Scan barcode
bookwyrm76's review against another edition
3.0
The False Prince disappointed me in some ways. I liked the main character and really enjoyed reading the book in his voice, BUT there was a disconnect somewhere. His voice and the level of the writting seemed to work well together, but the level of violence and some elements of the plot seemed to be aimed at an older reader. I would put the writting at a level which I would give a 9 to 12 yr old, but the level of violence and the character's reaction to that violence bumps it up to something I would give more to the 13+ crowd.
This isn't a huge problem, other than the fact tha I think many of those readers will desert the book thinking it is 'too easy' or predictable without giving it a fair chance.
If you have a reader in your life who likes adventures, isn't turned off by some pretty cold violence, and could use an easy read. This would be the book for them.
I hope that Nielsen continues to write, because even with the issues I had with the book, I want to know what happens to Sage.
This isn't a huge problem, other than the fact tha I think many of those readers will desert the book thinking it is 'too easy' or predictable without giving it a fair chance.
If you have a reader in your life who likes adventures, isn't turned off by some pretty cold violence, and could use an easy read. This would be the book for them.
I hope that Nielsen continues to write, because even with the issues I had with the book, I want to know what happens to Sage.
barciko's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
lzyc22's review against another edition
Didn't love the writing style. Plot is old and predictable.
floe's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.5
eesh25's review against another edition
4.0
4.25 Stars
I picked this book up because I really wanted to listen to an audiobook, and this was the only one in my local library that was also on my TBR list. I knew what it was about, of course, but I somehow missed that it was middle-grade. So when I started it, I thought to myself that it seemed a bit young for a YA novel. The protagonist, Sage, is fifteen, so it could've gone either way. But my point is, I like that the book can sound like its genre. Something that I've had an issue with in a few other novels.
The plot is that Sage, a boy who lives in an orphanage, is taken/bought by a man named Conner. Conner's been around many orphanages looking for boys of fifteen who are similar in appearance. None of the boys know why until Conner tells them that the royal family has been murdered, and one of the boys is to impersonate the long-lost prince and take the throne. Hence the name of the book.
There are several important characters in the book, and I loved how the author handled them and the direction she took them. But I don't want to spoil any of the fun stuff so I'll just say a few things about Sage and move on. Because I have to mention Sage. Not only is he the protagonist, but he's also a very interesting character. There are quite a few contradictions in him that give him a layered personality. And as the book goes on, all the contradictions make sense. But they also open him up to much more growth.
The plot itself is fairly simple but engaging. There's a decent amount of world-building done because a large part of the plot is based on Carthya's relations with surrounding kingdoms, but also on the political situation in Carthya itself. And the book does a great job of not overcomplicating things, but also not talking down to its readers.
There was a part around two-thirds of the way in, or maybe a little later, that could've gone badly. But the author handled it well. I can't say more than that. But I think it was something that could easily have been very disappointing. Instead, it made the book better, just like the ending did. And I'm eager to see where the series is headed. There was an interview with the author at the end in which she said that things were only going to get more challenging, and I can't wait to see how.
One last thing, the audiobook... I don't have much to say. There was nothing bad about it, but also nothing notably great. It neither added to nor took from the story. The narrator did a perfectly fine job. And this is the one case in which I can say, for sure, that the medium I chose for the book did not affect my opinion of it.
Overall, this was a great read, and I would recommend checking it out.
I picked this book up because I really wanted to listen to an audiobook, and this was the only one in my local library that was also on my TBR list. I knew what it was about, of course, but I somehow missed that it was middle-grade. So when I started it, I thought to myself that it seemed a bit young for a YA novel. The protagonist, Sage, is fifteen, so it could've gone either way. But my point is, I like that the book can sound like its genre. Something that I've had an issue with in a few other novels.
The plot is that Sage, a boy who lives in an orphanage, is taken/bought by a man named Conner. Conner's been around many orphanages looking for boys of fifteen who are similar in appearance. None of the boys know why until Conner tells them that the royal family has been murdered, and one of the boys is to impersonate the long-lost prince and take the throne. Hence the name of the book.
There are several important characters in the book, and I loved how the author handled them and the direction she took them. But I don't want to spoil any of the fun stuff so I'll just say a few things about Sage and move on. Because I have to mention Sage. Not only is he the protagonist, but he's also a very interesting character. There are quite a few contradictions in him that give him a layered personality. And as the book goes on, all the contradictions make sense. But they also open him up to much more growth.
The plot itself is fairly simple but engaging. There's a decent amount of world-building done because a large part of the plot is based on Carthya's relations with surrounding kingdoms, but also on the political situation in Carthya itself. And the book does a great job of not overcomplicating things, but also not talking down to its readers.
There was a part around two-thirds of the way in, or maybe a little later, that could've gone badly. But the author handled it well. I can't say more than that. But I think it was something that could easily have been very disappointing. Instead, it made the book better, just like the ending did. And I'm eager to see where the series is headed. There was an interview with the author at the end in which she said that things were only going to get more challenging, and I can't wait to see how.
One last thing, the audiobook... I don't have much to say. There was nothing bad about it, but also nothing notably great. It neither added to nor took from the story. The narrator did a perfectly fine job. And this is the one case in which I can say, for sure, that the medium I chose for the book did not affect my opinion of it.
Overall, this was a great read, and I would recommend checking it out.
ellexem's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? N/A
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
enteka's review against another edition
4.0
reading a few books i read as a kid. this is pretty nice, actually. i love sage.
sumayyaha's review against another edition
5.0
I had very high expectations for this book and I can proudly say it SURPASSED them all! Jennifer's writing is amazing, it flows through your mind so smoothly. I did not expect Sage to be so lovable. I thought the twists in this book were unexpected at best. And you will not be disappointed when you put this book down, and you could probably read it in one sitting. I didn't but if I had the time I totally would've. I can't stop blabbering about this book I will literally tell everyone to read it. I look forward to reading the next one.
ria_ray's review against another edition
5.0
An amazing book. Although I do have to say I predicted the twist very early on, I told my friend “I beilieve that Sage is truely Prince Jaron.” I am glad to say I was right at the ending of this book. Sage kept so many secrets hidden from the reader, I commend the author for that, beautiful writing. I am going to start the next book immediately!
bookph1le's review against another edition
4.0
I liked this book a lot. I've read a bunch of disappointing YA fantasy this year, so I was happy to read something well done. Though I thought the setting was good, the characters are what really make this book. More complete review to come.