Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.03 AVERAGE
4.03 AVERAGE
Probably 3.5 stars. I didn't like this one as much as the first or even the second, probably because Angelini definitely tried to increase the scope of the series in this novel, and I felt like it was only partially successful.
I did like that she didn't bother trying to redeem either Lillian or Carrick because I don't think it could have been done, but it definitely could have been attempted. Even as it was, it was somewhat hard to reorder this world with regards to the Woven, and there's no real resolution about what will happen afterwards with any of the characters, which I would have appreciated. Still, overall, this gave a sense of completion to Lily's arc and the issues in the Witch world, which was appreciated.
I did like that she didn't bother trying to redeem either Lillian or Carrick because I don't think it could have been done, but it definitely could have been attempted. Even as it was, it was somewhat hard to reorder this world with regards to the Woven, and there's no real resolution about what will happen afterwards with any of the characters, which I would have appreciated. Still, overall, this gave a sense of completion to Lily's arc and the issues in the Witch world, which was appreciated.
adventurous
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
adventurous
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Almost took a star off but then I realized my inability to take time out of my day to finish the book speedily and in a large chunk is what effected my experience with the end.
Lily was fierce in this, she’s no mere war-monger witch, she’s a dang war-queen witch.
Lillian’s departure was a little disappointing but she disappoints a lot of people so what can you expect.
I really wanna draw fanart of Lily and Rowan, especially in Lily’s pyre outfit and accessories
Lily was fierce in this, she’s no mere war-monger witch, she’s a dang war-queen witch.
Lillian’s departure was a little disappointing but she disappoints a lot of people so what can you expect.
I really wanna draw fanart of Lily and Rowan, especially in Lily’s pyre outfit and accessories
4.5
Definitivamente una gran conclusión a una gran trilogía de fantasía. Debo admitir que se volvió un poco lenta towards the end pero en general me encantó.
Esta trilogía tiene un turn interesante en como funciona la magia y las "brujas", razón por la cual definitivamente la recomiendo, sobre todo si quieren leer algo diferente.
Sigo pensando que la historia de amor de este libro y como describen todo es THE CUTEST.
Lastimosamente sentí que el final tenía que explicar más, quedé queriendo saber el futuro de los personajes y blah blah (me encantaría aunque sea una mini novela sobre eso <3)
En fin, muy recomendado.
Definitivamente una gran conclusión a una gran trilogía de fantasía. Debo admitir que se volvió un poco lenta towards the end pero en general me encantó.
Esta trilogía tiene un turn interesante en como funciona la magia y las "brujas", razón por la cual definitivamente la recomiendo, sobre todo si quieren leer algo diferente.
Sigo pensando que la historia de amor de este libro y como describen todo es THE CUTEST.
Lastimosamente sentí que el final tenía que explicar más, quedé queriendo saber el futuro de los personajes y blah blah (me encantaría aunque sea una mini novela sobre eso <3)
En fin, muy recomendado.
This one was definitely my favorite. The ending was just perfect, actually it wasn't because it left me wanting more, would love to read more about what happened after the epilogue.
Emotional ending but it made sense and didn't feel rushed.
SPOILER
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
And the way Grace died??? Almost made me laugh, it was the best death.
Emotional ending but it made sense and didn't feel rushed.
SPOILER
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
And the way Grace died??? Almost made me laugh, it was the best death.
I’ll give you everything I am. Everything but one part—the worst of me. That I’ll take with me to my grave.
After a bit of thought, I decided to write a single review for the entire trilogy, because, ironically, I can't seem to write a proper review when I truly loved a book.
Isn't that frustrating???
Anyway...
It's been a long time since I last read an entire series back to back, in a matter of days. I started Trial By Fire almost by chance, because I didn't know what to read next so I let my tbr shelf pick for me. I really didn't have any expectations for it, especially because I usually end up getting disappointed by a YA book that came out many years ago.
Boy was I surprised when I found out this wasn't the case.
It got me immediately and after I started, I couldn't stop reading. Lily is an incredible main character. She's probably became my favorite of the whole YA heroine scenario. yes, she's nothing but flawless, but she's also very passionate, selfless and charitable, which, in my book means the pros outweigh the cons.
I'm a very calm and patient person in real life and I'm used to keeping a cool head in front of adversities so I really related to the way she handled problems and was (mostly) reasonable most of the time.
I also couldn't have asked for better side characters even if I wanted to. I loved how easily (and a bit unrealistically) the whole gang came together and how easily people accepted the new reality they were thrown into (also a bit unrealistic but who really cares at this point).
The romance is heart-wrenching and , although it plays a big role in the story, it's never overwhelming. I appreciated the fact that Rowan and Lily were not one of those fictional couples that keep their positive or negative feelings for themselves creating useless drama and unecessary angst. Even the "love triangle" (love square?) thing is played out in the best way.
I read Angelini's Starcossed series a while ago and I remember liking it a lot, but the part I really loved was how friendship and family dynamics were shaped and it only got better with the Worldwalker trilogy.
I'll never get over how good of a team Lily and her friends were.
Also, Rowan, Caleb and Tristan slaying bad guys was the hottest thing ever.
Anyway, while the characters were some of the best I've ever read in a book of this genre, it's the plot that really sold this entire series for me. It's extraordinarily crafted, easily understandable, well written, full of shocking moments that make your heart run wild, and with an original magic system that made me wish this particular crucible witches, their mechanics and the whole stone business appeared in more books about witches and magic in general.
Can you believe it took me 6 years to find my new favorite trilogy??
ACTUAL RATINGS 50000000/5
This wasn't a bad book book, but I didn't enjoy nearly as much as the first two books of the trilogy. I found Lily to be annoying in many ways and so removed from her behaviors in the previous books. For a finale, not much happened. On a positive note, I loved the epilogue and my adoration for Rowan is firmly intact.
Overall - a decent trilogy but won't go down as a favorite either.
Overall - a decent trilogy but won't go down as a favorite either.
I don't want to it end. I love the characters and their struggle. I hope later on down the road we get a glimpse of them again.