17k reviews for:

Milk and Honey

Rupi Kaur

3.7 AVERAGE

emotional fast-paced

{Edited}

too pretentious
felt like ive already seen some stuff somewhere else

I felt bad not liking it. There were some good lines in there but a lot of it felt more like quotes people post on social media without going any deeper than that. Perhaps the style is just not for me.
emotional hopeful informative lighthearted reflective tense fast-paced

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
challenging dark emotional reflective sad tense fast-paced

Concise and heartfelt.
I especially loved the section called The Healing

unsure

in the beginning i was underwhelmed but the more i read the more poems i liked

I like poetry. I believe this series of poems depicted some powerful and intriguing emotions, but I feel deeply unsatisfied.
If it was meant to be written to expose the author's inner most feelings, unaltered, the unique style makes sense, but it cannot explain the shortness of the lines and their surface level of coverage of the topic. Otherwise, if the poems were altered through the prism of ration and society's rules, the format is again faulty, due to the lack of deeper meaning of the words.
All in all, great subject, but a more detailed coverage of it or a deeper meaning of the verses would have made it more enjoyable.
emotional sad fast-paced

What a quaint read. I didn't particularly like the poetry collection, and would struggle to pick out any individual poem I enjoyed either. But this was a time capsule that launched be back a decade. I wasn't old enough and am not currently researched enough to say whether Kaur was a product of the time or influenced the coming generation, but with all things I think it was both.
In this book I saw countless Tumblr blogs and Insta spam accounts. I remembered so many of the girls I was friends with through my youth. I remember the reality-altering intoxication of that first big love. I just wish I had seen better poetry.
Most of the book read like a collection of self-help mantras passed from therapist to client. I wish it had been more advice from the older to younger sister. 
I know the feeling of having my life ruined by heartache. Kaur tells me she knows, too. So where was it in the poetry? When well over half the poems are sentences broken into stanzas, the impact of a sparse verse is lessened. Make me feel how sickeningly sweet the love was and how great the chasm of your broken self is in its wake!
I'll go through more Kaur in the coming days/weeks, but I don't except my outlook to change. Which is a bummer, because that will impact my reading of her books. 
All in all I think it's cool that this young person released something that spoke to so many. That's more than I've ever done, and will likely ever do. Maybe it's just another collection that isn't for me.
I also enjoyed the drawings.