Scan barcode
yorha_'s review against another edition
Soft DNF, not in the mood but will come back
ammonoids's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
For a good majority of this book I was unclear about where it was going or what exactly the protagonist wanted. She was thrown about by bad luck and a biased society, her head literally torn open to stop her from feeling grief, and then brought along to testify in a trial that didnt happen until the very end of the book. I can only think of a few times she controlled her own fate. It all left me feeling very uninterested in what was otherwise a very intricate magic system and set of characters. Our main character was passive and uninterested, so I was too. I'm not sure if I'll continue this series.
blazeofredfiree's review against another edition
4.0
I enjoyed this more than I expected to! I wasn't entirely convinced by the first half, but the second was pretty great. This was a nice change from typical ya. The protagonist Raine was certainly different to most ya protagonists and I really enjoyed her pov and growth throughout. The magic was also pretty fun! I also liked that the romance subplot wasn't shoved in my face- it was relevant but realistic in that it wasn't just "they're both enamoured at first sight.
The action was also really fun- really vivid and exciting. The plot was pretty simply, but satisfying!
The action was also really fun- really vivid and exciting. The plot was pretty simply, but satisfying!
elsecallerreads's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
This was a really solid start to a fantasy series! I loved how complex the characters were and the magic system. I did have some issues with pacing (the middle is a bit boring if I'm being honest) and that kept it from being a 5 star but over a great read.
willrefuge's review against another edition
5.0
10 / 10 ✪
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com/2022/06/28/daughter-of-redwinter-by-ed-mcdonald-review/
—
Those who see the dead soon join them.
Seventeen year-old Raine knows what she wants out of life, and has it. A man that loves her, a life where she’s respected, a group she’s protected in so much that she almost feels loved. The only problem is that her new family is on the run and holed up in a decaying monastery—which has started widening the cracks in her perfect life.
Maybe her love isn’t so perfect. Braithe is great, but at twice her age he should know better. He yells and belittles and raises his hand to her far too often, to the point that Raine is starting to feel like nothing but a bedwarmer. Her perfect family is less than perfect as well. The sisters preach about the colors within, and their followers eat it up. But Raine isn’t a believer. In fact, she’s never felt like one of them less.
But her die is cast and her lot chosen. She’s with them to the death—especially since death is coming for them all.
In the form of a lost apprentice, hunted by her Draoihn brethren. One that Raine helps, and who repays her by trying to summon an ancient evil unto the world.
An evil Raine helps defeat, but only just. After which she is whisked off to Redwinter by the Draoihn pair, as a witness to the foiled end of the world plot. But after being spared certain death, Raine is now confronted by a probable and much worse end. For if they knew her secret—her ability to see and commune with the dead—these warrior mages would kill her in a much more spectacular and painful manner.
As she lingers in Redwinter, Raine finds more than she ever could’ve hoped, but far less than she might have dreamt of: a life, albeit not one she expected; friends, though they might turn on her if they ever found out her secret; power, though it’s temperamental and impossible to control; and a plot, one she’s got to get under control before it burns her new home down around her.
—
I began to have a life. It was not a life I had wanted, but it was the one I was living, and one cannot always swim against the tide.
—
Earlier this month I read a review from Rebecca over at Powder & Page, which proclaimed this as a potential book of the year candidate. Now, I thoroughly adored McDonald’s last series and was ecstatic to hear her praise. And even more excited, as the book did not disappoint.
—
Friendship is easy to claim and dangerous to test.
—
I thought I had this pegged as soon as we prevented the ancient evil from releasing itself on the world. I was wrong.
This was not a “teen discovers powers”, “teen goes to magic school”, “enter hijinx and tomfoolery and maybe the end of the world”, like I expected. Sure, it has many of those characteristics—so many that it really looks like it’s going to follow the same pattern. And then the plot takes a left turn. Even further on, when I thought we’d fallen back into the original pattern—it takes another abrupt turn. I’m not going to spoil either of these, but they’re as surprising as they are entertaining, and—better yet—they work really well. The twists may not be world-changing, but they do just enough to change the story while keeping the pace and flow intact.
Raine is an excellent character. She’s young and foolish. She’s clever and witty. She’s pessimistic but hopeful. She has darkness within her, but light as well. She’s… human. Well designed, well portrayed, well written. She’s by far the strongest character, though the others are well written as well. Often profoundly so. Ovitus was among one of my favorite characters just for his sheer complexity. He’s not a particularly… charming character, though he does have something about him that makes him appealing. He’s just so interesting—especially in how he interacts with the world, the other characters, Raine herself—that he’s a fascinating character to read. Raine was by far my favorite, though a few of the others grew on me over the story’s course.
What else do I really have to say about this? Well, not too much as it turns out. I could rave about how well everything is done or about how much I loved every bit of it, but sadly I don’t think this would be enough. The only thing I can really do is tell you to read it, and recommend it whole-heartedly.
TL;DR
Not much to say here, except that Daughter of Redwinter continues Ed McDonald’s strong course of written works. I won’t even bore you by recapping the details. Everything was strong, in my opinion. A great world, great characters, story, blah blah blah. This is (very, very likely) my book of 2022 thus far. Go read it.
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com/2022/06/28/daughter-of-redwinter-by-ed-mcdonald-review/
—
Those who see the dead soon join them.
Seventeen year-old Raine knows what she wants out of life, and has it. A man that loves her, a life where she’s respected, a group she’s protected in so much that she almost feels loved. The only problem is that her new family is on the run and holed up in a decaying monastery—which has started widening the cracks in her perfect life.
