326 reviews for:

The Lost Year

Katherine Marsh

4.49 AVERAGE

kimmahkimmah's profile picture

kimmahkimmah's review

4.75
challenging dark emotional reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
informative inspiring reflective relaxing medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Yet another well-written YA book opening my eyes to a part of history I had little to no background on. If it hadn’t been for recently reading The Things We Cannot Say which had a similar plot twist to it, I probably wouldn’t have figured this one out from all the breadcrumbs the author left. Great read! And, as always, appreciated the non-fiction pages at the end

I read Katherine Marsh's book Nowhere Boy and loved it, so I was excited to learn of this new release in 2023. The Lost Year is a historical fiction book that addresses an event many people have little to no knowledge of - the Ukrainian famine of the early 1930s. Stories from this horrific time were largely hidden by the Soviet government and propaganda for years, only really surfacing in the last couple of decades.

Marsh's story is related through three narrators: the first two are girls - one living in the United States and the other in Ukraine - in the 1930s. They are cousins, but are not aware of one another at the beginning of the book. The third narrator is a boy named Matthew living in 2020 in the United States just after Covid has sent everyone into isolation. Matthew lives with his mother and his great-grandmother, who has come to live with them due to a fear that she won't survive in a retirement home in the midst of a global pandemic. As it turns out, Matthew's great-grandmother, Gigi, is one of the cousins, and much of the story is revealed as Gigi reluctantly shares what happened in the 1930s through letters, journals, and photographs.

Marsh's story is full of fascinating details about Ukraine soon after it came under the Soviet regime, characters who the reader will care about deeply, and some plot twists and turns that make this a suspenseful page-turner. It is also one more cautionary tale about how important it is to be aware of history so that it isn't repeated. Beautiful writing and a memorable story!


There have suddenly been so many stories taking place in Ukraine and my knowledge (and horror) of Stalin is growing. This novel goes back and forth from 2020 New Jersey during the early days of the pandemic to 1932 Ukraine during the Holodomor (death by hunger). Alternating chapters introduce Matthew, Mila and Helen and GG, Matthew's great-grandmother who seems to tie them all together...somehow. That mysterious thread keeps readers hooked. I initially listened to this novel but I am so glad that I finished it in print so I could see all the photos shared by the author in the Acknowledgements. How grateful we all should be to Katherine Marsh for giving us this story based on many members of her family.

Grades 6 and up.

Wow. What a beautifully written middle-grade novel. I loved how the stories came together at the end. The struggles and resilience of these characters were authentically portrayed making it an emotional read. Hands down a solid 5⭐️ read. This is one I will not forget.
informative reflective sad fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

This book has four main characters: Matthew, who is a modern kid living through the Covid lockdown, and three cousins, who are each living very different lives though all at the time of the Holodomor. On the one hand, I loved the way Matthew grows in his relationship with his great grandma as she reveals the story of her past. I also loved her story. On the other hand, I hated the Covid aspect. It seemed like the author was trying to correlate living through the bloody reign of Stalin with living through Covid lockdown and I find that utterly ridiculous. Then there's the irony of equating those who didn't believe there was a famine in Ukraine with those who thought the reaction to Covid was overblown or don't believe in global warming. This could have been an excellent book, but it was brought down by the author's handling of the pandemic.

CC: divorced parents, Covid lockdown, death of loved ones, death in childbirth, climate change, modern main character fights with and is very disrespectful to mom a lot/mom is portrayed as mean and unreasonable for most of the book (no real redemption there either) 

Wow, the timing of this book’s publication was fortuitous. Timely story that flips back and forth in time between lockdown COVID 2020 and 1933 Ukraine. Important. I’ve recommended this to several MG readers already. I liked the writing advice tucked slyly onto the pages. We have to get our elders’ stories down before they go with them.

Amazing story and so timely.

This book is set in three locations, 1930s Russia, 1930s USA and 2020 USA.

In 2020 Matthew is stuck at home during the pandemic and ends up spending time with his great-grandmother who grew up in Russia. The readers joins Matthew in learning the story of his great grandmother's time in 1930s Russia. It is not a happy story and reminded me of Ruta Sepety's book BETWEEN SHADES OF GRAY as I discovered another covered up time in Russian history that I hadn't known about. Millions in Ukraine died of starvation because their government caused a preventable famine in an effort to control the people. The irony of the current war in the Ukraine is not lost on me and the author mentions it in the author's note at the end of the book.

While his great-grandmother is struggling with life in Russia her family in the USA is working to get her out. All three stories come together with a satisfying ending. It is important to know this history, despite it being such a dark time.

2023 Popsugar reading challenge #A book about a family