Reviews

Jack and Yani Love Harry Potter by Mary E. Twomey

brianne_k's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I don't know if it is because I am a cynic or something, but I found this too sweet and too cheesy for my liking. I liked the tour of locations from her favourite books though.. that would be awesome.

thepeachmartini's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

delightfully sweet!

Read it in a day, which doesn't happen often! Characters are great, story is fun, and the romance is PERFECT! Perfect read for Valentines Day weekend.

Full Review here - http://www.thepeachmartini.com/?p=674

ellelainey's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Would I read it again - Yes
Plot - Excellent
Characters - Lovable, fun, full of quirks and very realistic.
Movie Potential - ★★★★★
Ease of reading - Simple, yet very well written. Very enjoyable.

Recommend to - Twilight and Harry Potter fans, fans of romance, fans of sci-fi, fans of blogging and candy. If you like a good romance, or if you just want to go along on Yani’s book tour with her, give it a read.

Jack and Yani love Harry Potter is one of those books that I found completely by accident, but which has turned out to be a new favourite read of mine. It will definitely have a place on my January Blog about the best books I’ve read in 2013.

This is one of those books that I wish I had written. I had me hooked from word one, and I literally only put it down because I was starving and needed to eat. Once I picked it up again, it didn’t get dropped until I was finished. That’s how good this story is. I laughed out loud, felt the anguish and wanted to do some slapping and hugging of my own, throughout the story.

Yani and Jack’s friends remind me of my own when I was a teenager. We would so stupid stuff like ‘the slapping’ scene and then find one of us was going to get into trouble for it later. I love how the relationship between Jack and Yani, however, is such an unspoken secret between everyone. Yani loves Jack and Jack loves Yani. Everyone knows it, but no-one admits it, until Jack’s best friend Nate steps in to take action.

Jack works at a technical support call centre, and reads ‘real’ literature quotes poetry while Yani reads fantasy, science fiction novels and is obsessed with Harry Potter and Twilight. Sadly, this is the only obstacle between them. Together they write a blog about candy bars, which really reflect their feelings at the time of writing. I think the best part about this book, is the way that it combines Jack’s serious reading list, with Yani’s whimsical one. She’s just turned thirty, but she’s still a big kid and she likes that. But she also knows that her friends, and especially Jack, don’t understand that side of her.

By the time Jack throws her a surprise birthday party, Yani can’t take much more of the missed moments between her and Jack. She believes that he doesn’t feel anything for her, so she leaves a note pinned to his door, to say that she’s gone off on a book tour, to visit all the places where her favourite books and films took place…oh, and that she hopes it will help her stop being in love with him. Which is exactly how he finds out how she feels. She begins at Forks and makes her way around the places she’s so longed to go.

Meanwhile, Jack is depressed about her note, her escape and the ‘cowardly’ way she told him she loved him. Until his best friend Nate comes to the rescue. He shows up and demands that, as friends, they all go on a road trip to find Yani, so that Jack can profess his love for her. Jack is, at first, unwillingly dragged alone until, the more times they just miss her, the more he realises that he can’t be without her.

Some very interesting characters make appearances on their journey and for the Twi-hard and Hogwartians out there, they will absolutely love Yani’s and Jack’s venture into the Comic Con. It’s worth reading the whole book just to get to that part ;)

What really makes me love this book, is not only the utter romance of Jack going everywhere he thinks Yani will go, in order to find her and profess his love, not only the best friend bromance between Jack and Nate that makes Nate such a good friend to suggest the road trip, but the fact that everyone of the characters begins to understand Yani better through the trip.

With only one friend of the group married, with a baby, the wife Kelly has to stay at home with the baby, Hannah, so her two best friends stay with her too, and two boys, who can’t get the time off work. In their own way, they take the same road trip as Yani and Jack do, separated from their friends by miles, but coming closer with each day the road trip goes on. They all realise, Jack’s friends on the road trip and Kelly and her friends at home, that they’re never really been fair to Yani. They’ve treated her fantasy book and movie obsession like something they had to suffer, not realising how much she has to hide her true feelings and joys to keep them happy. The girls decide to take the road trip too, watching all Twilight movies and five of the Harry Potter films that they refused to let Yani make them sit through.