Maybe her love isn’t so perfect. Braithe is great, but at twice her age he should know better. He yells and belittles and raises his hand to her far too often, to the point that Raine is starting to feel like nothing but a bedwarmer. Her perfect family is less than perfect as well. The sisters preach about the colors within, and their followers eat it up. But Raine isn’t a believer. In fact, she’s never felt like one of them less.
But her die is cast and her lot chosen. She’s with them to the death—especially since death is coming for them all.
In the form of a lost apprentice, hunted by her Draoihn brethren. One that Raine helps, and who repays her by trying to summon an ancient evil unto the world.
An evil Raine helps defeat, but only just. After which she is whisked off to Redwinter by the Draoihn pair, as a witness to the foiled end of the world plot. But after being spared certain death, Raine is now confronted by a probable and much worse end. For if they knew her secret—her ability to see and commune with the dead—these warrior mages would kill her in a much more spectacular and painful manner.
As she lingers in Redwinter, Raine finds more than she ever could’ve hoped, but far less than she might have dreamt of: a life, albeit not one she expected; friends, though they might turn on her if they ever found out her secret; power, though it’s temperamental and impossible to control; and a plot, one she’s got to get under control before it burns her new home down around her.
—
I began to have a life. It was not a life I had wanted, but it was the one I was living, and one cannot always swim against the tide.
—
Earlier this month I read a review from Rebecca over at Powder & Page, which proclaimed this as a potential book of the year candidate. Now, I thoroughly adored McDonald’s last series and was ecstatic to hear her praise. And even more excited, as the book did not disappoint.
—
Friendship is easy to claim and dangerous to test.
—
I thought I had this pegged as soon as we prevented the ancient evil from releasing itself on the world. I was wrong.
This was not a “teen discovers powers”, “teen goes to magic school”, “enter hijinx and tomfoolery and maybe the end of the world”, like I expected. Sure, it has many of those characteristics—so many that it really looks like it’s going to follow the same pattern. And then the plot takes a left turn. Even further on, when I thought we’d fallen back into the original pattern—it takes another abrupt turn. I’m not going to spoil either of these, but they’re as surprising as they are entertaining, and—better yet—they work really well. The twists may not be world-changing, but they do just enough to change the story while keeping the pace and flow intact.
Raine is an excellent character. She’s young and foolish. She’s clever and witty. She’s pessimistic but hopeful. She has darkness within her, but light as well. She’s… human. Well designed, well portrayed, well written. She’s by far the strongest character, though the others are well written as well. Often profoundly so. Ovitus was among one of my favorite characters just for his sheer complexity. He’s not a particularly… charming character, though he does have something about him that makes him appealing. He’s just so interesting—especially in how he interacts with the world, the other characters, Raine herself—that he’s a fascinating character to read. Raine was by far my favorite, though a few of the others grew on me over the story’s course.
What else do I really have to say about this? Well, not too much as it turns out. I could rave about how well everything is done or about how much I loved every bit of it, but sadly I don’t think this would be enough. The only thing I can really do is tell you to read it, and recommend it whole-heartedly.
TL;DR
Not much to say here, except that Daughter of Redwinter continues Ed McDonald’s strong course of written works. I won’t even bore you by recapping the details. Everything was strong, in my opinion. A great world, great characters, story, blah blah blah. This is (very, very likely) my book of 2022 thus far. Go read it.
melmmh's review against another edition
3.0
I stumbled onto Daughter of Redwinter as a "kindle daily deal" and am I ever happy I snapped it up.
The opening sequence pulled me right into the story, and as I'm very much a mood reader - I love that kind of beginning.
I wasn't sure how much I "liked" the MC, Raine, but it wasn't relevant in terms of the story. Raine is seventeen years old and very much behaves in ways one would expect an adolescent to. It was refreshing to see a teenager portrayed as such.
The character development, back story filling and world building were all top notch. I was slightly disappointed that the story wrapped up so neatly at the end, but with a second book forthcoming - there's obviously more to look forward to.
I would like to see the relationship between the MC and a side character developed much more. Not even necessarily in a romantic sense (since there were several possibilities there) but the story seemed to waver around a possible "super ominous" intent - and then kind of petered out.
All in all, very happy I read this. It was fast enough to hold my attention but well written enough I wasn't plowing through it.
3.5 stars
The opening sequence pulled me right into the story, and as I'm very much a mood reader - I love that kind of beginning.
I wasn't sure how much I "liked" the MC, Raine, but it wasn't relevant in terms of the story. Raine is seventeen years old and very much behaves in ways one would expect an adolescent to. It was refreshing to see a teenager portrayed as such.
The character development, back story filling and world building were all top notch. I was slightly disappointed that the story wrapped up so neatly at the end, but with a second book forthcoming - there's obviously more to look forward to.
I would like to see the relationship between the MC and a side character developed much more. Not even necessarily in a romantic sense (since there were several possibilities there) but the story seemed to waver around a possible "super ominous" intent - and then kind of petered out.
All in all, very happy I read this. It was fast enough to hold my attention but well written enough I wasn't plowing through it.
3.5 stars
librarian_rachel's review against another edition
The main character was intermittently aware and not aware of what their character development should be. It got annoying!
agyrophobia's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
catherinenereader's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
funny
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
beansandfungi's review
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
A really strong fantasy novel, with some unique aspects to it. Raine isn't my favourite protagonist, she can be irritating at times, but I definitely enjoyed it on the whole!