3.75 AVERAGE


According to Byung-Chul Han, control is no longer exercised through negative power, wherein a disciplinary society prohibits certain actions or behaviours. Instead, people are now shaped by another controlling force; themselves. Western neo-liberal society is now an “achievement society” where self-optimisation determines our actions. Now, owing to the totality of capital, struggle no longer occurs between the in-group and the out-group, but against oneself. We are now free from the constraints of negative societies, which tell us not to do things, but now we are trapped in a positive society that tells us that we can achieve anything, if only we labour enough. We are achievement-subjects, compelled to maximise ourselves, auto-exploiting ourselves until we burnout. 

I like how Byung-Chul Han characterises depression, as following “from overexcited, overdriven, excessive self-reference that has assumed destructive traits... Entirely incapable of stepping outward, of standing outside itself... It wears out in a race it runs against itself”. 

slow-paced

Tbh puede ser que esté siendo dura con el libro.

No sé si fue el formato (audio), la narración (español ibérico), o la traducción que no terminó de encantarme. Algunos términos que utiliza en lo personal no me gustan, y otros no siento que fueran manejados como lo haría desde la psicología occidental.

Más allá de eso, la idea general es interesante y su propuesta me hace sentido (mayormente).

No creo que intente ser, a fin de cuentas, una explicación científica. Sólo un ensayo filosófico.
challenging informative reflective

We find ourselves subject to achievement, an epochal shift from the society of discipline familiar to any reader of Foucault - or most people, in fact. The consequences: the distresses and derangements of positivism, self exploitation, and social atomization.

Does the shoe fit? Too well. Too, too well.

On a minor note, I quite enjoy that Han frequently takes pains to point out how other philosophers are wrong. It's a petty habit that becomes quite the stylistic tic.
reflective fast-paced
informative inspiring reflective
challenging informative reflective slow-paced

disclaimer: non studio filosofia sono una becera matematica. l ho trovato interessante dal pov contenutistico (societa prestazionale vs societa disciplinare + multitasking + origine depressione) ma violentemente frustrante da capire nella forma. tutti i concetti sono spiegati 0 volte e ripetuti 100. pbabilmente non è un testo pensato x essere interpretato da me che non so niente. per es il paradigma immunologico non e spiegato eppure e venduto come concetto fondalmentale sul quale la societa pre prestazionale e definita. non sono d accordo sulle conclusioni su antidepressivi e sacralità del corpo, per il resto sono abb d accordo. consiglio a chi e del mestiere/abbia voglia di riscrivere un testo x poterlo interpretare.
challenging informative mysterious medium-paced
informative fast-paced