottie in sight (that she doesn't even know), she disappeared with him to do unspeakable things. Then got jealous because Meg was spending time with TJ. WTF? She went all psycho when she thought the two were going to the Homecoming dance together...obviously she's not that great of a friend if she can't tell that Meg had feelings for TJ.
Which brings me to Meg. While Minnie was bitchy about Meg and TJ, some of the blame was on Meg as well. She was a spineless, vapid doormat of a character and I wanted to punch her in the face. She wouldn't speak up about ANYTHING, and I like a lead that can stand up for what she believes in. She let Minnie walk all over her, and instead of telling her 'best friend' that she had feelings for the same guy, she lied about it. Repeatedly. Not that she should have been going after her best friend's 'love' in the first place. She also lied to TJ over and over again. It was just plain ridiculous and cowardly and she just dug the hole deeper for herself. She had nasty thoughts going through her head, yet would smile in the person's face and kiss their ass. Talk about two-faced. Not to mention she was thinking about boys and kissing when someone DIED. It was all just a bit too high school for me.
Meg felt dizzy. Had he just kissed her? Had T.J. Fletcher just kissed her?
Several thoughts filled her head simultaneously.
Number one - she was quite probably going to pass out from joy.
Number two - had he meant to kiss her? Had it been a mistake? No, that was silly. How could it possibly have been a mistake unless he was trying to lick something off her face?
Number three - was there any way Minnie might have seen them?
Lick something off her face? Really? Hey, you ah, got a little leftover dinner on your face. It's okay, I got ya. I'll just LICK IT OFF. BECAUSE THAT'S TOTALLY NORMAL.
And how the hell do you 'accidentally' kiss someone? Oops, sorry. I accidentally tripped into your face and kissed you. That happens to me all the time.
Meg's face, meet Geo's fist. Now share a nice moment together.
Another complaint? Overuse of the words 'weird,' 'off,' and 'wrong.' Us poor wittle readers don't need anybody holding our wittle hands. I think we can tell for ourselves that things were weird without it being pointed out constantly.
Other than all that - I know it seems like a lot - I did rather enjoy the last half. Aside from the irritating and immature characters and drama, the book was actually pretty good. It was creepy and full of suspense, and the background for the killings was great. I liked how the journal entries were connected to the murders and the way they happened; it was quite brilliant. And I didn't figure out who the killer was, so kudos for that. Although I did figure out that the obvious suspect was a farce.
Without the horror movie fluff (read: drama and angst), this probably would have been a 4 or 4.5 for me. The suspense really hooked me!
ASSESSMENT
Plot: 4.5/5
Writing style: 3/5
Originality: 3/5
Characters: 2/5
Pace: 3.5/5
Cover: 4/5
Hmm. I had a lot of mixed feelings about this one, so let me start with the bad (as per usual for me).
The beginning dragged. A lot. There was waaaay too much teen angst and relationship drama for my tastes (I KNOW, it's young adult. I know. But this was juvenile even for YA), which brought the story down quite a bit - for me, at least. It read too much like a typical and cliche horror movie: A bunch of teens take a trip together; it even had the typical roles, including the slut, the asshole, the bitch, the black guy, and the shy one.
I couldn't stand two of the main characters, which is another thing that ruined my enjoyment of the book. Minnie was the major one for me. It's rather sad when you read a book and actually hope for a character to die. She was a skank and a total bitch, not to mention an extremely horrendous friend. She was supposed to be bipolar, which I suppose would excuse her from some of it...but I didn't feel as if it was portrayed very well.
She complained adamantly about Meg going off to college and guilt tripped her for 'leaving her behind'....sorry but shouldn't you want your friend to be happy and do what she wants to do? And be successful in life? She claimed to be 'in love' with TJ, yet as soon as she got on the island and laid eyes on the first hottie in sight (that she doesn't even know), she disappeared with him to do unspeakable things. Then got jealous because Meg was spending time with TJ. WTF? She went all psycho when she thought the two were going to the Homecoming dance together...obviously she's not that great of a friend if she can't tell that Meg had feelings for TJ.