Meanwhile, on the road trip, Nate’s come up with the brilliant idea of the whole gang listening to the audio books of the Twilight and Harry Potter series. To their own surprise, each and every one of them finds themselves sucked into the stories and realising why Yani loves them so much. That still doesn’t help them when they come to the Comic Con, though, and have no idea why they have to dress up in Team Jacob t-shirts. Possibly one of the funniest moments in the whole book is when they go into the Comic Con, but it’s also very sweet, that they’re even willing, by this time, to enter such a place in search for their friend, and the love of Jack’s life.

Highly Recommend

moonwisher's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I'm so glad I finally got around to reading this book, as I've been wanting to since I read about it on MuggleNet -- yes, I'm THAT nerd. And I absolutely adored it. As a Harry Potter fangirl (not so much a Twilight one), I found myself squealing and giggling and feeling-all-the-feels when reading Jack and Yani. It also made me realize how important it is that my someday-husband loves Harry Potter. Serioiusly. It's really important.

Overall I can see how, objectively speaking, this book could be deemed average. And I think that yes, the book wasn't meant to be all that "meaningful" and the writing was certainly clumsy-ish in some places. But what it lacks stylistically, it makes up for in heart. I don't even really know how to fully describe it, other than to say that if you're the type to fangirl -- or fanboy -- over anything, Twomey has written the perfect light read for you.

Random note: Big Carl (the man himself or anything that has to do with him) is more fantastic than I can say in words.

mamabookwyrm's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Cute and funny

As a girl who belongs to a lot of fandoms, I can certainly relate to Yani. This book was super sweet, had tons of cute and humorous moments and zero angst. It was just what I needed to get out of a depression induced book rut.

madetofly's review

Go to review page

5.0

This book is absolutely perfect for anyone who loves to read young adult books, especially if you happen to be older than the young adult target demographic. Yani turns thirty in the book, and all of her friends give her a hard time for liking young adult literature. One of my absolute favorite aspects of the book was how her friends learn to respect the books Yani loves. I know that I've been teased for things I like in the past, so I loved seeing them finally give these books a chance and discover why Yani loves them so much.

Read the rest of the review here:
http://hmweasley-blog.blogspot.com/2013/03/book-review-jack-and-yani-love-harry.html

cozykrysti's review

Go to review page

4.0

Attention all bookworms and potter nerds! Attention! We interrupt the planned book list to tell you about a new book that we just had to read. It's called Jack and Yani Love Harry Potter! If the title alone isn't enough to get you to read it, let me tell you a bit more about it.

Jack and Yani are the best of friends and avid readers. But Jack loves classic literature while Yani loves books of the Harry Potter, Twilight, Interview with a Vampire variety. The two are also secretly in love with one another, but when Yani believes her feelings to be unrequited, she takes herself on the bookish adventure of a lifetime! She goes to visit the locations of some of her favorite books: Forks and New Orleans. She also visits Harry Potter Land in Orlando and Comic Con in San Diego. Jack chases after her to tell her about how he really feels, but will he be able to get to her in time?

The book is fun and funny with a group of friends that you can't help but wish you were a part of and a bit of *sigh* romance to boot! It's also a super quick read, so please, drop whatever it is your doing/reading, and go pick this one up!

charlottejones952's review

Go to review page

4.0

I found this to be a really sweet contemporary read with just enough romance and geekiness. If you're a fan of Harry Potter or Twilight, this is a good read for you as has a lot of references to the fandoms.

krystimuggle's review

Go to review page

4.0

Attention all bookworms and potter nerds! Attention! We interrupt the planned book list to tell you about a new book that we just had to read. It's called Jack and Yani Love Harry Potter! If the title alone isn't enough to get you to read it, let me tell you a bit more about it.

Jack and Yani are the best of friends and avid readers. But Jack loves classic literature while Yani loves books of the Harry Potter, Twilight, Interview with a Vampire variety. The two are also secretly in love with one another, but when Yani believes her feelings to be unrequited, she takes herself on the bookish adventure of a lifetime! She goes to visit the locations of some of her favorite books: Forks and New Orleans. She also visits Harry Potter Land in Orlando and Comic Con in San Diego. Jack chases after her to tell her about how he really feels, but will he be able to get to her in time?

The book is fun and funny with a group of friends that you can't help but wish you were a part of and a bit of *sigh* romance to boot! It's also a super quick read, so please, drop whatever it is your doing/reading, and go pick this one up!

thepeachmartini's review

Go to review page

5.0

delightfully sweet!

Read it in a day, which doesn't happen often! Characters are great, story is fun, and the romance is PERFECT! Perfect read for Valentines Day weekend.

Full Review here - http://www.thepeachmartini.com/?p=674