4.35 AVERAGE

moosebreath's review

4.25
dark informative fast-paced
the_grimm_reader's profile picture

the_grimm_reader's review

5.0

Like many readers, I have a short list of books that have painted my worldview with a fine brush. Some have been so revelatory that, upon turning the final page, I could feel my perspective shift—tectonically. Few, however, have painted that perspective with as wide and wild a stroke as Nuclear War: A Scenario by Annie Jacobsen.

To start, a little personal context: as a young boy—well into my teenage years—I was absolutely terrified by the prospect of nuclear war. If you grew up in the 1980s, you may recall the made-for-TV film The Day After. Its special effects were modest, but the psychological fallout was devastating. That film carved itself into my imagination. I had recurring nightmares of nuclear holocaust, so vivid I once confided in my Sunday school teacher, hoping they could offer comfort. They tried.

Eventually, the terror dulled. Nuclear war became something more often seen in the realm of fiction, especially science fiction—like Sarah Connor’s vision in Terminator 2: Judgment Day. That helped me shelve the fear as a kind of childish worry, something overblown and exaggerated by fantasy.

But in the past decade, I’ve felt a familiar knocking at the gate of that fear. Why now? I think it’s age, greater access to information, and an eroding confidence in the volatile individuals who hold the nuclear codes. I’ve grown more willing to look into the darker corners of reality without the frosting of comfort. Enter Annie Jacobsen.

Nuclear War: A Scenario is, without hyperbole, the most terrifying book I have ever read.

Jacobsen is known for her meticulous research, and this book is no exception—thoroughly cited, expertly structured, and packed with firsthand accounts and hard data. What sets this one apart is the format: a minute-by-minute, hour-by-hour fictionalized scenario based on factual analysis, illustrating how one nuclear incident might unfold.

Notice I said “hour-by-hour.” Not days. Not weeks. Just one hour. That’s all it takes.

In that devastatingly brief window of time, we watch humans make impossible decisions. We watch plausible miscommunications snowball into global catastrophe. And the worst part? It all makes sense. It is terrifying because it’s not just believable—it’s probable.

There are no heroes here. No smarter, calmer heads prevailing. This is a Rube Goldberg machine of death: overlapping systems, sensors, programs, and chains of command, all meant to preserve peace while simultaneously holding the power to annihilate us. In Jacobsen’s scenario, those systems fail us. We fail ourselves.

Throughout the narrative, Jacobsen deftly weaves in chilling real-world history. There were moments I had to stop reading, stunned by revelations I had never heard before—revelations that explain exactly how close we’ve come to extinction, multiple times. Accepting this information means stepping out of the fog of delusion and facing a grossly underplayed existential reality. We are not protected. We are poised—on the razor’s edge of doom.

Not doom for some. Doom for all.

When I finished the book, the sky seemed bluer. Each breath felt heavier and sweeter. The sound of birds, sharper. The presence of my small family—achingly precious. Since reading Nuclear War: A Scenario, I’ve thought about it daily. Many times a day. It has stripped so many of my worries of their false importance.

We are living in an age of madmen—erratic figures with immense power, surrounded by flawed systems, holding the keys to irreversible destruction. They do not cherish life, not truly. They are beasts in suits, and they walk among us.

And yet, through my fear, Jacobsen’s work has left me with resolve: to pay attention, to care more deeply, to hold others—and myself—to higher standards. As a child, nuclear fire scorched through my nightmares. As an adult, this book ignites a fire in my awareness—a burning that won’t go out.

Annie Jacobsen’s Nuclear War: A Scenario wields a very wide brush, indeed.

elisec2503's review

4.25
dark informative

Literally the scariest thing I’ve ever read. Everyone must read it but be prepared to need to distract yourself immediately after. 
dark informative reflective tense medium-paced
dark informative sad medium-paced

gj377's review

5.0
dark informative tense fast-paced

Terrifying. Essential reading. So well-researched.
emotional informative medium-paced
lauripauri's profile picture

lauripauri's review


nominiert für den Goodreads Choice Award 2024
challenging dark informative sad tense fast-paced

A thriller type reportage of a nuclear war scenario. Spoiler alert - everyone dies. Terrifying in the sense that if one "mad king" presses a button, there is no escape for humanity. Comforting in the sense that we'll all be dead within the hour. (Footnote - the living will envy the dead.) Must read.