Scan barcode
meggan's review against another edition
3.0
The plot of this installment of the Pellinor series was... weird. I feel like it didn't advance the story nearly as much as it could have. I will definitely read the next one to see what happens!
chasmofbooks's review against another edition
4.0
VERY good. Alison Croggon did a great job continuing the story.
kylie_annh's review against another edition
3.0
This is probably my least favorite book in the series--I want less time traveling/describing the landscape and more time in Arkan-da with the Winterking. I think thirty pages is not enough time for Maerad to develop the feelings she has. The pacing here is pretty funky.
That being said, Cadvan's "death" and their reunion at the end are beautiful and absolutely make this book. I think the heart of these books is their relationship, and even though I've read these before and know Cadvan is alive, it still hurts to read Maerad's grief for him.
That being said, Cadvan's "death" and their reunion at the end are beautiful and absolutely make this book. I think the heart of these books is their relationship, and even though I've read these before and know Cadvan is alive, it still hurts to read Maerad's grief for him.
More...