Which brings me to Meg. While Minnie was bitchy about Meg and TJ, some of the blame was on Meg as well. She was a spineless, vapid doormat of a character and I wanted to punch her in the face. She wouldn't speak up about ANYTHING, and I like a lead that can stand up for what she believes in. She let Minnie walk all over her, and instead of telling her 'best friend' that she had feelings for the same guy, she lied about it. Repeatedly. Not that she should have been going after her best friend's 'love' in the first place. She also lied to TJ over and over again. It was just plain ridiculous and cowardly and she just dug the hole deeper for herself. She had nasty thoughts going through her head, yet would smile in the person's face and kiss their ass. Talk about two-faced. Not to mention she was thinking about boys and kissing when someone DIED. It was all just a bit too high school for me.
Meg felt dizzy. Had he just kissed her? Had T.J. Fletcher just kissed her?
Several thoughts filled her head simultaneously.
Number one - she was quite probably going to pass out from joy.
Number two - had he meant to kiss her? Had it been a mistake? No, that was silly. How could it possibly have been a mistake unless he was trying to lick something off her face?
Number three - was there any way Minnie might have seen them?
Lick something off her face? Really? Hey, you ah, got a little leftover dinner on your face. It's okay, I got ya. I'll just LICK IT OFF. BECAUSE THAT'S TOTALLY NORMAL.
And how the hell do you 'accidentally' kiss someone? Oops, sorry. I accidentally tripped into your face and kissed you. That happens to me all the time.
Meg's face, meet Geo's fist. Now share a nice moment together.
Another complaint? Overuse of the words 'weird,' 'off,' and 'wrong.' Us poor wittle readers don't need anybody holding our wittle hands. I think we can tell for ourselves that things were weird without it being pointed out constantly.
Other than all that - I know it seems like a lot - I did rather enjoy the last half. Aside from the irritating and immature characters and drama, the book was actually pretty good. It was creepy and full of suspense, and the background for the killings was great. I liked how the journal entries were connected to the murders and the way they happened; it was quite brilliant. And I didn't figure out who the killer was, so kudos for that. Although I did figure out that the obvious suspect was a farce.
Without the horror movie fluff (read: drama and angst), this probably would have been a 4 or 4.5 for me. The suspense really hooked me!
ASSESSMENT
Plot: 4.5/5
Writing style: 3/5
Originality: 3/5
Characters: 2/5
Pace: 3.5/5
Cover: 4/5
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Not bad, very pretty little liars meets harpers island
Actually 2 1/2 stars.
I really liked this book. Until the end.
I figured out the killer early on, but that did not take away from my enjoyment. It was a fun cross between I Know What You Did Last Summer and And Then Were None.
I just wish it had gone with a more Christie-esque ending. It unfortunately finished with a nice, neat, happy ending all wrapped up on a bow. Blah. Too bad.
I really liked this book. Until the end.
I figured out the killer early on, but that did not take away from my enjoyment. It was a fun cross between I Know What You Did Last Summer and And Then Were None.
I just wish it had gone with a more Christie-esque ending. It unfortunately finished with a nice, neat, happy ending all wrapped up on a bow. Blah. Too bad.
adventurous
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Fun overall. Some of the dialogue felt a little forced in the beginning of the book like they were pretending to be teens but weren’t sure how teens spoke. I know crushes were important to me when I was a young teen but not to the extent of constantly worrying about how my crush was perceiving me if I was also actively trying to not get murdered.
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
This book was definitely entertaining I cruised through it. A YA thriller where 10 students go to a house party on an island and due to weather they become stranded and people start dying. I thought the lead up and the mystery itself was good. The mental health representation was not great. The ending, when we find out what’s happening I didn’t totally see coming, partly because it didn’t seem the most plausible.
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No